o~D arom mame-moos a eau a wo 0°”H0912M8″46K040″ “6 |l PHOTOS BY ROD CARR by ROD CARR Roger Hoffman’s “Super Barbara” ghosting nicely in light air on Seattle’s Lake Washington. Mast is 8 foot and sail’s area is much larger than stock. Satl-design tips for maximum Vortex Model Engineering’s vin- tage 1977-’78 Vortex 60—a semi-scale boat based on the America’s Cup defender, Intrepid. Any reader who has one should contact the author. | performance ‘VE RECEIVED several correspondences from readers telling how they’ve rigged and trimmed their genoa jibs (those big jibs that overlap the mast). It’s a complex task, and there are many approaches that can be taken. As I read through their letters, it became obvious that how the sail will be used is an integral part of its construction. I quickly realized that this is an involved pro- ject, so I will split it into two parts for convenience. The first part will deal with the design and construction of the genoas, with appropriate bits of aerodynamic theory, design criteria and con- struction techniques. The second part will entail the rigging and the sheeting of the sail. With the help of this first installment, you can decide whether to embark on such a project. 46 RADIO CONTROL BOAT MODELER before, they become unwieldy off the other sails that you’ve become accus- to boat performance while sailing to wind, though I’m sure there’s an enter- tomed to, the corners are named con- windward. They help on tight reaches, prising tinker out there who will fit sistently as head, tack and clew. but they become progressively less roller reefing to the forestay and sim- Likewise, the names of the edges—luff, manageable as the reaches become ply furl the thing on the downwind leech and foot—are standard. A couple broad and turn into runs. Use of runs. (Will he then set a Rich Matt- of new terms need clarification. whisker poles is common among big- style spinnaker?) In close quarters with ¢ The “J” measurement is simply the boat skippers, but I’ve never seen them other boats, there is the possibility of distance from the mast to the used on models. Genoas are different, getting entangled. jibstay /deck intersection. On model Genoas make their best contribution a challenge to make and an effort to Because of the stress and abuse that yachts that have a genoa, the jibstay use effectively. What more could one they suffer as they are hauled from generally terminates at a deck fitting ask of a hobby? side to side while tacking, genoas have on the center line. Rules for Genoas the shortest useful lifetime of any ¢ The luff perpendicular (LP) is the model yacht sail. Less than a year of distance from the genoa clew to the Big boats use genoas for upwind work, sailing is typical, though many skip- luff—perpendicular-wise. If the LP is so they must provide increased perfor- pers keep them flying even though equal to theJmeasurement, the genoa mance somehow. The majority of orga- they start looking rumpled, baggy and is said to be 100 percent. If the LP is nized racing classes here in the United strained. longer than J, the fraction of “4 is used Because the area of the sail near the to calculate a percentage by which to States don’t offer a class rule structured to provide a place to use them. A clew is almost parallel to the center identify the genoa. Sails of up to 150 genoa, extending aft of the mast, offers line of the boat when it’s sheeted, the percent are typically used. a way to get additional sail area with- after portions of a genoa are not effi- out contravening a rating rule. Most cient at contributing forward drive. American Model Yachting Association The net aerodynamic force, caused (AMYA) class’s sail-area rules specify by the different air pressures on a maximum for the measured triangles either side of the sail, points athwart of the actual sails. This eliminates any ships. Because the force vector does advantage that an unmeasured sail not point forward, the after part such as a genoa might confer. produces little drive. It produces The International 6-Meter and parts of the sail are usually rather however, allow genoas. The size of close to the deck, the heel isn’t the fore triangle specified in these magnified by working through measurement rules is typically a long lever arm. (see Figure 1.) A fore triangle is mea- Figure 1 provides the gen- eral nomenclature for a ed. You may set any size sail using the genoa jib. Learning the jibstay position that defined the I and J lingo is a good first step measurements. So, if the sail is set out- in approaching things side the fore triangle, it’s not directly of the nautical per- measured, and a bigger jib—a genoa— suasion. As with can be set without changing the rating. jib club on the foot, the genoa fills the fore triangle better. It will usually have Sailrite Kits, Colur Figure 1. Genoa jib nomenclature & “ J & a deck-sweeping foot, which acts to y, seal off the gap between the sail and the deck, thereby eliminating the Me | 430° \p under-boom vortex of air leakage. For years, the “end-plate effect” has been IN / Head What’s in a Name? sured, the rating of the yacht calculat- Compared with a working jib with a () mostly heel; but, because the after International A Class rules do, 0.85 x Another variable characteristic of Clew ne | J praised for its beneficial influence on performance. Except for C.A. Marchaj (1979), I’ve never seen anything in J ere Ie Tack print that quantifies the benefit. The Short of It Genoas used for model yachting have a few shortcomings. As mentioned NOVEMBER 1995 47 GENOA JIBS Cx = design entry angle 8 =jibstay sagged entry angle Figure 2. Genoa jib entry angle and the effect of jibstay sag. ie genoas is the height of the clew off the tively with the standing rigging while inches, depending on the size of the deck. Because there isn’t a skipper tacking procedures are worked out. sail). The camber is usually from 15 aboard to have his view blocked, most The established model yacht sailmak- to 18 percent of chord, and maximum model yachts are rigged with deck- ers have experience with genoas, but depth is between 40 and 45 percent sweeping genoas. In heavier air sail- they aren’t likely to insist that they’re behind the luff. ing, high-clewed genoas prevent dragging in the water, but most model experts. In 25 years at the sewing If this is your first genoa, make the machine, I’ve probably made 20 to 25 foot %4 inch too big; this provides some skippers change to a somewhat smaller of them for boats from 36 inches to 8 insurance if you find that you have to sail—usually a working jib of 85 to 90 feet in length, and each one was re-cut the luff curve to better match percent LP. unique. This is not to say that you shouldn’t have a go at producing one yourself. your jibstay shape while sailing. A Getting Started For discussions of big-boat genoas, read the section on draft control in Ross’ (1975) book, “Sail Power.” It’s on pages 101 to 112, and it’s an excellent introduction to the shape of genoas. Additional information on design can be found in the chapter on shapes of cruising and racing sails in Tom Whidden’s book, “The Art and Science of Sails.” Sail design begins with a consideration of your boat, the location of its side shrouds and spreaders and the method by which sheeting of the clew of the sail can be accomplished. Because the gear needed to handle the sail will add weight to the boat, your hull form will need to have some reserve buoyancy. Most genoas sheet outside of the shrouds, so the genoa lead block can be mounted right on the gunwale; some sort of a track might be a good approach to allow quick movement. Figure 1 shows a generic genoa sheet lead angle to extend from the midpoint of the luff to the clew and then onto the deck. This is a first approximation, so it will need to be fine-tuned once the sail has been made. The side profile at 130 percent shown in Figure 1 might be a bit exces- sive for the first experiment; though 120 percent might be a little less spectacular, it will require a bit less sheet and will be less likely to interact nega48 RADIO CONTROL BOAT MODELER Luff Stuff A “bar tight” jibstay is very important, because when it sags, the sail is likely to develop too much camber in its leading edge. An S-curve should be cut into the luff. I’m satisfied with a simple hollow luff with a maximum hollow at 35 to 45 percent of the way up the luff; the percentage will vary from boat to boat. For your first attempt, make the luff die straight; you can always get fancy later at the cost of a few square inches of sail area. Clearance for the spreaders can be problematic in the upper third of the sail; often, a combination of hollowing the leech of the sail and lowering the head can improve the situation. Be sure to leave an open slot in the upper parts to allow good air circulation between the main and the genoa. Choking off the slot where the highest velocity of air is available will substantially diminish performance. Shaping Most model genoas are made of mulltiple panels. The relatively small loads that are applied to model yacht sails allow you to make the panels horizontal, especially if a non-directional fiber material such as micafilm Mylar is used. Individual panels should be no narrower than 10 inches (even 15 genoa hanging parallel to the ground on a test rack doesn’t really reproduce the wind loading or the jibstay shape, so the sail will look significantly different on the boat loaded with wind. To allow you to assess the sail’s shape when the boat is under way, add two or three contrasting “draft stripes.” Designing a Sail There are two ways to approach designing a sail. e You can start with the overall sail, choose its outline and then work downward to develop the shape and orientation of the individual panels. This is a top-down procedure. ¢ Alternatively, you can start with the strength requirements necessary to carry the loads that are expected for the sail, and work upward—in a bottom-up procedure. For our purposes, we will take the bottom-up procedure because it will give us the opportunity to consider the various physical constraints that must be dealt with for the sail to do its job properly. Strength How strong must the sail membrane material be to carry the loads that the rig and the wind will impose on it? A genoa is supported only by a jibstay; both the leech and the foot are totally loose, restrained only by the sheet at the clew. Few measurements have been made of the forces that act on sail models. An upper limit can be set by considering the kinds of forces that are being borne by the rigging, because those forces are generated by the sails. surface roughness. even a spoiler. It will convert the ¢ Minimal panel seams as projected on wind’s laminar-flow energy into turbu- the wind flow pattern across the sail. lence, thereby reducing the pressure Dr. Larry Robinson pioneered the Three or four kinds of cloth with yel- direct measurement of shroud and stay tensions among the current crop of Pacific Northwest East Coast 12-meter rigs. He discovered that stay tensions greater than 8 to 10 pounds were rarely, if ever, encountered in properly rigged and tuned boats. Tensions in a lowish Mylar radial patches coming ful genoa is the ability to control out from each corner look neat, but this and maintain the appropriate entry construction method produces vertical angle. As shown in Figure 2, the seams that can destroy the power- angle between the luff tangent and backstay have not been measured of stiff material, and the result is a sail pressure, it will move aft and leeward. while under way (thougha strain with a polygonal cross-section rather Notice how the sail’s leading edge gauge seems to be a simple device that could be employed), but 30-pound test, stranded rigging wire seems to work well. The plastic-covered wire typically than a smooth curve. Stiff corner patches are often found on tall, high- curves differently and the entry angle aspect sails such as in the M-class. helmsman must bear off, pointing The result is insufficient camber in lower and not making distance to fails at the swaging points where the the upper third of the sail, and that windward as he did before. wires attach to turnbuckles or the effectively depowers it. mast. difference that gives the sail the ability When you make a model sail, the to produce drive. goal isn’t to duplicate a big boat sail. One of the key features of a power- producing laminar flow of air across the chord of the sail controls how close the leading area of the sail. Some you can point with advantage to the genoas I’ve seen use varied thicknesses wind. If the jibstay sags under wind increases. To keep the sail full, the Jibstay Assessment Tests for the 2-ounce Dacron and lightweight micafilm molars available for sails show that the former does not fail mechanically, but it loses its dimensional stability when the sail Drag loses its shape owing to the break- changes in overall sail shape may be the system so that measurements can down of the resin binder in the cloth. Even old Dacron doesn’t fail as a material under the stress of taking a typical model yacht to weather. The micafilms don’t fail mechanically either, even under the stress of heavy air sailing. It’s more likely that glued or stitched panel seams will come apart, especially in the leeches of similar in the magnitude of their effect be made. Photos from dead ahead will on lift and drag as are differences in surface roughness. quantify sag of the jibstay to leeward. sails that are allowed to flog. We can therefore conclude that modern sail membranes that are used on models typical of our sport are not operating anywhere near their ultimate meaningful if it can be measured when for rough versus smooth sail construc- the boat is moving through the water tion is difficult, probably because there is a flexible airfoil involved. Small and the sail is full of wind. Photo- graphs are an excellent way to freeze Photos from abeam will show the fore and aft sag. For a scale factor, put some Small airfoils, working at low black-tape stripes on the mast a foot or speeds, small Reynolds numbers… where do you find them? Glider wings! None of the local R/C glider pilots would knowingly put wings with big seams and joints on their fuselages; drag would increase and lift would so apart. And remember to measure the wind strength as you go along, or you won’t be able to make sense of the data. decrease. To compare the lift on our vertical Figure 3. Genoa sheet wings (sails) that pro- lead block. ability to carry the loads. Because of how woven Dacron cloth can become deformed, sail makers orient the fabric so that loads are carried along a thread line. Unwoven membranes, such as the vides the drive to the Mylars, have absolutely no require- roughness, do every- ment for orientation under the loads thing you can to elimi- imposed by models; panel arrange- nate discontinuities in ment of Mylar sails must be guided by your sails. Use as few considerations other than strength. In order of importance, the major panels as possible, ori- factors governing panel layout are: they are parallel to the anticipated airflow. A ° The ability of the sail to assume and maintain the design entry angle, camber and maximum camber location through its intended wind range design. ¢ Development of a smooth, threedimensional surface with minimum The assessment of jibstay shape is only Directly measuring drag coefficients hull to glider wings seems a pretty good bet. To minimize drag caused by surface ent the panels so that double thickness of cloth, a layer of double- sided seam tape and 72” Radius some stitching will act just like a turbulator or NOVEMBER 1995 49 BLAZER GENOA JIBS R.C. BOAT WORKS Having developed an idea of the SE i aR F-41 STRIKER the horizontal, as shown in Figure 3. range, use a flexible, constant-section At present, blocks with bevels of 1.5, 2, batten to draw that curve parallel to the edge of your worktable. Carefully undo the main luff tabling (hem) of the 3 and 5 degrees seem to cover the sail. Tape the head, and at the ends of the new luff curve line, tack it down onto your worktable at the ends of the new luff curve line you drew. Lift the clew off the table, and hold it up to J & G MUSCLE MACHINE 22.5cc 4.9HP@ 14500 RPM allow gravity to pull the designed camber into the sail. Then use the flexible batten to duplicate the jibstay curve you drew. Mark the sail for the new tabling—% inch inside the batten edge. 3.7HP@ 14300 RPM GASOLINE POWERED CATS, VEES, HYDROS READY TO RUN, KITS, PARTS, HULLS, ENGINES BLAZER R.C. BOAT WORKS 10421 S. CICEROAVE. OAK LAWN, IL 60453 708-422-7370 (PHONE/FAX) 8906 LaDona CT. FOUNTAIN VALLEY, CA 92708 714-842-2632 CATALOGAND VIDEO – $14.95 CATALOG – $2.00 50 RADIO CONTROL BOAT MODELER right. Blocks are identified by a 4-digit number: the first two digits are the block radius, and the last two are the angle drop from the center line. The blocks described above are therefore: 7205, 7203, 7202 and 7201.5. If you make a sail with four panels and three panel seams, start with the discussion of this, see the chapter on Carefully analyze the shape that you percent camber for a light air—or Number 1—genoa, with the maximum draft located 40 to 45 percent from the seam down: 7202, 7201.5, 7201.5. get in the finished sail, and change a block or two on the next sail you make. For example, go to a 7203 on the top seam if the head of the sail was not sufficiently cambered. Remember that as leading edge. Because it is meant to fly in heavier air, a Number 3 genoa will have 10 to 15 percent camber, and it will have its maximum draft at only 35 to 40 percent of the way of aft. This the camber increases, so does the entry configuration will react to jibstay sag genoa jib, why not add your sheeting that’s caused by the heavy air by moving the draft back in the sail to the 40 percent area where performance will be acceptable. A Number 2 genoa will design and a description of your equipment to the lore of model yachting? Send me some good-quality, high- obviously be midway between these two extremes. angle, so make changes slowly. Share Your Thoughts If you’ve rigged and sailed with a contrast photos of your genoa; a description of the boat it’s on; how you did it; and how it works. There are lots of good ideas out there that deserve to Twists and Blocks be pulled together and shown off. Typical twists in a genoa will be in the We’ll do it here. 20- to 25″degree range. Some are accounted for by the velocity gradient TWO LOCATIONS TO SERVE YOUR RC BOAT NEEDS 7:30 PM to 10:30 PM WEEKNIGHTS only turn out as good as the blocks, so spend adequate time getting things following series of blocks from the top Tom Whidden recommends 15 to 18 BLAZER G-23 ZENOHA 22.5cc requirements pretty well. The sails will Then cut the cloth at the batten, fold it over, and sew it back up. For further genoa design in Tom Whidden’s book. QUICKDRAW 28cc TO 140cc 35cc 6.6 HP@ 15000 RPM both sides of the center line down from amount of sag at your target wind of the wind, and additional twist is required because of the interaction between the main and genoa. Twist is controlled by the shape built into the sail, but also by the angle of the sheet lead relative to the clew of the sail and the amount of tension carried in the sheet. Tensions are balanced in the foot and leech by adjusting the position of the genoa sheet lead block on the deck. As wind strength varies, the position of this block will change. The actual seams that put the shape into the body of the sail are developed with a set of building blocks. For general model yachting use, blocks with a radius of approximately 72 inches seem to have been a good compromise. The top of the blocks receive a bevel on While you have your correspon- dence equipment out, tuck in a stamped, self-addressed, business-size envelope, and I will return to you the latest version of the Model Yachting Source List. After years of waiting for someone else to develop a listing of the sources for all the bits and pieces that model yachtsmen need, I finally just put my head down and bulled my way through. The Source List has already grown to four closely spaced pages and is expanding every day from contributions made by folks who obtained early copies. It covers everything from kits and fittings to plans and sails. Rod Carr, 3011-177th Ave. NE, Redmond, WA 98052. L





