Radio Control Boat Modeller: November – December 1988

  • Title. Author. Summary
MAB> MODEL MAGAZINE NOVEMBER-DECEMBER 1988 – pcore .° ee ifai —— a es s AP World RM Championships Submarines at Gosport RC Hydros’ Worlds AN ARGUS SPECIALIST PUBLICATION YACHTING 7 Peter Stollery wins the Junior World Radio Marblehead title in Berlin. Janosz Walicki wins the senior but our own Graham Bantock gets second place — one better than two years ago. A predominance of race reports this time, the main story being of the Radio Marblehead World Championships in Berlin. A snippet of wisdom about mark rounding, learned the hard way and an explanation of a nickname introduce a bit of variety. An apology First item this month is an apology, and an explanation. Many readers will have, no doubt, spotted the odd reference to a gentleman by the name of lan Taylor in various race reviews; lan is often associated with the word ‘Vulture’ being woven into the text. Old hands of the Model Yachting Association will know of the source of this name, but there must be many who wonder just how lan came to acquire such an odd handle. My reading of some old ‘Model Boats’ magazines purchased at Primrose Valley’s ‘swap shop’ prompted me to ask the question. | think modern readers might be interested in the answer. lan was introduced to the Model Boating world at large through a short series which 4a. days). lan had one of ‘those’ meetings: he arrived at Fleetwood late in the afternoon of the day the race started; during the first two days of a typical windy Fleetwood week (ie. howling gale and driving rain all week) practically everything that could break — did! After recovering from this disastrous start the yacht, when fixed, became almost unbeatable and lan rose from near the ran in the magazine during the mid seventies. In ‘Introducing…’ — July 1976 issue lan Taylor was described briefly in a manner that suggested a rather ‘Goonish’ humour. Somehow lan “Accepted with glee the honorary title of Lord Vulture (family motto ‘Carrion Sailing’)’’. It seems that the derivation of this title goes thus: In 1975 lan had a Marblehead (Vane steered of course) called ‘Luncheon Vulture’. This yacht, made of balsa wood, weighed about 12 Ibs, making it somewhat revolutionary in those times. It fell to pieces at Dovercourt two weeks before the World (Vane) M Championships. In two weeks lan made a mould from the wreck, produced a glass fibre hull, fitted it out with new masts and rigging, and equipped it with new sails from ‘Omega’ (Graham Bantock in his early bottom of the fleet on Tuesday to 7th overall on Friday. As a result of ‘Luncheon Vulture’s’ progress and the slightly zany humour of the Vane Sailing fleet lan was dubbed ‘Lord Vulture’, or occasionally just LV, and the nickname stuck. Following this revelation | humbly apologise to his ‘Lordship’ for quoting him as simply Mr Vulture. lan, | am glad to say, retains his sense of humour whilst carrying out his job as Honorary Racing Secretary of the MYA; and his invaluable work as computer jockey and scorer at many Radio National Championships. One of his aims, | know, is to try and inject some of the fun and friendless found at Vane meetings into Radio Races — | really hope that he succeeds, so we all can enjoy our sport just that little bit more. Long may Lord Vulture perch at our meetings! Radio Control Boat Modeller Race reviews During the last month or so, this being written in August, a number of Marblehead race meetings have been cancelled or postponed. Last year at about this time | made the rather alarmist statement that people were leaving Model Yachting in general, this year, entries for Open Radio Marblehead Meetings have been down on previous years – which seems to the prove point. Why is this? Could it be that the periodic cycle of disgruntlement is recurring? Could it be that the old chestnut of the ‘Rules’ is flowering again? Or could it be that the enormous success of one or two designers and skippers and the subsequent replication of their yachts is making sailors old and new believe that the only way to compete is follow in their bow waves? Buying a copy of the latest technology is certainly one way of giving yourself a good chance to figure slightly higher in the results lists, but not essential. Unlike in some other branches of Model Sport money is not the only route to being competitive at the highest level in Radio Yacht Racing. Despite what | just said about reduced entries and cancelled races, there have been a number of events to whet the appetite during the summer months. appear to be streaks or bands of wind. This was particularly apparent as several yachts with only feet separating them seemed to be sailing in totally different wind conditions. After a while, at the prompting Mr Priestley we all moved to the leeward end of the course to start between the leeward mark and a pole on the bank. This allowed the line to be adjusted more easily to remove much of the bias such that the fleet was, for a time, spread out a little more. It also gave a magnificently long first leg of the course which, with the devilish island and a bend in the wind induced by the curving bank of the lake made life quite exciting after a start. One of the meetings postponed first time disappointing, there being a total of fifteen yachts sailing, though at least three of the As the wind increased some of the differences in yacht performance began to be evened out and the fleet started to travel around the lake together in some very close number were not taking part in the ranking race. Cleveland Club’s water at Hemlington was the venue. Sunshine and a moderate westerly wind was forecast; the weatherman almost got it right, though the sunshine was a little late in coming and most skippers were in tail suits (and warm races. The most dominant of the skippers at this meeting was Martin Mickleburgh with his new blue Hush-Hush, though several others severely dented this dominance at times. The other Martin present, Mr the heavier airs yachts were starting to show their paces. With only fifteen yachts entered lan Hall, the main race organiser, planned a thirteen boat schedule where two yachts dropped out each time to help the permanent race officer run the races. interspersed with loss of control, running aground on the island, coupled with wet footwear and trousers from a boat rescue job. Despite all this it was the two Martins who took first and third places being split by Derek Priestley in second. The meeting was conducted at a fairly brisk pace and eventually a five minute break between jackets) until around lunch time. By the end of racing we were in ‘B’ suits or lower and Cleveland? Now for the big one! Imyru/ Naviga World Championships Peter Stollery did and Graham Bantock almost did! What? Peter won the junior section of the World Radio Marblehead Championship and Graham was second to Janosz Walicki in the Senior Devision. The last full week in August saw what some have billed as the first true World Radio Marblehead Championships. Sailed on the Havel in West Berlin and organised jointly by IMYRU and Naviga with a strong input from the local club; this event was to see entries from Countries covered by both Major Model Yachting Control Authorities. As a result the numbers available for each National Fleet were reduced from the levels Northern District Ranking Race around due to lack of entries, only nine at the first attempt, the event was rescheduled to merge with the Rocket Trophy race on August Bank Holiday Sunday. Again the entry was somewhat day was to greet skippers when they returned from the lakeside to the Clubhouse complex. The majority of the assembled cars had been vandalised by forced, and not very tidy, removal of badges. It is a sad reflection on current times that in the middle of a pleasant parkland area surrounded by modern housing such vandalism is rife. Perhaps this is why there were few entries for the meeting at Roberts from Birkenhead, had an eventful day with good race scores being races was formally introduced to permit sail changes etc. A sad end to an otherwise very enjoyable seen at Fleetwood two years ago. Five skippers represented the MYA in the RM class, two in the R10R class, also sailed during the same period and one in the junior class of RM yachts. Unfortunately your reporter was not able to be present at the meeting so this report has been put together from interviews with four of the MYA Team, Graham Bantock, lan Cole, David Coode, and Roger Stollery. Their impressions and comments are interesting and illuminating. It was rumoured before the event that winds would be generally light. However it seems that they were not actually light, they just seemed that way. The Havel is one of the large lakes on the water complex in and around Berlin. It is some 10 or 12 Km long and about half a kilometre wide at the point where the championship took place. Like much of the area its banks are tree lined and even though the championship headquarters clubhouse is in a basically Heading, Norman Hatfield’s photograph of an RM fleet dwarfed by the massive expanse of water in Berlin’s Havel, venue for the World Radio Marblehead Championships. Left, Martin Mickleborough leads in a heat at Cleveland’s Northern District race. Above, Derek Priestley (78) and Martin (98) battle it out. Photos: Mike Kemp. The wind was initially not in an ideal direction for the lake and the course for the first few races was reminiscent of the 1988 Gosport RM National course. This was particularly true of the starts which initially had a considerable degree of port bias allowing most yachts which managed to squeeze through at the port end to make it to the first mark in one long port tack. Hemlington is one of those lakes where, with this sort of wind direction, there November/December 45 residential area the gardens have trees right down to the water’s edge. With a prevailing Westerly direction this meant that for most of the time the wind was coming over the backs of the competitors. It also meant that it was being blanketed by trees and buildings. Thus a frustrating time was had as the wind could be seen further over the lake but not where most of the competition took place. The far side of the lake is quite a busy waterway with commercial traffic as well as the pleasure cruise craft. It is also intensively used for recreation with large power boats and, at the weekends, literally thousands of yachts. As a result of all this use there is a constant source of waves. Unlike our normal sailing waters however, the waves are not associated with wind and in light conditions were a positive menace — literally shaking the wind out of the sails. Almost all major Championships seem to produce at least one controversial feature which remains a talking point for some time afterwards. Occasionally this can be turned around into a positive development of our sport. In this case the features would Above, one’of the many close starts in the light conditions. Left, World Junior RM Champion Peter Stollery. Below left, American skipper/designer Jon Almalah’‘s dart shaped R10R, came 8th. Below, the Russian ‘pits’. Photos: Norman Hatfield. appear to be a sailing system called the ‘Italian System’ and the difference between the IMYRU and Naviga sailing rules. The ‘Italian System’ trying to tack from port into an overlap when they may not be able to point high This is a fleet racing arrangement which apparently has favour with some within the Naviga organisation. According to my enough to round the mark. This particular rule variation would appear to be a ready source of protest material and, coupled with the ‘Italian System’, even further delay to racing. At off-wind marks, particularly in heavy weather | imagine, it would seem to offer wonderful scope for someone to barge into an overlap situation and present a considerable hazard to yachts. We have enough trouble under the lYRU rule where a yacht can be refused an overlap if the outside boats cannot respond in time. Under the Naviga system the fact that the inside boat does not have to worry about intelligence sources the Italians disowned it! It redistributes yachts around subsequent fleets by taking the top two or three from each fleet in any given round and putting them all in the new A fleet. The next group in each fleet find themselves in B fleet and so on down to the bottom fleet. So if you only manage to get into the bottom two or three of A Fleet you descend instantly to, say, F Fleet. If you then win your F fleet race you are instantly back up into A Fleet. As one of those who seem to spend their championship life bouncing between A and B fleets, | would become a real Yo-Yo between top and bottom. Apart from the dislike of this violent up and down the system has one other significant disadvantage which seems to be abhorred hitting the mark opens the door to all sorts of belligerent behaviour. A sort of ‘yachting dodgems’ might be the ultimate result. by all | have spoken to. Because the next round of races cannot start until all protests have been resolved, there is a vastly increased delay between races. In Berlin it was often as much as one and a half hours. Under the preferred, and more familiar to us, fleet systems at least seventy five of those minutes could be used for racing unaffected heats while protests are thrashed out. The ‘Italian System’ was used for the first two days of the Senior Marblehead event; it was followed by reversion to the more familiar International Radio Control Yacht Racing System. Never the less because of the wind conditions, large courses, and slightly sloppy frequency and fleet control racing was not speeded up significantly. As a result only seventeen races were completed between Sunday and Thursday sailing from 9.00am to 6.00pm each day. Naviga Sailing Rules is not a system that has much in its favour. The result seems to be that there is a comparatively large congretation of yachts, particularly around the windward mark, all of which for one reason or another are virtually head to wind. Thus they have little or no way on and cannot manoeuvre, they are invariably touching one another, and Graham Bantock – In the Marblehead because of the shaking sails and event it was probably as high or even appear, contentious differences between Naviga’s sailing rules and those of the lYRU is that in Naviga races one is allowed to hit marks of the course with impunity. General opinion of those | have spoken to is that this line get squeezed up to windward by yachts 46 How did the standard of racing compare with that which we see at our National events? their racing numbers cannot be easily seen overlapping yachts. It is difficult to judge who had rights of way, on the inside with a true overlap ie. one that would allow the yacht to correctly round the mark — even if it did hit the obstacle. Also, yachts approaching the mark ‘correctly’ on the lay One of the most significant and, it would Racing Standards higher, in the R10R event | don’t think it was very high because of the use of the Naviga rules. People get used to that and they sail badly as a result of it. In fact | was absolutely amazed at some of the poor quality of rule observance and sailing | saw in the R10R event. Radio Control Boat Modeller the bow which rounded out in the middle and toward the stern. He had mounted his radio gear right at the back. The winch and the servo were about five inches from the lan Cole — In general the standard of racing was good, as you would expect. The fleets were pretty tight, the start was always tight, every one knew that they ought to be there stern and the batteries were actually velcroed onto the inside of the transom. This allowed him to put the fin further forward with the lead and the rig, | suppose he did this to increase the moment of inertia to stop the boat from pitching in the short waves. Perhaps also to make it more predictable when trying to tack in big waves, if you have more weight in the ends it will carry its way through when the wind is light and the waves were large. Unfortunately he gave up after about two days due to a number of circumstances. He had bursts of speed, | saw him win a couple of races; but also he worked his way down on time. It was obvious that the better skippers were there, if you didn’t get the good start it was very difficult to catch up. If you had to do a set of turns you were very unlikely to get back in again. The standard amongst most of the people was such that had there been a bit more wind it would have been a very interesting Championship. More consistent wind would have made the tactical aspect of sailing much more important. There was a certain amount of luck involved, with the vagaries of the wind and waves and what have you. | know the top people always seem to come out on top regardless, but at this event they were all top people so they couldn’t all come out on to C fleet in one race so he obviously wasn’t doing something quite right. top. Roger Stollery — | think it was very good. The fact that our skippers, spread over the top ten in the Nationals, were spread over the top forty in this event gives a good indication of the overall standard of the skippers sailing. Far left top, three of the Russian R10R yachts — similar boat took the World Championship. Beneath, what a combo for the TOTs trophy — left, Finland’s Lindholm (4th), Norway’s Klem (5th) and USA’s Elmaleh (3rd). Middle top, Lupart’s beautiful R10R finished 7th. Beneath, top RM skippers in World, Walicki flanked by Bantock (left) and Elmaleh. Above, Victor Nasarov’s yacht shows it’s slightly ‘old fashioned’ look — 33rd in the RM but won the R10R! Photos: Norman Hatfield. and narrow with low freeboard, there were only a few present: unfortunately Kardatski himself wasn’t sailing. Walicki’s boats are similar in a way but are basically bigger, more stable. | find it difficult to tell the difference between his boats, they all look The Yachts Over the past few years we have had a good view of yacht design and developments in Europe, how do they compare with developments in other Countries? Graham Bantock – The German boats all seem to be very different to the English ones; there seem to be two schools of thought. Either Walicki’s boats are used or the hulls by Kardatski; there weren’t so many of Kardatski’s there. His seemed to prefer the lighter winds, they are quite light November/ December the same to me, but | am sure they are slightly different; it might well have been the same boat that he used last year. They have this cunning system where they use the same registered number for each competitor all the time, so you can never tell if they’ve got a new boat. As for the rest of Europe, that’s another thing. We are fairly familiar with the French boats. Paul Lucas’ boat was very different this year. | think he had spent a lot of time thinking about the likely conditions and producing a boat which he thought might well work well in those condtions. It was narrower with a much flatter rocker in the middle, virtually straight with all the curvature at the ends. It may have had an overhang at the bows. It tended to have Vee sections at the bow because of the depth of Russian and East German boats all seemed to be ten years behind the time really. They were a bit like Marbleheads in the late sixties and early seventies in this country. They looked as if they were relatively heavy displacement, tended to have high freeboard but the fittings were quite sophisticated and neatly made. The Russian boats, like the Italians at Fleetwood, had slides everywhere and radial jib fittings which used a rather large ball bearing and worked very well. They also had rotating masts. Jon Elmaleh appears to be sailing the same hull as in Holland last year, it now has a lot of lead on the bottom and had a carbon fin instead of the solid aluminium one. It looked as if it was quite a stable boat now. Terry Allen’s must have beena bit heavier and was a bit beefier, to my mind it looked a bit more normal. It had a flat all the way down the middle; as if it has a bottom panel of a chine boat about a couple of inches wide, perhaps in the middle of the boat, tapering off towards each end. Outside of that it had the full form of a Sea Urchin perhaps, slightly finer stern — a very interesting boat. The Chinese boats arrived after a couple of days by which time they had been sailing a couple of loaned German boats, and were doing very well. They probably didn’t do quite as well with their own, actually. John Cleave thought they all looked like Netsuki’s 47 — but then he thinks that everything looks like a Netsuki. Some of them genuinely were like the Netsuki, though they appeared to have slightly more Vee sectioned bows. Again, nicely made fittings. lan Cole – | think we are probably well ahead on development, looking in general at the Eastern Country boats. They are all perhaps what we were sailing quite some time ago. There were one or two carbon masts, one of the Russians had one on a ten rater that was home made. In general they were on aluminium spars, and the Chinese as well; they made fairly good use of them, lots of standing rigging with about three sets of shrouds to try and hold the thing in a reasonable shape. Their sails were good, mostly either mylar or draughting film. Quite nice shapes, the bit that mattered was reasonably efficient. The Russian boats were using quite heavy Futaba winches and what looked like lead acid batteries to run them. What voltage they were was a bit suspect because their Futaba winches ran very quickly, much quicker than they normally do. They could have been Silver Zinc, they certainly were largish square boxes, two or three of them with screw terminals on top. Most of the Russian boats | looked at had wet cell power for the winch and Nicads for the Radio. They were into some very nice engineering in their fittings; there was a Russian quite well placed in the Marbleheads, Igor Nalevski, whose miniature engineering on his boat was very impressive. Some nice fittings, a bit on the heavy side, but that sort of thing was quite advanced. Perhaps they just lacked the materials; but their boats were reasonably light so they were obviously trying. On several of them they had systems for goosewinging the jib over, using a third channel so they were reasonably advanced in controlling them. Japanese radio gear in general. The French Zef that Christian Goubet and Philippe Sol were sailing is not unlike Hush-Hush to a certain extent; it doesn’t have the chine and its a little bit different at the bow, but in general it’s not dissimilar. All the French except Sol were using swing rigs, the two Evolutions both had swing rigs one Bantock style the other a KMS – the unbalanced one. All equipped with shrouds and cantilever arrangements. Paul Lucas’ boat was obviously an attempt at a light airs boat, slimmer than normal; quite a nice looking shape. Graham reckoned that if he had struck to his original Cedar that he sailed at Fleetwood he would have done better with it. Whether it was a new boat, untried, or he was not used to swing rig, he seemed to a) have some problems with it and b) not be very consistent in sailing it. Certainly on some occasions| left him well behind with the Hush-Hush. But it looked as if it had potential, at times it seemed quite quick, so whether he was having trouble with the boat or anything else | don’t know. Roger Stollery — | was disappointed by the performance of the French designs, but more by the bad sportsmanship of their skippers. The Walicki type of yachts seemed to be very responsive and allowed very quick following of wind shifts, which could be up to forty degrees at times. With their ‘skimming dish’ shapes having both ends clear of the water and rudders set well in from the stern they were able to turn very 48 quickly with little disturbance in the water. They also seemed, with their rounded shape, to be able to follow the wave action and cope with the slop experienced there. The American type hull shapes were obviously very effective. With four of them in the top ten and Graham Bantock’s similar Hush-Hush somewhere in between they suited the wind and wave conditions very well. The Archer design seemed rather overpowered when the wind got up, but good sailing overcame that problem. The Chinese yachts seemed rather similar to the Japanese designs like Netsuki that we have seen before. The Russian boats looked a long way, some twenty Radio Control Boat Modeller Opposite top, 15th overall and one of the victorious Team of Three, Torvald Klem to Lady Jane to Berlin. Middle, reigning European Champion Jon Elmaleh sailed his latest Archer design with impressive engineering to cantilever that lead. Bottom Lindholm’s boat was 4th with his American designed yacht. This page, top left, typical early American light wind yacht shape in Ralph McCufferty’s yacht. Above, more modern Chinese boat was 17th. Top right, USA‘s Terry Allen sailed Spot into 16th. Right, Chinese Netsuki- like boat with deck stepped mast. Bottom, Berlin Rowing Club, home for the Championships. Photos: lan Cole. years, behind ours, though they were performing reasonably and had some really well engineered fittings. One even had the parts machined out of titanium. The Rules There has been a great deal of discussion about rule observance and interpretation in different countries, what sort of problems emerged during this event? Graham Bantock – | think the jury was a very competent one, the problem as usual came with the evidence that they had. They were probably let down by poor quality observers. That’s a hard thing to say and | feel happier about saying it having spent two days being an observer myself in the R10OR event. | found that after about two races | just could not remember the things that had happened. They happened so quickly that it was just impossible to remember them. It was worse in the R10R event because they were using Naviga Rules where boats are able to hit the marks. The mark touching is the basic difference between the rules; but that creates so many problemsin itself it’s not just a simple difference of being able to hit the mark, which seems relatively minor. If we are used to rounding the mark in the normal way and we leave just enough room for us to get round and suddenly we find there are boats piling in happy to hit the mark then the onus is on us to actually skirt November/ December round them as well as the mark. The other problem with being able to hit the mark is that you don’t loose your rights when you do. So if you hit it on the wrong side and then you’re re-approaching it to round it correctly you have still got all your rights if you are on Starboard Tack and the other boats on Port. It’s crazy and certainly creates havoc. lan Cole — The rule observance certainly didn’t seem to be very good, | don’t know whether it really wasn’t very good or just not understood. The Chinese seemed to have trouble knowing whether they were in the right or wrong if contacts were called. There were not that many protests though; | wouldn’t think we had the same sort of volume as at Fleetwood, though we didn’t have as many races. It worked better with the Marblehead racing under the IMYRU rules than it did under the Naviga system. | think the IMYRU countries now sail under very much the same interpretation of rules as we do, there didn’t seem to be a great problem in IMYRU. The biggest change was this hitting the buoys, which Naviga seem to think is a great thing. Quite noticably there were a lot more contacts at buoys when you able to hit them. People would try and squeeze round when they didn’t really have enough room. The same at the start, they would all try and barge round at the windward end, thinking that rather than hit you they could hit the mark and sort of roll around and it and try and get in. That generally caused chaos; | certainly think that our system has the edge. Possibly the protest committee had more of a problem. They had this system for prejudging where you could accept their decision on the jetty. They got the observers together to make a decision among themselves on any contacts that were outstanding where turns had not been getting pretty consistent top class then took it to protest and argued it you then took a penalty if you lost your case. So the system did try to encourage fewer protests. Despite what was in the sailing instructions | think they actually continued the prejudging all the wav through so that you could accept last place to make it go through that much quicker. The Chinese and are maintaining a good standard of done. Then they would disqualify who they thought was in the wrong. If you accepted that decision you scored last place, if you seemed to suffer because they spend so long trying to figure out which rule to protest under that they missed the time limit for lodging protests. They only had one person, a sort of ‘minder’, who could speak English to try and interpret. The Russians were the same, they had a ‘minder’ who could interpret, but | don’t recall any of the Russians going to protest, they seemed reasonably fair with their sailing. competition before you go. Getting skippers reasonably sharpened up before they go, it might help; | can’t see that it would hinder. Roger Stollery – | think we have developed racing with our programme of events. There is one thing that we can learn from the way Naviga do things though. Where are our ‘junior’ races? If we are to develop our sport we need to develop the interest of the youngsters. If you look around at the moment, all the younger people we are seeing are following their dad into the sport — Peter is a case in point. | don’t know how we can do it but we need to attract the younger people so that we can ‘grow’ the champions of the future. Perhaps television is the answer; full sized racing can never be shown live on television, it just takes too long. On the other hand model racing is more feasible, after all most races only last about ten minutes, all within easy range of was expecting it to be a bit grim. It was interesting to meet all these people from other countries and see what they are getting up to. | think the ranking system itself works well, it’s just that there wasn’t a great deal of interest in going to Berlin. Roger Stollery – Yes | think so. a camera. Roger Stollery – | don’t think | want to comment on that, | would rather concentrate on some more positive features of the event. However | suppose a major realisation was that the ‘Italian System’ is not at all suitable for this sort of event and far too much time was wasted between races. The prejudging system only seemed to add to the delays. Can We Improve Our Standards? Is there anything that we, the MYA and/or Clubs and/or individual skippers, need to do to reach (or maintain) standards that compare favourably. Graham Bantock – One approach would be to do what Walicki does and that is to go out and practise regularly and spend an awful lot of time building and maintaining boats, and improving on existing designs. To a limited extent some of us are doing that, perhaps not to the same extent that he is. He was clearly way ahead of the rest of us in terms of results this time, it’s partly because he is very used to sailing his boat, Choosing A Team Is the MYA Ranking system the right way to go? (Bearing in mind that there appears to be a reducing entry level in general) Graham Bantock- If all the top British competitors wanted to go to the next World Championship it would be the ideal way of selecting the team. Because everybody would be fighting for a place and you would them. Also because he was on home truly get the top people out of the top of the ranking list. When some of the top people territory he felt more relaxed. A dedicated approach. Also perhaps we can think more about different ways of rigging and serious interest in the ranking system. Then perhaps in those conditions or conditions like are not planning to go to the world championship they don’t take such a designing boats. There is not enough variety at the moment, we need to think the results you get are not necessarily indicative of the true quality of British Model more about boats for specific conditions rather than just for our own conditions here. | am sure if the same crowd of people probably because there is not a World Championship next year although there is a had been gathered together in America for a championship the American boats would have come out on top, because they would have had their conditions and their home Yachtsmen. The reducing entry level is European one. We are going to have to find a means of selecting for that, and being Italy, it sounds a nice place for a holiday. We have got to have a method of choosing people and with the increased frequency of territory. | have no doubt they would have been very difficult to beat. But they were at a disadvantage because like a lot of other people they were away from home. these events it’s going to have to be continuous system. | can’t see anything to lan Cole — | think we are probably doing the lan Cole – Yes | think the only reason that right think with our ranking race system, so that you tend to get those who are on form at the start of that year or who have got the better boats. Perhaps we should do a bit more training than we do before something like that. We do it perhaps once or perhaps twice a year at the ‘Race of Champions’ and the ‘Best of British’ where the entries are selected. We could probably do with that before we go to an International event rather than at the end of the year. So that you are entries are reducing is we got to the point where it was known who was going to the 50 replace what we’ve got at the moment. Worlds. Nobody knew anything else was coming up in the following year so they haven’t bothered to make the effort. They couldn’t foresee anything worth going to, now there is a carrot to hang out, you will find the entries will go up again for ranking races. | don’t think many people thought of Berlin as much of a place to go; | was rather surprised that it was as good as it was; | Left, French skipper Guy Lordat was using this complex swing rig which carries shrouds and all. Top, first seen at Fleetwood in 1986, the French Evolution has been re-rigged with a Bantock style unit which normally points the other way! Russian Bondarenko’s RM with unusual fin, 53rd. Opposite top, McCufferty’s elegant boat. Middle, ex Olympic yathcsman from New Zealand, Geoff Smale with an absolutely beautifully built boat. Photos: lan Cole. IMYRU and Naviga? What do think of a combined IMYRU/ Naviga event? Graham Bantock – | hope we don’t have any more, quite frankly, though a lot of nice noises were made at the prize giving about what a success it was. In many ways it was a success. Getting people together from a great many different countries was a success, there can be no doubt about that because we would not have met half of those people at an IMYRU event. Equally they would not have met us at theirs. Socially it was very good, the Germans know how to organise that sort of thing; there were lots of pleasant evenings down at the pondside with barbecues and food and booze and everything. It helps having sponsorship, no doubt, but even the meal on the boat after the prize giving was a very pleasant affair, everybody seemed to enjoy it. From that point of view it was a marvellous affair. lan Cole – It would be improved if we could get the system running more efficiently. Radio Control Boat Modeller Perhaps run it along IMYRU lines rather than Naviga lines. Whether that is possible, | suppose they will each want to do a bit of their own system; they like their system, we like ours and it might be difficult to get them to run on IMYRU fleet system continually. Their system is, | suppose, a way of selecting fleets: if we must have it then that is probably where to use it. After two selection days the fleets were probably what you might have envisaged anyway; they weren’t that far out. Whatever system you use, it is certainly good to get both sets of people together for an event like that. To try and encourage the whole world to take part in a proper World Championship. We ought to have everyone represented, and it was nice to see that we had people from most of the places — a pity some of them didn’t turn up. Roger Stollery — Great, the bringing together of competitors from all over the world was an excellent event. However | think that combining two or more classes at such an event inevitably de-values one of them. | had the feeling that the R10R races were being treated as the ‘also rans’. | understand that Naviga are talking of combining the 1 Metre yachts with the Marbleheads and R10OR yachts at the next Championship, which would de- devil of a job to get the 10 Rater measured initially, because of a different Naviga system. Finally we managed to convince them that all it had to do was to conform to its IMYRU certificate in exactly the same way as it was measured under the IMYRU system. To start with | was slicing lead of the back of the bulb to try and get it to their waterlines, we did not want to start cutting the sails. In the end we got them to measure it to the IMYRU system, it was then half an inch too short so | had to put all the lead back on again. Those sort of differences should have been thought about, and something organised beforehand so that they could measure boats to IMYRU rather Naviga. Having done one they would probably then realise the difference and carry on. Roger Stollery – Not really, every one was interested in sailing, its only at the higher ‘political’ levels that positions seem to be entrenched and causing difficulties. Model Yachtsmen are individual Model Yachtsmen, the world over. Perhaps the best thing that could happen would be the disbanding of both IMYRU and the yachting section of Naviga, then have them reform under the wing of one organisation such as the IlYRU. value one or more of them even more. Learning Experiences Can They Get Together? We all learn from our various experiences, what did you learn from this meeting? Did any major differences become visible to skippers that might prevent the ultimate merging of yachting under one authority? Graham Bantock – | listened in on a bit of conversation between Hans Kukula (Naviga) and Jan Dejmo (IMYRU) about this. IMYRU is moving steadily in the direction of IYRU, Graham Bantock – | suppose effort pays. | was much more relaxed this time that | had been at Fleetwood two years ago. | hope this not taken wrongly, but it was actually easier to come second this time than it was to come third last time. | suppose it is partly we would not get a separate committee dealing with Model Yachting in the same way that there is a sail-board committee. We wouldn’t quite have the same status as the other branches of sailing, which is a pity. | suppose people are going to wonder whether we should hang out for committee Class Association status for the time being. Unfortunately Naviga don’t appear to want the same out of the sport of model yachting as we do. They seem to see it as just a of the set-up. They’re not likely to go out on a limb. Because of the differences in the rules, and from what they are actually doing it does not look as if they are making any attempt to merge with IMYRU before we become part of IlYRU. They are still actually writing out all the sailing rules, the racing rules, etc., that they need. They are not producing an appendix as IMYRU does, and yet they claim that their rules are very similar to ours. They claim that their Marblehead rule is very similar to ours; if it is, why they don’t they just adopt ours, and if necessary write an appendix. lan Cole – No | don’t think so really. Obviously the Marbleheads are now measured under the one rule; but | had a November/December assessed what the conditions were like without actually going there. We did expect light winds, the Marbleheads normally go well in light winds, the performance of the skippers wasa bit of a pain, this skipper could have done better. In general | cope reasonably well with light airs, but normally when we sail in light airs we are close to the boats so we can see what the tell-tails are doing or see how the sails are setting and reacting to the wind. Because of the combination of very long courses, the sails shaking about, and having to beat towards you, it was very difficult to keep the boat moving on the wind. It was difficult to see a getting away with them. status whether we should just take ake rules is slightly different. The people who are organising Model Yachting within Naviga tend to be also interested in the rest lan Cole – Certainly the boat preparation was alright; it was very difficult to have followed it, and in very light airs the swing rig doesn’t very well. It made conditions very difficult to sail all together. They were the sort of conditions that we haven’t sailed in England. Graham coped remarkably well and so did John Cleave with his Logic in a similar way to he did in Holland; going for some rather hairy port end starts and been offered class association status. So maximum amount of fun for the maximum amount of people, if necessary at the expense of quality racing. | think this is one of the reasons why their approach to the races in very light airs. That could be used to affect the results of the race itself. big shift in light winds unless the boat had at the moment it seems that IMYRU has hobby, and they want to try and provide the They didn’t appear to be keen to sail any because | had been leading at Fleetwood earlier on, albeit for a very short time, and then people were overtaking me. When you are in that situation things are a bit different, the pressure comes on. | enjoyed that; at the end of it | felt that | had had a really good scrap and still been in there at the end. But this time Walicki was well away from the rest at quite an early stage. That left a bunch of half a dozen people, any one of whom could have been second, third, fourth, etc. But because of the unpredictability of the racing there was no point in getting too worked up about it. One just had to be more relaxed and not worry too much about the conditions. Enjoy it without getting too uptight about things. It would have been easy to get very upset with the organisation there; a few times races were postponed because there was not enough wind, they said, and yet boats were sailing about on the water. The organisation were being seen, it could be argued, to try to help their local boy win. There was another Logic being sailed by a Norwegian. They are quite a small, narrow boat which went through what waves there were quite well. The other American boats coped with the waves well and had very soft rigs that seemed to sense the wind better than perhaps a stiff swing rig might. Graham had a very light swing rig for his but didn’t help swing rigs at all, they are fine in waves and wind but not in waves and no wind; they were not the ideal rig for the venue. Roger Stollery — | came home questioning my own yacht design criteria some of which, | realise now, have been dormant for a considerable time. | have grown up with the idea that a long waterline is desirable for windward work. In addition there is the idea that it is necessary to get away from the leeward end of a vane lake as quickly as possible you end up with a yacht with a sharp forefoot which will cut through the waves. For a radio yacht these features are not that necessary, they are not sailed close to the edge of the lake, there are other criteria than just making them sail ina straight line between A and B faster than the next boat. 51 On the Continent there seems to be a lot of independent thought about yacht design and shape; in this country the yachts are selection system wasn’t very efficient. They didn’t appear to have looked into the possibility of everyone having their own starting to all look very similar. Twenty years ago when it was possible to just go out and buy a yacht everyone had to develop their own line of thought and English yacht development was very varied, but leading the rest. We need to get back to that questioning and development of independent ideas. Trying things to handle different conditions —- why don’t you have a go at designing a boat? frequency, they did as we do at open Worth Going? The actual turn around, although they had gathered people on the jetty during the previous race, at times there was quite a wait before you started the next race. There didn’t seem to be any threat of “if you’re not in the water we will start without you”. They did stop once or twice for weather, for Overall did you have a good time in Berlin? Graham Bantock – Yes. Berlin is very interesting place. A pretty inconvenient place, | suppose, because it is a bit of a drag getting there driving through East Germany. We went the shortest route and that was a pain. People who went on some of the other routes to Berlin had to spend many more hours driving through East Germany than we did. | suppose people who had come from Austria and Switzerland had much longer routes as well. It was an interesting place to see and | am glad that the event was there because it was an opportunity to go to Berlin to do a bit of Model Yachting when | would never go to Berlin just to see the city itself. lan Cole – Yes the social side of it was reasonably good, but the long time between races puts you more on edge to do well. As you do poorly in the few you are getting, you start to worry more than perhaps you might if you were getting lots of races and you could blow off the odd one. A lot of waiting about, so that wasn’t all enjoyable. After a while you had seen everyone else’s boat and got to talk to everybody and ran out of things to talk about. With that number of people, unless it was really ultra sharp organisation, you needed something like there was at Fleetwood to push the skippers along. Roger Stollery – Yes, an excellent time. Can We Learn From The Event? What lessons do you think can be learned about race organisation from this meeting? Graham Bantock – We have a damned good system already, and there is no reason on earth to start using the crumby ‘Italian System’ which they used for the first two days. | understood that the ‘Italian System’ would be used as we would normally use the preliminary round, schedule, grillehazard, or whatever to seed the fleets. The local club, the organising authority, saw it as a separate method of scoring prior to the fleet system. It was therefore not treated as a preliminary round and was subject to its own variations of rules. For instance under the ‘Italian System’ they don’t allow discards. This meant that at the end of the regatta we were only discarding from the second half. We were very lucky really, the wind went light and they couldn’t start any more races on Monday otherwise we would probably have had half of Tuesday under it as well, if they had managed to start another A fleet race. lan Cole — The actual organisation of fleets was quite slow, and there were quite often frequency clashes because people hadn’t checked the boards. Their frequency 52 meetings and move little pegs about on boards which could easily get a change in frequency which wasn’t announced so you had to go and keep checking. In Holland the system was very efficient particularly with the use of a computer which can sort them out; even if there are a few that have to change that would be far more efficient than everybody having the possibility of having to change. not enough wind or even a thunderstorm. In fact they didn’t stop for the storm, they stopped after it until the wind had dropped! That seemed a bit strange. Because the fleet before had had a mast fall down and people careering about out of control, simply because there was suddenly a lot of wind that they weren’t prepared for. That’s not really a reason to stop racing at this level, you just have to cope. | think they tried hard to get things as slick as possible but it’s things like that could have speeded things up and avoided a lot of hassle. Roger Stollery — None what so every from the British point of view. “Thank you, gentlemen, for the opportunity to share your thoughts and experiences.” Did You Know? If you are rerounding a mark after having hit it; you have not completed the job, and regain normal rights of way, until you have left the mark astern on a proper course for the next mark (RULE 45.1). Ballast Regular readers will remember that some issues ago | conducted a kit review of the Kyosho Fairwind, an almost ready to go yacht kit being distributed in this Country by Ripmax. One of the things | commented upon was the problem of ballasting this semi-scale yacht which has a simple fin keel moulded into its hull. The instructions call for 1.7 Kg of what appears to be lead shot to be poured into the fin to bring the yacht to float evenly on its designed waterline. | found at the time that, in my locality at least, buying lead shot from fishing suppliers is like trying to buy Rocking Horse manure. The non-toxic substitute material was, | concluded, prohibitively expensive. Following the review and a conversation with Ripmax | recently received a sample of the ballast recommended in the kit. The ‘Kyosho Balls’ (considerably smaller and denser than the Bantock or Stollery variety we Radio Yachtsmen are used to) are indeed ideal for this type of pour-in ballast. Whether they are more realistically priced | Write To Your MYA | have been having some correspondence with IMYRU Technical man Jan Dejjmo. Among the items he has mentioned is one which | feel is worth reminding MYA Club members of. If you have some beef or dissatisfaction with the way in which things are being run, tell someone! Better still, commit your grouse to paper in a letter to someone; Chairman, Secretary, Racing Secretary, District Representative: it doesn’t really matter if you send it to the wrong person. As long as that person is in ‘the system’ your letter, preferably constructive, should receive attention. | can vouch for the fact that the current MYA Council constituents do respond to such treatment, even to the point of arranging for one of their number to visit the person in question to try and sort out the matter face to face. The previously mentioned reduction in race entry levels must be symptomatic of something being wrong ‘out there’ somewhere. That means that someone in amongst the grass roots has some ideas why; a letter voicing some ideas from those people could be the very trigger that is required to provide those at the top with inspiration to guide our organisation onwards. At the moment it appears to be going downwards: and that is not good. All of this is another reason why the individual ‘sailor’ should join his/her local club. An organisation such as the MYA is only as strong and effective as its constituent clubs. In turn, an individual club is only as strong and effective as its members (not its committee) make it. Remember, the committee member is generally an enthusiast who will join in and enjoy his sport; irrespective of the support given by the ‘ordinary’ member. However, without the support and participation by the ‘ordinary’ member, the committee cannot make a club great. Stop Press! The 1 Metre rules have finally been settled. They should allow the American and Naviga rule yachts to fit. Briefly: the sail rigs will have to conform to the IMYRU/ Graham Bantock designed ‘one design pattern. The draught ie. Waterline to bottom of lead bulb, must be between 340mm & 400 mm. The ‘Rocker’ ie. Waterline to bottom of hull body, must be no more than 60 mm. The fin/bulb assembly must be removable and weight between 2.2kg & 2.5 kg. Below, New Zealand team, from left to right, Bruce Edgar, Kevin Fieldes and Geoff Smale. Photo: lan Cole. Above, an elated R10R Champion, Viktor Nasarov flanked by Janusz Walicki (left) and Quian Zhao. Above right, Champion Peter Stollery seems ill-at-ease with his boquet will leave to your calculation, but they are available, through your Ripmax agent, at around £16.00 for a 2 Kg. pack. Also seen in sample form is some lead flashing type ‘strip ballast’ from Graupner, also available from Ripmax. This material is very similar, although somewhat thinner, to the lead | eventually cut up to provide ballast in the review yacht. Radio Control Boat Modeller RADIO MARBLEHEAD- JUNIOR DIVISION . Yep FIVE RESULTS Country England Brasil Brasil ‘Russia Belgium as the anthems are played. Photos: Sine Pooecter Cleave’s Netsuki, brought back from the – RADIO MARBLEHEAD – SENIOR DIVISION : es7 TENRESULTS Norman Hatfield. Below, Chinese Jing- _ Qiang Zhao’s yacht looks a bit like John East by John 4 or 5 years ago. Photo: lan Cole. 10.8 16.4 19.1 35.7 $8 : : Skipper Place ist _—=s—s Sanusz Walicki : Country West Germany USA Finland West Germany France Russia Finland Spain Engiand Score 327 79.4 80.8 102.7 109.4 1124 140 150.4 152.4 RADIO MARBLEHEAD- SENIOR DIVISION _ OTHER ENGLISH PLACINGS Country England England England Score 216 3147 423.7 ‘RADIO 10 RATER _ TOP TENRESULT : Country Russia West Germany China China China New Zealand _ Switzerland USA _ ‘Russia _ Austria Score 39.2 474 514 58.1 62.8 65.4 66.7 674 69.7 85 ‘RADIO 10 RATER ENGLISH PLACINGS Country England id Coode England Score 101.7 139 very “NOTEAnbough DavidCoode was not placedclear, _ highly in the R10RResult, his continuous, and concise week-long performance @s an unpaid _ observerin the RM event was rated highly by some _ of the competitors, and deservesa mention. November/December 53