US Boat and Ship Modeler : 4th Quarter 1990

  • Title. Author. Summary
_ WINTER 1990 © $3.95 CANADA $4.95 0 BY ROD CARR MARBLEHEAD DEVELOPMENT f this is your first issue of USBSM, and you find the contents of this column of interest, contact the editor for the previous issue, where this discussion of the Marblehead Class started. The following comments from Bob Sterne should be taken with more than the usual attention paid. Shortly after writing this, Mr. Sterne put the “state of the art” boat in the water for its first competition in the Pacific Northwest’s NORC I regional regatta. It worked just like he predicted it would and left some pretty solid competition over the horizon by taking eight firsts, five seconds and a lone third place to wax the fleet. Listen up folks! STERNE, 1990 Bob Sterne has continued his line of development which began with the “Kisutch” design that won the World Championship in 1980. His exploration of the performance envelope has culminated in recent designs of the “Logic” (1985 AMYA ACCR winner), “Fusion” and “Monocat” families. His experimentation with fins in the 16 to 19-inch region, as well as his controlled development of hull forms, has provided a series of hulls/fin/bulb combinations that cover the range of conditions that skippers are likely to encounter. Displacements ranging from 10+ pounds to 13 are covered by the variants, each with its own strengths and ability to fit certain wind and wave conditions. For specific details, Bob can be reached at 3785 Edinburgh Street, Burnaby, B.C. V5C 1R4, Canada. He has been kind enough to provide us with some insightful commentary on the M-class design proc- ess which I am very proud to be able to include in its entirety. “Let me start by telling you what I did in 1985 after reading Stollery’s article in Model Yachting News. I took his data, added my own regarding North American Designs, and predicted that by 1986 the Marblehead winning design would have 7.5 pounds of lead on a 16-inch fin blade, 28 WINTER 1990 the ballast shrinks, this ratio must INCREASE, to possibly 75% for good allaround performance. Certainly, it must not decrease. Iam quite alarmed by the current American trend toward light yachts by the simple measure of taking off lead. While this can produce yachts that are very fast in some conditions, it has been my experience, and apparently also Stollery’s, that the yachts so configured are not good all around. “Another thing we agree upon is that there is a certain minimum stability required for a good all around Marblehead. There are several ways of approximating this, but the proper way is to find the vertical CG, measure its distance from the vertical CB, and multiply the distance by the total displacement of the yacht to give the righting moment. Then you must take into account the additional heeling force caused by a deeper fin, by measuring the heeling arm from the vertical CLR to the vertical CE of the rig. However, this may be simplified by saying that for every two inches Bob Sterne’s new lightweight ‘M’ at 8 Ibs., 13 0z., with maximum height swing rig and carbon fiber mast. All photos by Rod Carr. on a 10.5 lb. boat, i.e., a ballast ratio of over 70%. We won the United States Annual Class Championship Regatta (ACCR) that year with ‘Logic,’ with just those specifications. The extrapolation continued, predicted that by 1989 the M would progress to an 18inch fin with seven pounds of lead, on a yacht weighing about 9.5 pounds. My “Orbit, the 1989 winner, was built to those criteria. Continuing, the next step would be 6.5 lbs. oflead, ona 20-inch blade with a total weight of about 8.75 pounds, probably in 1992. “One thing that Stollery andI agree on is that all really successful Marblehead designs must have a ballast ratio of at least 70%. I think that as additional keel depth, you can take off about 1/2 lb. of ballast. Combinations that have worked in North America have been 8-1/2 lbs. on a 12inch blade, 8 lbs. on a 14-inch blade, 7-1/2 lbs. on a 16, and 7 lbs. on an 18. Remember that I am talking about ALL AROUND performance. Yachts have been built with, for example 7 lbs. on a 12-inch, 6-1/2 lbs. on a 16inch, and work, but are more specialized for lighter conditions. In England, it would be common to have 1/ 2 to one lb. more ballast than in North America. As it is my desire as a designer to produce yachts capable of winning ANYWHERE, I refuse to produce specialized yachts. “In general terms, shallower keels are faster in light winds, and deeper keels faster in heavy conditions, even if they have identical wetted surface and frontal area. This may be a Reynolds number effect, or it may be that a longer leading edge has more drag, I don’t know. However, I am convinced that this is true. I feel that this is one of the reasons that devel- opment takes so long, and is tied to the pace of available technology. Otherwise, we could simply take a 1980 vintage yacht that weighed 12 pounds, 8 being lead, and simply fit an 18-inch fin with 7 lbs. of lead and have a winner. Instead, one finds that when you do this, the 11 lb. yacht produced is VERY slow in light winds. It takes asubstantial increase in technology, and the associated displacement, to get back the loss in performance the deeper keel produces. “What I am trying to say, is that we are constantly fighting a battle to produce ever lighter, deeper keels, and not lose any light air performance in the process, while gaining performance in the moderate wind range. The ballast ratio is of course also very important in heavier winds, comments from 1985 that in general, light yachts are superior in heavy winds. They tend to be not quite as fast to weather, but their far superior downwind speed far outweighs this. As I believe that in general, the hull should be as small as possible to support the required displacement, and as the originator of narrow round section hulls, I obviously would predict and believe that narrow hulls are better in heavy wind and wave conditions. I feel that the “Monocat’ (5″ WL beam, 6″ at deck) is the fastest hull I have in heavy winds. Unfortunately, any hull that narrow pays aterrible price in form stability, and can never achieve the same displacement as a more conventional hull of similar stability. Conversely, at equal displacement, stability would suffer, asinthe ORCO ‘Skinny’ yachts by Swede Johnson. “Swede tries to get back the stabil- ity he loses by using a shorter rig. In my opinion, this is limited to certain wind conditions, although in those it works very well. I feel that in the two to six mph range, the availability ofa maximum height (i.e. 80” luff) rig is a REQUIREMENT for the best performance in the M Class. As with the type of stability I design into my boats, in which each rig is good for about a 10 mph range of winds, I recommend 80, 70 and 60-inch rigs covering 0-10 mph, 8-18 mph, and 15-25 mph. Beyond that, storm rigs are necessary. (Top right) “UNA” Swing-rig used for moderate air sailing. Note narrow beam of hull and deep fin. (Top left) Standard swing rig requires substantial mast bend to accommodate big luff round in mainsail. Jib has no club, using a sliding traveler. (Above) Swing rig produces an extremely clean installation; one sheet exit guide, and can be changed to another rig in 10 seconds! decrease in non-ballast weight, to enable a yacht to be produced with a 70% minimum ballast ratio, and therefore the required under 10 lb. not only for power to windward, but also for planing performance on the reaches. : “T would tend to support Stollery’s “From what I have been saying, you can see that I do not believe that one should build a specialized yacht for certain conditions. A properly built Marblehead, with a minimum 70% ballast ratio and sufficient stability, utilizing state of the art technology, can be made to be competitive in all conditions. Sure, you can build a boat aimed at a particular condition, but what are you going to do when conditions don’t suit you? The answer, all too frequently, is place poorly and complain about the conditions. I am afraid that I don’t have much sympathy for that approach. “On the subject of fin area, I think that this is tied to the thickness of the section used, and also to the conditions encountered. I have seen and sailed yachts with fins from 30 square inches to 64 square inches, and everywhere in between. In general, yachts with too small a fin will exhibit too much leeway in both drifter conditions, and in overpressed conditions (i.e. at the top end ofarig’s effective wind range). In the first case, itis a simple lack of area, andin the latter it is a matter of too much US BOAT & SHIP MODELER 29 ‘loading’ requiring a very high angle of attack to maintain a course to windward. As the maximum lift in a symmetrical foil occurs when the thickness is about 12%, a foil of this thickness can be smaller than a thinner or thicker one. As drag is roughly proportional to thickness, however, a thinner foil will generally have a better lift-to-drag ratio, and hence better performance to windward, providing that the loading per square inch is not so high that it operates outside of its low drag zone. This is why thinner foils have become so popular in recent years. However, in some of my testing, I have noticed that, indeed, thinner foils need more area in heavy winds or they will exhibit the predicted increase in leeway. For example, I have noticed that at this time you could give the nod to either rig, all around. “Proponents of swing rigs have left out an important bit of information from their propaganda. The rigs cause noticeably more downforce when running than the conventional rig, and if the jib boom ever digs into the water, they become uncontrollable very quickly. This is why most of the top European boats revert to conventional rigs for their B and C suits. I am currently experimenting with a balanced Una-rig for the same reasons. Una-rigs in full size are known for a lack of power in light winds, but conventional rig at these weights, although you could get fairly close. (Columnist’s Note: The new boat produced a first place finish in its maiden regatta in a fleet of 11 boats. Light to medium winds at 90 NORC I produced heat finishes of 3-1-1-2-22-2-1-1-1-1-1-2-1, for a net score of 6.8 pts. after two throwouts. Net score of the second place boat ‘was 27.8 pts. Mr. Sterne was kind enough to allow me to photograph the boat the day before the event, and the results are presented here for inspection.) “My commitment to the swing and Una-rigs on this yacht is not because increased leeway in heavy winds with a 6% foil of 48 square inches, and I have noticed the same with a 10% foil of 40 square inches. “It is apparent that fin design is a constant struggle between trying to get a thinner foil for low drag, with low wetted surface, versus sufficient area to prevent leeway in non-ideal conditions and of course the required mechanical strength to support the lead ballast properly without bending and twisting. Fin design is one area where Iam constantly working, because I feel that it is at least as important as the hull or the rig. Obviously, the same comments apply to the rudder except one also considers the need for power for maneuvering. “I would like to comment briefly on the swing rig, and also the Una-rig. Swing rigs are not new. They have seen, in their current reincarnation, considerable development, from stiff unstayed masts with tiny 200 square inchjibs, to offset pivot arrangements with conventional size jibs and currently a thin, bendy mast with, which is able to carry a 250 sq. inchjib. The earlier small jib rigs did not perform well to windward, hence all the playing around. I think that to windward, the BEST swing rigs are now competitive with a good conventional rig, and getting close to equal performance on a close reach. “It has been said that the swing rig is a rocket downwind and broad reaching, compared to the conventional rig. I have not seen this to be the case, with the exception of those runs where a conventional rig will not set ‘wing and wing.’ This can be eliminated to a large extent by proper balancing of the jib boom, using a large (25% jib offset) and a topping lift. Properly done, I really do not feel 30 WINTER 1990 for superior lift to drag in heavy conditions. I expect that more of these will be seen as B and C rigs in the Marblehead’s future. “You may find my latest personal boat interesting. I am sailing an ‘Orbit’ with a swing rig top suit, and a una-rig for my second suit. If the Una-rig works well enough, I will use another one for my C-suit. The yacht weighs 8 lb. 18 oz. ready to sail, and carries 6 lb. 10 oz. of lead (4 kg total, 3 kg lead). This gives a ballast ratio of 75%, and to the best of my knowledge is the first Marblehead to be completed at only one kg less ballast. There are only two channels of radio, and in fact the radio installation, including battery, (250 mAH) weighs only 7 ounces! The only thing I am currently lacking to complete my 1992 *winner’ is a suitable 20-inch fin. At the moment I am using an 18-inch one. I have pushed technology to the limit with this yacht, and at present, it could not be duplicated with a Ihave decided they are better. Rather, it is because I don’t want to rely on others opinions about their performance. I want to ‘see for myself.’ At present, I feel that the jury is out… in fact, maybe all the evidence hasn’t been presented yet! “In looking to the distant future, a further extrapolation of my chart would indicate a Marblehead with 6 Ibs. of lead, and 8 lbs. all up weight, with a 22-inch fin, to provide sufficient stability. It may well be that we may never be able to achieve this, as the increase in draft may use up more performance than can be gained with an 8 lb. boat. It is possible that a real breakthrough in materials for the fin might make this yacht possible, but I can’t see it happening soon. However, someone will build one before the turn of the century, I can almost guarantee it. Whether or not anyone can afford it is another issue. “Realistically, Isee a slowing down in Marblehead development, and more effort being made on rigs and details. Appendage design will also be important, while hulls will take a second seat. Ifthe swing rigs do catch on in North America, their biggest advantage will not be at the front of the fleet, but rather in the middle, where the ability to stay ‘tuned’ will help the skipper whose performance varies over a wide range due toa lack of tuning skills. The swing rig will improve his consistency by a considerable margin and this may be the swing rig’s greatest advantage.” ROGER STOLLERY, 1990 Referring back to Figure 1 (See the Fall ’90 issue), Roger points out that both 1986 and 1989 events were sailed in heavy air. M-class designs in the British Isles have to be a compromise to cope with a wider range of conditions than is apparently typical in either the U.S. or Germany, the two latter being known more for light air with correspondingly smoother water. Roger’s records show that over the last five years 85-inch rigs were used 66% of the time, 64-inch rigs for 17%, 53inch rigs for 13% and 40-inch rigs for the remaining 4%. The base is approximately 100 races over the period. The differences he notes when comparing the German boats to the English are: a) Generally half the freeboard in the bow sections; b) Much lighter overall; c) Much attention to reducing wetted surface by using semicircular hull forms. Based on experiments he has conducted with identical hulls, he feels that 19 inches is the best total draft for displacements in the range of 11 to 12 pounds. Optimal total displacement is related to what kind of wind and waves you typically sail in. The higher winds encountered in Eng- land seem to demand the 11 to 12 pound boat to deal effectively with the waves, ifthe boat is made lighter, windward ability drops off. His final comment was to ask me if Thad considered using the “Pocahontas” hull and equipping it with a modern fin and rig. His prediction was that if done properly we would all be surprised at how competitive it might be. While this comment is at odds with Roger’s earlier advice on taking a “systems” approach, it does show that plain old experimentation for the excitement of it is still alive and well in this high tech class. CURRENT TRENDS In discussions of the 1989 British Championships, we are beginning to see assessment of the style of sailing of the combatants. In fact, each US BOAT & SHIP MODELER 31 L.A.W. (LAND, AIR & WATER) RACING PRODUCTS MARINE PRODUCTS DIVISION Computer designed and machined products for the serious power boater. Exhaust Throttles, High Performance Heads and Velocity Stacks for over 25 different marine engines including outboard motors. Proven products that have captured several IMPBA records. Products that are simple to install, and do not require any engine configuration changes. Call or write today for a free brochure L.A.W. RACING PRODUCTS, 1229 Capitol Drive, Addison, IL 60101 — (708) 543-2030 of the combatants. In fact, each skipper’s approach to the business of getting around the course seems to finally be recognized as worthy of study, and it is intimated that there is substantial impact of the skipper as part of the sailing “system.” This is not really different than in the vane sailing days, when the skill of sail set and trim was often the deciding factor in victory. More Yachting News discussion of “top boats” has concluded that top competition has evolved away from the workshop putterer and his glue pot. Escalating costs and the busi- ness of buying a ready-to-run boat from a designer/builder were decried as somehow “un-corinthian.” It would appear to this author that there has been a basic change in the sport. In the olden days, it was almost demanded that each skipper design, then build, then sail his creation. To U.S. MODELER THE COMPLEAT MODEL NAUTICAL PERIODICAL! Ph: (714) 645-8830 i] The REAL how.to maga zine on all types of model boats and ships; R/C, steam, electric, sail, racing, sport, static and operational scale. Also construction articles on all types, with fullsize plans and patterns available, complete with reprint of building instructions. 34 WINTER 1990 | | | } H | | | {| | {| SUBSCRIBE NOW (Starts with next published issue). U.S. Only (includes APO and FPO): One year(4 issues) – $13.95 Two years(8 issues) -$26.75 Overseas(also Canada and Mexico): One year only-$23.00 includes postage & handling. Payment must be in U.S. funds, drawn on a Name US: Bank- Sig. Address City State Visa or M/C No. (Add 5%) Zip Exp. Date BACK ISSUES AVAILABLE – Limited supply. $4.00 per copy. U.S. add 50¢ per copy, outside U.S. add $1.50 per copy for shipping. U.S. BOAT & SHIP MODELER, 898 West 16th St., Newport Beach, CA 92663 do otherwise was somehow not “yachty.” With the advent of radio control, there crept in to the sport a new emphasis .. . the maneuvering of the boats under the guidance of the skipper with due regard for the racing rules. Racing became distinct from design, from construction, and now it is not even necessary to as- semble the boat yourself. Indeed, with the proliferation of high-tech materials, it may be impossible for the average modeler to build his own boat. Even as long ago as 1979, it was obvious that the BONE Syndicate had set itself on a course to deal with carbon fiber, computer programs and Kevlar. That new materials should be incorporated into formula class designs does seem to be a natural evolution. One of the interesting reactions to this rush into space age materials and technology is an unabashed return to the old days within the program promoted by Russell Potts British VINTAGE YACHT GROUP. Here, construction, and even restoration is considered a prime focus for the group activity. Classic designs are being reproduced or restored. Materials and procedures of past eras have been resurrected, as have construction techniques. In this approach, epoxy resins may continue to be suspect, provided there remains a source of horse hooves for glue. But there are those who decry the march of progress, seemingly asking that a formula class allowjust a little bit of development that anyone can take part in. The Orlando MYC Newsletter has joined the chorus by decrying a $2,700 Marblehead class boat sailed by one of its members. My question is whether the boat is winning anything. Performance requires a skipper worth more than $1.98 to get the best out of such a vehicle. For when it is all said and done, you can spend a lot of money, but it will not guarantee you a trophy. As if by osmosis, the Naples NYC Editor, Banny Sprague, a skipper of long association with our sport, recently provided the following comment on the evolution in the formula classes in the United States: “[m afraid that the open classes will die because of the use of synthetics and sophisticated processes introduced by the builders. The trend by the latter has been to develop products and processes that are exclusively theirs in their endeavor to corner this very small but competitive market. The outstanding example of this is Jon Elmaleh’s keel. I don’t blame Jon for this. Sure, an open class allows for the development of new ideas, but that development is the very ingredient that will likely kill the class. Let’s remember, these open classes began before synthetics and sophisticated building processes were even a gleam in someone’s eye. For example, the original thought behind the 50/800 was to give each modeler a simple rule to which to build a class model, NOT continued on page 46 Advice For Boat Modelers: Ram it! Because we are known for our airplane and car products, boat modelers sometimes forget that we have many items specifically designed for you or adaptable to your needs. Take a look at the list of AMERICAN MADE products and we’re sure you will see several that will be perfect for your boat model. @ SEE YOUR DEALER @ SEND STAMPED ENVELOPE FOR RAM INFO #REDO5 Marine Navigation Lights (3 lights, 9 volts) 19.95 #RED 27 Simple Throttle (2 speeds forward & reverse) 19.95 #RED 31 3 Way Simple Siren (3 distinct sounds) 19.95 #RED 37 Simple Servo Setter (auto. controls 1 servo) 19.95 #RED 38 Gas/Diesel Engine Sound & Horn, 4” Speaker 39.95 #RED 40 Gas/Diesel Engine Sound & Horn, 2” Speaker 39.95 #RED 41 34.95 Horn and Steam Whistle (adjustable tones) #RED 44 Boat Saver (bilge warning light) 14.95 #RED 45 Boat Saver w/Pump (6 to 12 volts) 24.95 29.95 If unavailable locally, send check, money order or full credit card info for the cost of #RED 46 Machine Gun Sound Module the item plus $2.00 ($5.00 foreign) for immediate shipment. Include full address for #RED 47 Programmable Semaphore U.P.S. Sorry no C.O.D. #RED 48 Steam Engine Sound, 4” Speaker CRAM RA Box 47236N. Milwaukee Ave. — Chicago, IL60630 $10.95 #RED 16 Econo Landing Lights (great for spotlights) Signal Lamp, 9 volts 29.95 39.95 Waterproof Radio Box (4 sizes) each 11.95 Electro Mate Astro25/K + B 3.5 Outboard Mating System 24.95 NEW SHIP DECKING & SCALE MODEL WOODS …in Basswood, for the true craftsman asin Northeastern’s handsome ship decking is authentic in appearance, 1001 easy to work with and really saves time! Available ITEMS… in .050 thick laminated sheets with 4 choices of spacing representing caulking between WU ay boards. Our extensive line of scale | SamMeAsTean model hardwoods are used by hobbyists and professional prototype modelmakers around the world. * Ship deckining in 3″ x 22” lengths with spacing in tVA,6”, So”, %e” and 36” » Carving blocks up to 24″ lengths .Belaying pins * Scale sheeting * Dowels */e,’to “a” * Double beads + Wood strips from .012 and up* Wood for mastheads, hatch covers, etc. * Mahogany, cherry and walnut also available in many items « Satisfaction guaranteed mem OF money back! ee 36 WINTER 1990 ORTHEASTERN SCALE MODELS INC. P.O, Box 727US Methuen, Mass, 01844 Tel. (508) 688-6019 See your local dealer or write today for our catalog and price list. Please send $1.00 to cover postage and handling. Refundable with first order. STRICTLY Continued from page 36 TO GIVE PROFESSIONAL BUILDERS AND DESIGNERS A FIELD DAY! Back then, with no fiberglass, or other synthetics, nor molds to “cookie cut” hulls, etc., it was almost impossible to produce duplicate hulls. One-designs weren’t practical. Every boat was just a mite different and there was no way to duplicate hulls like you can do today. What better way to generate interest than to say to interested brethren, ‘make ‘em no more than 50 inches long and use no more than 800 square inches of sail.’ So, you rolled your own and didn’t wind up spending the kid’s inheritance! Now, only the professional, and the rare amateur builder, can produce a competitive 50/800. New and faster designs and processes come out each year and yesterday’s winner becomes today’s turkey, which has no resale value, while the cost of the new boat goes spiraling up. “Today, one-design classes are not only practical, they are the least expensive way to go. In addition to offering a lower initial investment and protection of that investment on resale, the competition is between skippers, not boats, nor professional builders, nor designers, which is the way it should be. I know you 12meter guys have been striving to tighten up the slack in your specs and I congratulate all of you for this because it can only strengthen the class. Iapplaud John Amen for pushing the Infinity 54, a class that I personally hope will grow to be as popular and widespread as the 12s. Lastly, I have no quarrel with the professional designers, builders, and sailmakers who strive to outdo each other by producing a better product. What is happening seems to be exactly what happened in “people” boats and that ain’t all bad! Once the one design boats took hold, the open classes died, BUT INTEREST IN SMALL BOAT RACING EXPLODED! Would that we should experience the same with R/C models in the years to come.” The rapid evolution is proving to be a bad case of heartburn for the rule makers. If one tries to control a formula class by adding prohibitions to a rule, as soon as one thing is under control the explorations of the skippers and designers go off in another direction, soon to emerge like toothpaste from a punctured tube. The AMYA EC/12 seems about to be infected with swing rigs and vane controlled sail control units because the AMYA Rule for the EC/12 doesn’t prohibit them. I would predict that it will only be a year or two and swing rigs will make serious inroads into the AMYA 50/800 class too. It seems that there are really only two ways to write yachting rules in general. First, one can write a simple statement which controls size (like the M-Class rule) and then stand back and watch the class go where it will. Secondly, one can write a prescriptive rule in which virtually every meaningful aspect of the boat is described as to size, shape and material with the purpose of requiring the boats to be “as alike as reasonably possible.” There does not seem to be a very viable middle ground, for classes can get caught between trying to look and act like a simple, well meaning one-design, yet in fact are being pushed and prodded by the experimentations of the skippers as if it were an experimental class. The result of such mischief is a dissatis- fied class, a low or declining population and competition events which are little more than thinly veiled wars with gritting teeth and violent protests. A variant on the formula class rule is the recently proposed AMYA Cubic Meter Class. All the parts for the TAKE THE HOBBY SHOP HOME WITH YOU. THE 14th ANNUAL RADIO CONTROL BUYERS GUIDE is the only reference guide for all R/C hobbies. Browse through the guide, find the items you need, and you’ll know just what to ask for at your favorite hobby shop. The RADIO CONTROL BUYERS GUIDE lets you turn your wish list into a shopping list. By Knowing what’s available, you can plan new projects or improve existing projects, Price information also helps you add up just what your plans will cost. Look for the RADIO CONTROL BUYERS GUIDE at your local hobby shop. Or call 800-446-5489 (weekdays 8:30 – 5:00 CST) to order. The RADIO CONTROL BUYERS GUIDE supports the Academy of Model Aeronautics (AMA) by donating $1.00 for every copy of the guide you purchase. To authorize the donation to AMA, mail your hobby shop reciept and the coupon below to Kalmbach. Order direct by using the coupon or calling 800-446-5489, ® To order send to: Dept. 0198, RADIO CONTROL BUYERS GUIDE, e P.O. Box 1612, Waukesha, WI 53187-1612 YES! I’d like to order __ RADIO CONTROL BUYERS GUIDE(S) (#12092) for $ Q Payment enclosed O Charge my account Name. \ Street City, State, Zip Country. Charge to: Q Mastercard Card# Signature $9.95/#12092 WINTER 1990 UO American Express (min. $15) Exp. Date Include for postage and handling: U.S $1.50; Canadian and foreign add 15% (minimum $3.00). Make payment in U.S. funds. Wisconsin residents add 5% sales tax. Price subject to change: 46 OVisa Dept. 0198 entire boat had to fit into a box which was a one-meter cube, for the purposes of measurement. The parts could then be assembled into the boat that would go out onto the water and compete. A NEW APPROACH TO AN EXPERIMENTAL MODEL YACHT CLASS ? Rather than complain, let’s see if we can come up with a new version of a formula class rule. My idea comes from something I watched recently at my daughter’s school science fair, from the full-sized boat building contest that is sponsored by Sikaflex at the annual Wooden Boat Show here in Seattle, and by recurring contact with that giant of contests, the Cub Scout’s Pinewood Derby. Ninth graders participating in the science fair were each given a shopping bag full of the same amount of sticks, manila folders, and string. One was allowed to use as much glue of any kind as required. The goal was to build a bridge to span 22 inches, which would have weights piled on it to test its strength. The winning design supported in excess of 180 pounds of lead shot until it broke. At the Wooden Boat Show, a similar approach was taken in which pairs of contestants were given a couple of sheets of marine plywood, some 2x4s, some tubes of Sikaflex adhesive, and a time limit. Ultimately the boats had to be both rowed and sailed against each other. I would imagine that just about everyone with male children has gotten exposed to the Pinewood Derby. A block of pine, some 3d box nails for axles, four injection molded wheels, and with a little bit of sandpaper and paint you and your 9 or 10 year old were ready to follow in the footsteps of Mario Andretti. I admit to being a bit hard pressed to recall when my oldest son, who is now a four-year Navy veteran and a couple of inches taller than I, finished third in a field of 90 cars (Of course, I had access to a metal lathe and turned those nails to a mirror smooth finish, then plugged and bored the wheels for a smooth, non-wobbly fit!). See what happens when there are loopholes in the rules? With those examples as a background, how about a totally open class that simply provides a grocery sack of materials and leaves everything else up to the builder. What would we put into the box? Plywood (3 – 1/16″x12″x48″, 1 – 1/8″x12″x48″), Two – 5-foot pine 1x4s, yellow glue, 5 pounds of lead, 2 square feet of fiber- glass cloth, a pint of polyester resin with hardener, 7 square feet of micafilm sail material, 10:screw eyes, 2 sheet exit guides, 5 Fisher 3/4-inch turnbuckles. Total maximum weight of the boat, less radio gear and batteries to be two pounds more than the weight of the loaded grocery sack minus the weight of all the left over materials in the original sack. We’d probably see some early boats slightly longer than a one-meter, hard chine sharpies or Pea Pod variants would be the obvious place to start, maybe even with gaff-rigged mainsails because of the five-pound lead constraint, or even a catamaran with the lead suspended between the hulls. The sack of stuff could probably be put together for less than $75.00, so with radio, one could be on the water for $250, give or take abit. Ifwe could agree on a bill of materials, maybe the first thing would be to have a design competition, and publish the designs submitted herein USB&SM. Maybe we could come up with aname that would indicate the descent of this class from the Pea Pod concept which has proven so successful under USB&SM’s editor’s tutelage. Comments, contributions, and photographs to: Rod Carr, 3011177th Ave. NE, Redmond, WA 98052. e From the brown water of Vietnam to Monitor 1N6 scale Semi-kit Includes: Hull, deck, cabin, plans and more. Dyn #141 the white caps of the North Atlantic… Dynamic brings to you two exciting new models* A heavily armed brown water battleship, the Monitor, is the newest addition to the Vietnam Riverine Series. Accurate Coastal Forces plans are included with this unparalleled fivepiece fiberglass semi-kit. The Smit Rotterdam is one of the world’s fastest and strongest ocean-going tugs. This seaworthy hull can be built Smit Rotterdam up into a highly detailed model using new plans from 1/48 scale Hull and plans. Dyn #143 Technical Arts Services. A large selection of precision scale fittings and running hardware is available. Don’t just build a model, Experience it! Dynamic : MODELS Drawer C, Dept. 3, Port Jefferson Station, N.Y. 11776 Tel. 516/928-8200 For Dynamics 1990 catalog please send $5.00 “Scratch building skills are required on all models. US BOAT & SHIP MODELER 47 Unlimiteds are made by a course judge flying overhead in a helicopter. When lane violations are called in a model boat race it is by officials positioned at the start/finish line with a viewing perspective often blocked out in the corners by roostertails from the models. Having spent many hours on the judges’ stand watching model boat racing, it is vividly apparent to me that two or more individuals can watch the same racing incident and have a different opinion as to who did what to whom. some people” is certainly true when it comes to making or not making an infraction call. Let me share a personal experience from the 11cc Scale Unlimited class at the 1990 APBA Model Boat Nationals. I was serving as the Contest Director for this event and had three other course judges as well as lap counters assisting. During the mill period, prior to the start of one of the qualifying heats, one of the model Unlimiteds ran over another one as the two boats were cutting through the infield near the start/ finish line. Both boat were attempting to merge onto the backstretch. The boat that ran into the other boat stopped. The boat that was hit from the rear and side continued to keep running. I had observed the entire incident and looked down to my course judges for a ruling. They were watching other parts of the race course. If a penalty were to de called, I would have to make the call. From what I saw, the boat that had been struck from the side and rear cut in front of the other boat, causing the accident. That means it should be assessed a driver’s infraction. Because the infraction caused the other boat to stop running, the boat assessed the infraction is disqualified from that heat. When a racing incident happens with our model boats, it does not happen in slow motion and it most often occurs in the corners—areas furthest removed from the judging area. A great many model racing incidents occur in the first turn, when the boats are often packed tightly together after making the start. Spray from the roostertails obstructs the judges’ view of what is happening in back and outside of the lead boat. Allofthese circumstances often come into play at the same time when judges attempt to figure out why only one boat is going down the straightaway and four others are scattered or shattered through the first corher. The old adage “There’s no pleasing That’s the decision I rendered. The boat disqualified was my 1982 “Executone” being driven by my son, Paul. There were those who said I had made a correct call and there were others who said, “Dunlap, you sure blew that one.” In my opinion, I still think I made the correct call. I don’t think Paul will ever agree with the call, but at least he’s still talking to me. Officiating any type of fast-action sporting event is extremely difficult. Look at how long it takes the National Football League to review close plays with their instant replay capability. Model boat racers expecting justice in all calls made by race officials are asking for a rendering of the impossible. Model boaters are human, and humans make mistakes. Although some racers might dispute this next statement, race officials are also human, and these humans also make mistakes. CAUTION: RUNNING MODEL BOATS CAN BE HAZARDOUS TO YOUR HEALTH This might be a label that needs to be attached to the boxes containing model boats, like the warning label on cigarettes. There was an incident here in the Seattle area in late July that makes me think such a warning FOR $99. YOU CAN GET INTO HIGH SPEED SAILING SHIPPING IS INCLUDED* WITH THIS A.R.S.+ LAND SAILOR (NO ELECTRONICS). JUST FASTEN TWO SCREWS & STEP THE MAST. IT CAN BE SAILED FROM THE COMFORT OF YOUR AUTO ALL YEAR. WILL SAIL WITH OR WITHOUT USES RADIO. (*CONTINENTAL U.S.A.) FUTABA FP-S 125 OR ORDINARY SERVO (+ALMOST READY SAIL WINCH. TO SAIL) AS SPECS.ON L.S. NEW POP UP CAT replica LENGTH. …ses. 38″ WIDTH . 3 os ooo 30″ Complete Kit $295.00* HEIGHT 22. sis cisieie 60″ CONTAINS of Stars and Stripes SAIL AREA…340 SQ.” All hardware is alum. vacuum formed 12 METER KIT impact $295.00 electronics) Hull vacuum formed in high impact ne. Solid 1300 lead wing WEIGHT 1400 60″,Height Minimum order $10. Send M.O. or Check. Visa,Master styrene.*(no 10#,SAIL AREA SQ. IN. MASTS :Carbon fiber 85″ $74.ea. Four for $260. six for $330. sq,in. minimum shipping $2. hull in high WIDTH 32″ ,HEIGHT95″ 86″, Weight 25#,sail area 204 SPECS: LENGTH 60″, styre- keel.(no electronics) SPECS .Hull items and stainless. stainless and nylon U.S. 47 pieces all alum,nylon CAT RIGHTS ITSELF BY RADIO e®) Block: #12 No snag $4.ea == (25 for $60. unassembled) Send $3 for catalog and prices Get 16 how to plans worth $8. free POP UP,2/7 EMERSON AVE, AMITYVILLE, fal tas nyr a apt N.Y.11701,(516)842 9309 FAX(516)842 6353 ALUM: 85″ 15.95 ea.eight (Ss for 108. 72”13.95,eight De for = = os o Tome’ a——fis} oN2g eb “Nxt QS) VARIABLE WINCH ARM SEE CATALOG FOR DETAILS US BOAT & SHIP MODELER 49 + never» dreamed sailing was w So simple! The simpligity of going sailing with the Tina Sailboat really’ _ surprised me. The only difficult part of owning this wonderful boat is having to wait for some wind. But, if the wind blows; (and the — harder the better), 1 am off to the lake. | remove the boat from. my car, and attach the mast. This takes about one minute because Tina has no troublesome rigging. | turn on the radio and |.am off with the wind and across the lake. | can sail all afternoon without recharging any batteriesit’s wonderful! No preparation, no fuel… mess, no waiting for motor batteries to recharge, no cooling off of a motor — nothing! The simplicity of owning’and running such a superb boat as Tina isa girl’s dream. No fuss! NY mess! No problems! My husband gave me the Tina R/C Sailboat for my birthday. He-did a wonderful job building it. He worked a couple of hours each evening and completed it in a-week. The boatis big and beautiful! | knew nothing about sailing and have never been interestedin sailing. |: have an R/C electric speed- boat and | love running it except that when something goes wrong I’don‘t know how-to fix it. Fcan race for 10 minutes, but then I have to bring it in and” “= ‘charge it for 30 minutes. Whenerash it or break a prop, .. not being-very mechanical, | usually. ask my husband to » fix it. (Actually ‘don’t like working on anything| mechanical). | Now for thé best part of all! You won’t believe how it . feelsito see your;sailboat drifting along, and suddenly-a “gust of wind fills the sail. You’tightenthe sail, . and Tinais on her side, slicing across the water ata speed you would not believe! \‘ve-sailed Tinasin-25mph winds dnd. wish! could describe to youthe.“’snap:.of the’sail’and.the wake she leaves as Tina “tacks hard aiid, trin¥’the sail tight!;My husband couldn’t standjust watchingme,’so he built a Tina for himself. The ultimate-fun_isterrace two of these magnificent big sailboats. We get them side by side’and when they pick up the wind and keel over‘Simultaneously, we get so tickled we start mghins- I heseuaaycr enjoyed a hobby as much as | “enjoy sailing Tina. If you want to get.into something thatis surprisingly exciting, totally hassle- free, please get a Tina Sailboat. It will change your ‘Whole concept of fun! Thisis what a hobby ought to be~ HLKK1h23 Hobby Lobby/Klaus Kricki Tina qe Sailhoat $126.00 36″ lobg, 11°’ beam, 62” height overall. Kit contains durable List price $198.00 preformed ABS parts, aluminum and brass ““no- rigging ’mast ‘ JoAnne Martin Tina can be sailed’with rudder-only control but sails much better with added sail control servo. Our Accessory Packs for Tina contain everything,you will need (including sail control servo) to complete the boat except for 2-channel radio system. and boom, heavy weighted keel (ballastis included) and ready- ‘ Order Accessory Packs: HLKK1424 for-Heavy- Wind, or cut waterproof. sail. Illustrated instructions are simple and we HLKK1425 for Light Wind. (call for price), have added a radio installation instruction based on our own experience with the boat. 5614 Franklin Pike Circle °_ Brenttaiiad. TMN 37027 ®, (615) 373.- ae b