Model Racing Yachts: Their Architecture, Design, Building, and Handling by BH Priest, and JA Lewis – 1966

Model Racing Yachts is a comprehensive treatment of the design and sailing of competitive model yachts by two accomplished British designers and skippers, B. H. Priest and J. A. Lewis. It begins with the naval architecture of small sailing craft—displacement, resistance, keel design, stability, hull balance, lines drawing, and sail plans—and explains how these interdependent choices shape performance. The authors emphasize that model yachts cannot simply be scaled-down full-size boats: they sail in full-strength winds and must be designed to meet the distinctive constraints of model racing and class measurement rules.

The book then examines three principal racing classes—the 10-Rater, Marblehead 50/800, and International A Class—with close attention to rating rules, successful designs, and the evolution of competitive hull forms. Later chapters turn to practical tuning, on-the-water handling, and racing tactics, connecting design theory with the observations and adjustments that win races. A final chapter introduces construction methods. Illustrated with photographs, technical drawings, and nine fold-out yacht plans, the book serves as both a historical account of mid-century model-yacht development and a practical reference for designers, builders, and racers.

Preface. The authors explain their aim of linking basic yacht-design theory with class rules, tuning, handling, and racing experience, stressing the relevance of model experiments to full-size sailing.

Part One—The Naval Architecture of Model Racing Yachts

  • Chapter I: Introduction. Introduces the design process, the effects of racing-class restrictions, the differences between model and full-size yachts, and the interpretation of hull-lines drawings.
  • Chapter II: Displacement. Explains buoyancy and displacement and demonstrates practical volume calculations using the trapezoidal and Simpson’s rules; also considers the longitudinal distribution of underwater volume.
  • Chapter III: Resistance. Examines the forces that oppose a yacht’s movement through water, including frictional and wave-making resistance, and their implications for hull shape and speed.
  • Chapter IV: The Keel as a Salient Feature. Discusses the keel as an essential part of a model yacht’s hydrodynamic design, including its influence on lateral resistance and overall performance.
  • Chapter V: Stability and Hull Balance. Considers the ability of the hull and ballast to resist heeling and the relationship between hull form, balance, and sailing behavior.
  • Chapter VI: Drawing the Lines. Describes the drafting and fairing of the hull’s waterlines, sections, and profiles, translating design ideas into usable construction drawings.
  • Chapter VII: The Sail Plan. Explains sail-plan proportions, placement, and the interaction of mainsail and jib in producing efficient drive and balance.

Part Two

  • Chapter VIII: The 10 Rater Class Yacht. Explores the measurement rules and design choices of the 10 Rater class, showing how designers balance dimensions, sail power, and performance.

Part Three

  • Chapter IX: The Marblehead 50/800 Class. Reviews the Marblehead class and the development of successful 50-inch, 800-square-inch designs, including differences in hull shape and sailing characteristics.

Part Four—The International ‘A’ Class

  • Chapter X: Rating Rules. Sets out the rating-rule background needed to understand the design and measurement of International A Class yachts.
  • Chapter XI: The International ‘A’ Class Rule and its Operation. Explains how the rule works in practice and how its measurement provisions influence the combinations of hull, ballast, and sail dimensions.
  • Chapter XII: Pre-war Under the Rule. Traces early A Class racing designs and the developments that emerged before the Second World War.
  • Chapter XIII: Post-war Development Under the ‘A’ Class Rule. Follows changes in A Class design after the war and considers how leading boats and designers advanced the class.
  • Chapter XIV: The Development of a Design. Uses the evolution of particular designs to illustrate practical decisions, compromises, and improvements in yacht architecture.

Part Five—Tuning, Handling and Racing Tactics

  • Chapter XV: Tuning. Details the adjustments to rig, sails, steering, and balance used to obtain the best performance in different wind conditions.
  • Chapter XVI: Handling. Discusses sailing and controlling a model yacht, including the skipper’s response to the boat’s behavior on different points of sail.
  • Chapter XVII: Racing Tactics. Examines competitive decisions such as positioning, wind advantage, and encounters with other yachts on the racecourse.

Part Six

  • Chapter XVIII: Construction. Outlines practical methods and considerations for building model-yacht hulls and related structural elements.

Index to Fold-out Plans

  • Plan I: Lines of Top Hat ‘A’ Class. Hull lines for the International A Class design Top Hat.
  • Plan II: Lines of Whirlwind 10-rater. Lines drawing of the 10 Rater Whirlwind.
  • Plan III: Lines of Witchcraft Marblehead. Lines drawing for the Marblehead yacht Witchcraft.
  • Plan IV: Lines of Witch Marblehead. Lines drawing for the Marblehead yacht Witch.
  • Plan V: Lines of Bewitched Marblehead. Lines drawing for the Marblehead yacht Bewitched.
  • Plan VI: Lines of Commando ‘A’ Class. Lines drawing for the International A Class yacht Commando.
  • Plan VII: Lines of Saxon ‘A’ Class. Lines drawing for the International A Class yacht Saxon.
  • Plan VIII: Lines of Highlander ‘A’ Class. Lines drawing for the International A Class yacht Highlander.
  • Plan IX: Lines of Moonshine ‘A’ Class. Lines drawing for the International A Class yacht Moonshine.
ode] Macing VOcwnis by B.H. Priest, M.I.Mar.E., and J.A.Lewis —S MODEL RACING YACHTS There are probably no two people better qualified to write a book on the arts of present-day model yachting than Dick Priest and John Lewis. Between them they have designed the majority of the top boats in important races in the last few years; both are outstanding ‘A’ class designers, Lewis is a top-line 10-rater architect, and Priest especially strong on Marbleheads. Thus the three main classes are completely covered by their combined experience. Practically, they are once again completely complementary, with Priest the really experienced racing man and Lewis, no mean skipper, of a highly experimental turn of mind. Both have deep sea experience, and Priest has considerable dinghy racing behind him, while Lewis has been responsible for experimental work connected with full-size sailing craft of a highly successful nature. Both build yachts, fittings, etc. As mentioned in the book, both were members of the same model yacht club for years, and worked together on research and basic design analysis, etc. While each produces individual designs, there is a similarity of conception and execution, not to mention a similarity in the long string of successes enjoyed by boats built to their designs! With such impressive qualifications, the publishers have confidence in offering this book as the finest ever written on the subject—a book which will be fascinating to any interested in the design and handling of yachts of any size, and one which will be the standard text-book for model yachtsmen for many years to come. Published by MODEL & ALLIED PUBLICATIONS LTD. 13/35 Bridge Street, Hemel Hempstead, Herts. Publishers of model books, plans, etc, and the following periodicals: Model Boats Model Cars Model Engineer Aeromodeller Model Railway News oo Radio Control Models and Electronics 49s. MODEL RACING YACHTS Their architecture, design, construction, and handling By B. H. Priest, M.I.Mar.E. and J. A. Lewis Model & Allied Publications Ltd (13 /35 Bridge Street, Hemel Hempstead, Hertfordshire Other Titles: RADIO CONTROL MANUAL No. 2 SIMPLE ELECTRIC CAR RACING BOAT MODELLING MODEL MAKER ANNUAL THE AMATEUR ROD-MAKER FLYING SCALE MODELS AEROMODELLER ANNUAL AIRCRAFT IN MINIATURE USING THE SMALL LATHE MODEL AERO ENGINE ENCYCLOPAEDIA POWER MODEL BOATS AEROMODELLER POCKET DATA BOOK GLASS FIBRE FOR AMATEURS SIMPLE RADIO CONTROL CONTROL LINE MANUAL VANE STEERING GEARS SECRETS OF SHIPS IN BOTTLES MULTI-CHANNEL RADIO CONTROL Further titles to be announced regularly Trade Distributors: ARGUS PRESS LIMITED 12/18 PAUL STREET, LONDON, E.C.2 PRINTED AND BOUND IN ENGLAND BY HAZELL WATSON AND VINEY LTD AYLESBURY, BUCKS Contents Preface Part One—The Naval Architecture of Model Racing Yachts Chapter I Introduction Chapter IT Displacement 10 Chapter III Resistance 15 Chapter IV The Keel as a Salient Feature 20 Chapter V Stability and Hull Balance 22 Chapter VI Drawing the Lines 26 Chapter VII ‘The Sail Plan 32 The 10 Rater Class Yacht 36 Part Two Chapter VIII Part Three Chapter IX = The Marblehead 50/800 Class 45 Part Four—The International ‘A’ Class Chapter X Rating Rules Chapter XI The International ‘A’ Class Rule and its Chapter XII Pre-war Under the Rule Chapter XIII Post-war Development Under the ‘A’ Class Chapter XIV The Development of a Design Operation Rule 52 55 58 62 71 Part Five—Tuning, Handling and Racing Tactics Chapter XV‘ Tuning 80 Chapter XVI Handling 92 Chapter XVII Racing Tactics 102 Part Six Chapter XVIII Construction 107 Index to fold-out plans Plan I Lines of Top Hat ‘A’ Class Plan IT Lines of Whirlwind 10-rater 40 Plan III Lines of Witchcraft Marblehead 46 Plan IV Lines of Witch Marblehead 50 Plan V Lines of Bewitched Marblehead 54 Plan VI Lines of Commando ‘A’ Class 74 Plan VII Lines of Saxon ‘A’ Class 78 Plan VII Lines of Highlander ‘A’ Class 90 Plan IX Lines of Moonshine ‘A’ Class 100 Preface Tuts book is the endeavour of two men to describe the science of Model Yachting from A to Z, from the very basics of design, through the application of design to the various rating rules, and on to tuning and handling. The book has been written to be of help not only to Model Yachtsmen but to those who sail Twelve-Metre boats, 5:5 Metre boats, Dragons or Dinghies. This might be considered an ambitious statement and that there can be little or no connection between one who designs and sails a model and one who designs and sails a Twelve-Metre yacht. Within the book it will be found that there is in fact quite a real con- nection. Taking design for an example, as applied to the International ‘A’ Class rule, it will be realised that we have as yet less then twenty registered numbers in the Twelve- Metre Rule in the country, whilst the International ‘A’ class models are nearly up to a registered number of eight hundred. Design to a rating rule is built up from a number of interrelated curves and factors. These can be combined in an infinite number of manners. As all design is a compromise then how these factors are combined decides whether a good or a bad boat has been produced. It is often said that nothing is new in yacht design, it has all been tried before. This is, of course true, but by altering all the things that can be varied then a brand new type of design can be produced. It would be logic to assume that the model designer, in the course of the thirty odd years that the International ‘A’ Class Rating Rule has been in use, has just about tried the lot and in so doing has evolved a type of boat miles ahead of the old originals. Just how this evolution took place must be of interest to every serious designer. It might be said that the Twelve-Metre designer has the advantage of being able to have his products tank tested. This is correct, but it must be remembered that the tank will only compare, say, four different designs; it will say which of them is the best under different wind ranges. It will not, however, say whether the products are good, bad, or indifferent. All four might be bad and the tank will only find the best of a bad bunch. A great deal has been written on the magic thing called Tuning. In this field the model man has a great advantage. He is not in the boat but is able to walk alongside it and so observe its every action. Because of this he has been able to devise a most scientific approach to the whole question, so much so that his final windward tune is reduced to no more than a degree on the helm or an eighth of an inch on the sheeting trim. The authors are only too aware, from practical experience, of the problems of trying to tune a yacht when sitting in it. Under these conditions everything is confused to a degree. Is it mast position, sheeting angle, or sail flow? Is the boat being pinched or is she having to be held up on her course? All this is simple to the experienced model yachtsman. By observation alone he can tell at once which point it is that requires correction. It is remarkable how few people have the faintest conception of how to set about the tuning of a boat, or even what are the major factors to be considered. For this reason the whole subject has been set down from its basics and the writers have endeavoured to guide the reader through the subject in what they consider the correct manner. If they have done their job correctly then the obvious conclusion will be that the only correct manner to tune an America’s Cup Challenger will be by having its designer up in the air to observe its conduct during competitive trials. The authors have set about this book because they believe that there is now a need for it and, on paper, that they are the most fitted to tackle the job. They base this assumption on the fact that in the three major classes sailed in the country, boats to their designs have won each of the National Championships of these classes, at least three times in each over the last ten years. It has been of great advantage that the writers have been members of the same club for a number of years and because of this have been able to talk about their designs and ideas together in a spirit of friendship and competition. It was found that their ideas were very much in sympathy, insomuch as they agreed on all major points. It will probably be found, indeed it is more than possible, that in reading through the book a divergence on minor issues will be found. Even in design it will be found that although the type of lines drawn have quite a likeness, their proportions vary. For example it will be found as a general rule that a Lewis design. has its centre of buoyancy somewhat further forward than that in a Priest design. This can only mean that the former type of design has finer after sections than those of the latter. Lewis is known to be more concerned with the actual theory of design than his co-author who has had a more practical experience. Because of this the book has naturally split itself into the fields in which the writers have felt most fitted to write—Lewis on design and the Ten Rater rule, in which field he has had his greatest success, Priest, on the other hand, on handling, tuning, and on the International ‘A’ Class, in which he is probably best known. A vast amount has been written about the art of sailing. Read though one may, it is usually found that the real crux of the matter is always left untold. Pure experience is the thing that eventually counts and this is very hard to put down in words, even if the writer wants to. In this book it has been the intention of the writers to put on paper, in the simplest manner they can devise, all the theory and experience they have encountered. In this effort they themselves believe they have succeeded. Time alone will prove if this is so, because, if it is found that design, tuning, handling, and competition have improved, the authors will consider their efforts to have been worth the labour. DICK PRIEST JOHN LEwIs PART ONE The Naval Architecture of Model Racing Yachts CHAPTER I Introduction THE designing of yachts is one of the most fascinating occupations that a man can have, particularly if he is not dependent on it for a living. It provides an outlet for his creative instincts and he can blend artistic and scientific talents in such proportions as pleases him. A great deal of research work is being done on yacht design but it will be a long time before designing becomes so highly technical that the man with a good eye and a feeling for a boat cannot compete successfully. He must of course be aware of developments but he need not have more than a basic knowledge of naval architecture. All yacht designs are produced to satisfy a particular specification. This may be in the form of Racing Class Rules or the requirements of the future owner. Sometimes the needs of the owner will not produce a satisfactory yacht and this is only one of the professional designer’s worries. The professional designer has also the responsibility of spending large sums of money and this is bound to check experimental development. Tank testing of sailing yacht models is interesting, expensive and provides data which can often be misleading. The designer’s brain and vision are still the most important elements of success. The model yacht designer is free of many of the restrictions of the designer of full scale craft and his job is considerably easier. He does not have to consider the con- structional problems of a design except in a most rudimentary way, he does not have to accommodate a crew, nor does he need seriously to consider seaworthiness. He can, if he is designing to one of the Racing Class Rules, concentrate all his efforts into producing the fastest form of hull to suit the particular rule. The Rule is his specification and as such must be thoroughly understood by him. He should be familiar with work of other designers and he should take every opportunity of seeing models performing under all conditions of wind and water. One of the worrying things about designing is the pendulum of fashion. When a successful yacht appears on the scene there is a tendency for the design features of that yacht to be pushed steadily to extremes by unintelligent development. If this occurs slowly the bad features do not show up until someone moves in the opposite direction and starts winning prizes. So, whilst being aware of the latest designs, also beware, and do not imitate for fashion’s sake. The basic laws of naval architecture in the determination of hull form are the same for model yachts as for large sailing yachts. There is no similarity between racing models and 8 racing dinghies or other forms of sailing craft which plane at high speeds on the surface of the water. Model yachts do in fact plane extremely rapidly but they do so under conditions in which full-size craft would not survive. The model yacht architect should look at designs of over 30 ft. length if he is seeking inspiration or guidance. Although the design process is similar it does not follow that a good model would necessarily be a good yacht if scaled up to full-size. It is equally true that success in full-size cannot be scaled down to a model. This brings us back to the importance of the initial specification. The wind does not accommodate itself to the requirements of the model designer and so his small yacht has to contend with a full scale wind. The water is also out of scale in density and due to the small expanse on which races take place it is very rare for the waves to exceed the length of a modern 10 rater or International A class model. Models have to race in wind strengths of up to 40 m.p.h. and therefore need to be extremely powerful and stable. Model races continue long after full-scale regattas cancel their events and the ocean racing chaps would be more water. concerned with survival than speed through the This does not mean to say that model designing cannot contribute usefully in the development of full-size yachts. In fact the model designer is in a position of advantage due to his freedom, and the intelligent use of his knowledge by the full scale designer could be of considerable value. This is becoming more and more recognised as a fact in yachting circles and it is a great pity that there are so few model designers who are pursuing a steady line of development towards improving design generally. A yacht to be satisfying as well as satisfactory should be a thing of beauty. Fortunately those features which produce what is acceptable as beauty fit in quite well with the require- ments of performance. The shape of a model does not have to be distorted in order to accommodate crew or passengers. It is as difficult to define what makes a yacht beautiful as it is difficult to describe why a picture is beautiful but there are certain features which can be learnt by anyone. However, it is the designer’s basic instinct for beauty of form and line which ultimately determine the final appearance. A good design does not need fashionable gimmicks to help it. The following chapters will explain various aspects of yacht architecture which are useful to the designer of model yachts. The information is treated under separate headings for simplicity but it should always be remembered that it is ove TOP HAT DESIGNED BY John Lewis . COPYRIGHT OF MODEL MAKER PLANS SERVICE 38. CLARENDON RD. WATFORD, HERTS INTERNATIONAL A CLASS SCALE: Ye FULL SIZE. 55:0″ 81-25″ DISPLACEMENT 60:0 LBS. (46 LBS. LEAD) 14-25″ LWL. BEAM 12-2″ DRAUGHT LWL. LOA, 11-74″ (1620 CU.INS) Yo QBL AV.F 52-06″ 4-4″ S. AREA 1604 SQ INS. 40°03 SA. FULL SIZE FIGURE 2 8] BODY PLAN YACHT SAIL PLAN va SCALE IST —25-0″ 2ND,3RD,4TH — 24-5″ | LEAD LINE —64-0″ | IST suIT 2ND. + 80-0″ 3RD. + 65:0″ 4TH. + 60-0″ 72-0″ IST. 2ND. 605″ 54.5″ 3RD. 505″ 4TH 455″ (ST -20″5 ” 2ND,3RD,4TH — 20:0″ MODEL RACING YACHTS “Vv SNIT MOG fe} fer D c D m m 5 fe) a3 fe) fe) Zz Zz ie | aundld > fe} na i Qa Zz wo ‘@ SNIT MOG |se m > 7) wn n ay fe) fe) D no} x > =A, ol ETM. ‘@ ADOLLNG VADOLLING i t_ y 7 Z cOvid ‘DADOLLNG IMS STM. oa Zam OTM “D SNIT MOG ‘S81 O09 LNSW39DV 1dSId—O-SS “TM1 SIHL NI SANIT JO NOILD3fOUd JO NOSIYVWdWOD DINO SaTaVNA (AsioDwaxXa DNILHONVYC ONILSAYSLNI NV) YAINNWW LTA > SoS a ee i ai | The representation of the shape of a yacht hull by means of a lines drawing can be a most absorbing essay in draughtsmanship. Whilst some superb drawings can be produced it is not essential to be a skilled draughtsman as long as due care is taken and a high standard- of accuracy is maintained. As in all good drawing each individual line has a definite meaning and Figs. | and 2 illustrate how the various hull lines interrelate. In the horizontal plane the ‘Level Lines’ or what are more commonly called ‘Waterlines’ show the shape of the hull at various distances above and below the ‘Load Water Line’ (L.W.L.) which is itself the plane of flotation of the hull at its designed displacement. The ‘Buttock Lines’ show the hull shape in the vertical plane parallel to the longitudinal centre line. These lines should more accurately be called ‘Bow Lines’ from midships forwards and ‘Buttock Lines’ from midships aft. The cross sections show the transverse shape of the yacht and it is on these shapes that the most important calculations are based. _ The lines ‘indicating the shape in an inclined plane are known as diagonals and these are most valuable in quickly arriving at a truly fair hull. The projected set of lines in Fig. 1 is not particularly useful in design but it does illustrate the use of lines and gives 2) 4 m a S ee a ee ee The meaning of the hull lines drawing an Zz Dv D NAHM JIT AOOT TIM TINH VW LYHM JO NOISSAYdHI TWIYOLDId VW SAAID GNV SOLLSIYSLOVYVHD TINH the amalgamation of all the considerations which make a good or bad design and that change in one feature is bound to cause change in other features. Only the designer himself can choose just how far he is prepared to push the advantages in certain directions and thereby accept the disadvantages in other directions. The designer must decide whether he is going to limit the yacht to a good heavy weather performance, a good light weather performance, or try and produce a good all-rounder. It is much easier to design for extreme conditions than to compromise and try for excellent results at all wind strengths. The easiest design to prepare is that for a good heavy weather boat when practically everything can be sacrificed to length and power. The light weather boat is probably the most entertaining of them all, as all sorts of architectural devices can be employed in order to reduce wetted surface area and skin friction. There is no need to consider only sheer maximum speed for a given length. The differences in hull form for low resistance at high and low speeds will be dealt with in a later chapter. The most difficult design is that intended to combine good light weather and heavy weather ability. In fact it is impossible for a compromise design to equal an extreme design in its own particular conditions, and the term ‘good all-rounder’ is rather a misnomer. The compromise design will always stand a chance of being beaten under any particular conditions but whereas the extreme designs will win races under their ideal conditions they could also be well down the finishing order on many occasions. The compromise design will win fewer first prizes but may constantly be in the top four and for this reason most model racing skippers prefer the compromise with a slight bias towards the average conditions in their particular locality. The fact that a model yacht has to operate over a wide speed range makes the problem interesting and it is very doubtful whether there will ever be finality in design. In the case of powered craft, which are usually required to travel at a fixed economic speed, for a given length the hull form is more or less predetermined. MODEL RACING YACHTS a good impression of the hull form in three dimensions. The normal layout comprises a plan, an elevation, and a set of cross-sections. In the plan the centre line, buttock lines and cross-sections appear as straight lines whilst the waterlines are curved. The elevation or profile contains the waterlines and cross-sections as straight lines and the curved lines are the bow lines and buttocks. The set of cross sections is commonly called the Body Plan but is really a.set of superimposed transverse sections. INTERNATIONAL “A” CLASS “YEOMAN” BEATING TO WINDWARD IN SECOND SUIT. GOSPORT 1952 CHAPTER II Displacement IF a yacht were to be placed in a tank which is brim full of water a certain quantity of water would spill over the sides of the tank and be ‘displaced’. Now it is a fundamental law that the weight of the displaced water would exactly equal the weight of the yacht and the volume of the displaced water would exactly equal the immersed volume of the hull. If weight is added to the yacht it will sink deeper into the water until the volume or weight of displaced water again exactly equals the new weight of the yacht and thereby also equals the new immersed volume. If more and more weight is added a condition is reached when the volume of the hull is insufficient to displace the necessary weight of water and the yacht will sink. This serious state of affairs does not occur very often but all too frequently a yacht does not float on its correct waterline plane because either the designer has made a mistake in his calculations or the builder has ignored the constructional weight set out by the designer. 10 People are often quite muddled when thinking about displacement. For example it is surprising the number who believe that filling a hull with table tennis balls would cause it to float higher out of the water whereas in fact the hull would sink lower, as its displacement is increased by the weight of the celluloid! The two most important decisions a designer has to take are in deciding what waterline length the yacht needs to be and to what displacement he shall shape the hull. As an alteration in weight will alter the depth at which the hull floats so will alter, therefore, the load waterline length. It is essential then for the designer to be able to calculate the volume of the hull below his chosen L.W.L. so that he knows accurately the resulting displacement. If the calculation shows that the displacement is different from that required, then the designer has to redraw the hull accordingly until the answer is correct. The calculation of displacement is the only absolutely MODEL RACING YACHTS necessary piece of mathematics needed in hull design and fortunately it is easy enough for anyone to do providing one of two formulae is accepted without worrying about the derivation. The two methods most commonly used are known as Simpson’s Rule and the Trapezoidal Rule, and to illustrate the working of these rules we will run through the enon of a typical 10-rater design of 55 in. waterline ength. It is usual for a designer to divide the L.W.L. length into 10 equal parts and the body plan therefore will show the cross-section of the hull at eleven positions along the L.W.L. It is convenient to number these sections 0 to 10 starting from the bow ending. It is necessary to measure the area of each of the cross-sections below the L.W.L. and if much designing is contemplated it is well worth buying a planimeter. This instrument will enable the job to be done quickly and accurately. They are very expensive if bought new, some £14 to £25, but can often be bought for less than £3 second-hand, from pawnbrokers. Try to find a shop near a university! Failing a planimeter the areas can be arrived at by using ,4, in. squared paper as shown in Fig. 3. This is quite accurate but somewhat tedious. Having arrived at the areas of the under-water parts of the sections we can apply one or other of the rules but remember that the sections only show half the total areas and the final figure must be doubled to give the true volume. With this rule you simply take half of the area of the first and last section (usually in a yacht design these areas are zero),’total up the areas of the other sections and multiply the result by the distance between the sections. Remember to keep the units of measurement the same, i.e. inches and square inches, and the result will be in cubic inches. The figures for a typical 10 rater are as follows: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 4 Section number Area sq. in. 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0-00 1-15 5-52 9-95 14-76 20-00 16-35 9-73 5-70 2:15 10 0-00 Rule multiplier Area sq. in. 0-00 1-15 5:52 9-95 14-76 20-00 16-35 9-73 5-70 2:15 0-00 Rule multiplier – 0-5 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0-5 Multiply by 2 for total areas. Multiply by section spacing i.e. 5-5 for actual volume. 1 lb. of fresh water equals 27-7 cu. in. Totals 0-00 1-15 5-52 9-95 14-76 20-00 16-35 9-73 5:70 2:15 0-00 Totals 1 0-00 4 2 4 4-60 11-04 39-80 2 4 29-52 80-00 2 4 2 4 1 32-70 38-92 11-40 8-60 0-00 Multiply by 2 for total areas The Trapezoidal Rule $ Section number render the use of the Trapezoidal rule inadvisable. Simpson’s Rule is more popular in this country whereas on the Continent and in the U.S.A. the trapezoidal rule is more frequently employed. It is essential that the body whose volume is being calculated is divided longitudinally into an even number of parts, i.e. there must be an odd number of sections. Using the same section numbering as in the previous example you take areas of numbers 0 and 10 and add them to the areas of 1, 3, 5, 7, and 9 multiplied by 4 and the areas of 2, 4, 6, and 8 multiplied by 2. The total is then multiplied by the distance between the sections divided by 3. 256:58 x2 Multiply by oe for actual volume 512-16 : x 1-83 = 937-25 For fresh water divide by 27°7 = “7° — 33-83 Ib, For salt water divide by 27:0 = ar = 34-71 Ib. FIGURE 3 Note. Put good quality paper divided in ‘/Oths. under area to be measured and count Tedious squares, but accurate. 85-31 x 2 170-62 x 5:5 938-41 + 27:7 mt rT Tt therefore divide by 27-7 for actual displacement — 33-87 lb. or 1 lb. salt water equals 27-0 cu. in. divide by 27-0 for salt water displacement = 34-75 Ib. Ignore squares where area is less than half Count squares where area is more than half Simpson’s Rule This rule is more complicated than the Trapezoidal rule but is slightly more accurate although not sufficiently so to Use of squared paper 11 MODEL RACING YACHTS a good impression of the hull form in three dimensions. The normal layout comprises a plan, an elevation, and a set of cross-sections. In the plan the centre line, buttock lines and cross-sections appear as straight lines whilst the waterlines are curved. The elevation or profile contains the waterlines and cross-sections as straight lines and the curved lines are the bow lines and buttocks. The set of cross sections is commonly called the Body Plan but is really a set of superimposed transverse sections. INTERNATIONAL “A” CLASS “YEOMAN” BEATING TO WINDWARD IN SECOND SUIT. GOSPORT 1952 CHAPTER II Displacement IF a yacht were to be placed in a tank which is brim full of water a certain quantity of water would spill over the sides of the tank and be ‘displaced’. Now it is a fundamental law that the weight of the displaced water would exactly equal the weight of the yacht and the volume of the displaced water would exactly equal the immersed volume of the hull. If weight is added to the yacht it will sink deeper into the water until the volume or weight of displaced water again exactly equals the new weight of the yacht and thereby also equals the new immersed volume. If more and more weight is added a condition is reached when the volume of the hull is insufficient to displace the necessary weight of water and the yacht will sink. This serious state of affairs does not occur very often but all too frequently a yacht does not float on its correct waterline plane because either the designer has made a mistake in his calculations or the builder has ignored the constructional weight set out by the designer. 10 People are often quite muddled when thinking about displacement. For example it is surprising the number who believe that filling a hull with table tennis balls would cause it to float higher out of the water whereas in fact the hull would sink lower, as its displacement is increased by the weight of the celluloid! The two most important decisions a designer has to take are in deciding what waterline length the yacht needs to be and to what displacement he shall shape the hull. As an alteration in weight will alter the depth at which the hull floats so will alter, therefore, the load waterline length. It is essential then for the designer to be able to calculate the volume of the hull below his chosen L.W.L. so that he knows accurately the resulting displacement. If the calculation shows that the displacement is different from that required, then the designer has to redraw the hull accordingly until the answer is correct. The calculation of displacement is the only absolutely MODEL RACING YACHTS necessary piece of mathematics needed in hull design and fortunately it is easy enough for anyone to do providing one of two formulae is accepted without worrying about the derivation. The two methods most commonly used are known as Simpson’s Rule and the Trapezoidal Rule, and to illustrate the working of these rules we will run through the pail of a typical 10-rater design of 55 in. waterline length. It is usual for a designer to divide the L.W.L. length into 10 equal parts and the body plan therefore will show the cross-section of the hull at eleven positions along the L.W.L. It is convenient to number these sections 0 to 10 starting from the bow ending. It is necessary to measure the area of each of the cross-sections below the L.W.L. and if much designing is contemplated it is well worth buying a planimeter. This instrument will enable the job to be done quickly and accurately. They are very expensive if bought new, some £14 to £25, but can often be bought for less than £3 second-hand, from pawnbrokers. Try to find a shop near a university! Failing a planimeter the areas can be arrived at by using ,’, in. squared paper as shown in Fig. 3. This is quite accurate but somewhat tedious. Having arrived at the areas of the under-water parts of the sections we can apply one or other of the rules but remember that the sections only show half the total areas and the final figure must be doubled to give the true volume. lated is divided longitudinally into an even number of parts, i.e. there must be an odd number of sections. Using the same section numbering as in the previous example you take areas of numbers 0 and 10 and add them to the areas of 1, 3, 5, 7, and 9 multiplied by 4 and the areas of 2, 4, 6, and 8 multiplied by 2. The total is then multiplied by the distance between the sections divided by 3. } Section number Area sq. in. Rule multiplier Totals 0 0-00 1 1-15 1 0-00 2 4 2 + 2 4 2 4 1 11-04 39-80 29-52 80-00 32-70 38-92 11-40 8-60 0-00 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 4 5:52 9-95 14-76 20-00 16-35 9-73 5-70 2:15 0-00 4-60 Multiply by 2 for total areas The Trapezoidal Rule With this rule you simply take half of the area of the first and last section (usually in a yacht design these areas are zero), total up the areas of the other sections and multiply the result by the distance between the sections. Remember to keep the units of measurement the same, i.e. inches and square inches, and the result will be in cubic inches. The figures for a typical 10 rater are as follows: % Section number render the use of the Trapezoidal rule inadvisable. Simpson’s Rule is more popular in this country whereas on the Continent and in the U.S.A. the trapezoidal rule is more frequently employed. It is essential that the body whose volume is being calcu- Area sq. in. 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 0-00 1-15 5°52 9-95 14-76 20-00 16-35 7 8 9 10 9-73 Rule multiplier 0-5 1 1 1 1 1 1 . 5-70 2:15 0-00 1 1 1 0-5 Multiply by 2 for total areas. Multiply by section spacing i.e. 5-5 for actual volume. Totals 0-00 1-15 5-52 9-95 14-76 20-00 16-35 256°58 x2 Multiply by x? for actual volume 512-16 3 1-83 = 937-25 For fresh water divide by 27-7 = 37° _ 33-83 1b. For salt water divide by 27:0 = — = 34-71 |b. FIGURE 3 Note. Put good quality paper divided in ‘’Oths. under area to be 9-73 measured and count 5-70 2:15 0-00 Tedious squares. but accurate. 85-31 x 2 170-62 x 5-5 938-41 1 Ib. of fresh water equals 27-7 cu. in. S21 therefore divide by 27-7 for actual displacement = 33-87 Ib. or 1 Ib. salt water equals 27-0 cu. in. divide by 27-0 for salt water displacement = 34-75 lb. TT mt Tt Ignore squares where area is less than half Count squares where area is more than half Simpson’s Rule This rule is more complicated than the Trapezoidal rule but is slightly more accurate although not sufficiently so to Use of squared paper 11 MODEL RACING YACHTS Thus it will be seen that the results are very close and that the Trapezoidal rule withits simple arithmetic is good enough for all practical purposes. All the preceding remarks on displacement are referring to measured displacement under static conditions. As soon as a boat starts to travel forwards various dynamic forces come into play and in the case of very fast motor boats and hydroplanes the displacement is reduced to very small amounts. The normal buoyancy forces are replaced almost entirely by dynamic forces supporting the hull. When model yachts are planing in strong winds their actual displacement is reduced although their weight remains the same. For this reason the terms displacement and weight are not synonymous. The choice of displacement is dealt with in later chapters but remember that the heavier model yachts have been the most successful and that light displacements although very attractive have a number of disadvantages. The Curve of Areas Although it is vital for a designer to know how much a hull is going to displace he should also consider how that displacement is to be arranged in the available waterline length. He can concentrate it mostly in the middle part of the hull and have relatively sharp ends to the boat or he can distribute the volume as much as practicable into the ends of the hull. In the first instance he will be thinking in terms of a light weather yacht and in the second instance he will produce a hull with a high maximum speed most suitable for hard weather sailing. This particular issue will be dealt with more fully under discussion of speed and hull form. The graphical way of demonstrating how the displacement is distributed is to draw the curve of areas of displacement. A typical curve is shown in Fig. 4 and it will be seen that a base line A.B. is divided into 10 equal parts and vertical lines are drawn from each of the division points. These lines are known as ‘ordinates’. Number the ordinates in exactly the same way as the section numbering of the lines plan and measure along each ordinate the amount of the section area used in calculating the displacement of the hull. If the points so obtained are joined up with a fair curve the resulting figure will show the pattern of displacement distribution. The area of the figure will also be equal to the volume of the hull providing consistency has been maintained in the use of measuring units. At one time this displacement curve was thought to have great significance and it was a widely held belief that the curve should take the form ofa sine wave for its first part and. a trochoidal curve for its after part, this combination of curves being similar to the natural shape of a wave and the belief was known as the ‘Waveform Theory’. In actual fact there is no theory involving geometry of line or mathematical deduction which has any fundamental value to the design of sailing yacht hulls. For the model yacht designer the curve of area has value when used for comparing one hull form with another. The modern form of design has a distinct fin keel and it is more useful to omit the displacement of the keel when drawing the curve as it will otherwise tend to distort the shape around the midship section. Fig. 5 shows the curve of areas of the canoe bodies of the A class yachts Top Hat and Vital Spark superimposed on the sine wave and trochoidal form. It will be seen how much modern designs differ from the old theory. USING A PLANIMETER TO MEASURE THE BODY SECTION AREAS OF A DESIGN ae 4 3 7 pa 7 6 =a 4 FIGURE 5 RATERIO FARE SOFCURVETYPICAL 4 5 FIGURE 7 6 MODELSCLAS AOFARE SOFCURVES SPARK. ‘VITAL MODEL RACING YACHTS 5 13 MODEL RACING YACHTS INTERNATIONAL “A” CLASS “CONCORD” 1934. SPORTING THE OLD TYPE OF SAIL PLAN WITH SMALL JIB AND LARGE MAIN. the same way as before and using the Trapezoidal rule the set out is as follows: Section number Area/sq.in. Moment multiplier Moments ote 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 0:00 1-15 5-52 9-95 14-76 20-00: 16:35 9-73 5-70 2:15 0-00 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Sum of areas 85:31 Sum of moments 432-24 x distance between sections 0:00 1-15 11-04 29-85 59-04 100-00 98-10 68-11 45-60 19-35 0-00 432-24 5:5 = 2377-320 Divide product of moments and section spaces by the 2377:32 sum of the area: sar 7 27.86. The centre of buoyancy lies in a vertical plane 27-86 in. aft of the forward L.W.L. ending. Finding the Centre of Buoyancy Prismatic Coefficient To express it simply the Centre of Buoyancy is that point at which the volume of the underwater part of a hull would exactly balance if the shape of the volume were made in some homogenous substance. It is particularly important to know the position of this point in a longitudinal direction as the designer must arrange for it to coincide with the centre of gravity of the structure. In actual fact the two centres will automatically arrange themselves in the same place but if the designer or builder has made a mistake the yacht will either float bow down or stern down. This unhappily occurs too frequently to be amusing and is usually due to the materials of construction being differently arranged or of different density from that expected by the designer. No two yachts, either large or miniature, work out exactly the same and it is probably true to say that all designers are a little worried until they have seen the hull afloat. Fortunately for the model designer the centre of gravity of a hull tends to work out very close to the centre of buoyancy and it is a waste of time doing elaborate calculations to find the C.G. The calculations for finding the centre of buoyancy are quite simple and for an example we will use the same hull as for the displacement calculation. The cross-sectional areas are measured and tabulated in A measure of displacement distribution can be made by examining the proportions of a hull in terms of the midship sectional area, the length and the volume. The most useful formula is: 14 Volume of immersed part of hull L.W.L. x area of immersed midsection This is known as the Prismatic Coefficient and it will be appreciated that a hull of fine ends and large midship section will have a lower coefficient than one with full ends and a proportionally small midsectional area. There is a scale of coefficients said to be ideal for any particular speed but the yacht designer cannot make much use of this as his design has to contend with a very wide speed range. For low resistance at higher speeds a high prismatic coefficient is desired and it will be seen that for a given waterline length a light displacement hull can have a higher coefficient. It is probably true that for model racing yachts the prismatic coefficient should be in the range of 0-5—-0-6. The lower figure is about the highest that can be achieved in the rather heavy A class without incurring penalties’in other directions and 0-6 is a good guide for lighter 10-raters but there is little need to go higher. The actual figure for Vital Spark and Top Hat is 0:5 in each case. CHAPTER III Resistance THERE are three forms of resistances which conspire to prevent a model yacht from travelling as fast as we would wish: (a) Eddy resistance (b) Wave resistance (c) Skin friction The least important of these from a design point of view is the eddy resistance and it is obvious that there should be no sharp corners in a design. Eddies are set up wherever the flow of water leaves the surface of the hull due to an abrupt change in shape. It is the duty of the builder to make sure that trailing edges of keels and rudders are as sharp as possible and it was once the practice to sheath these edges in some full-size craft with metal in order to achieve this end. Now that satisfactory adhesives are available it might be worth while gluing metal strip to these edges in models and to sharpen them to a greater degree. It is attention to all details that add up to a really successful model. One of the most prolific causes of eddy resistance is the frequent slipshod construction of skeg, rudder post and rudder. In model yacht design eddy resistance is usually ignored but it should not be forgotten entirely. It cannot be completely eliminated and eddies must be induced in a yacht when sailing to windward as the whole hull and keel is pushed through the water at an oblique angle. Furthermore, hull shapes satisfactory in full-size design can cause eddy resistance in a model where none existed on other larger yachts, the waterline endings at the stern being a case in point. In certain racing classes it is possible, and desirable, from the rule cheating point of view to end the waterlines in a very abrupt curve. This curve is of sufficient radius to allow nevertheless a smooth passage for the water, but scaled down to model size the equivalent radius can be so tight that water will no longer flow smoothly and eddies are set up and the resistance of the model will be unduly high. Thus an advantage in full-size may be a disadvantage when using the same rating formula in miniature. A racing model requires easier lines than its full-size counterpart. Speed/length relationship and wave making resistance Before delving into the subject of wave making resistance it is necessary to consider how the relative speeds of different hulls can be assessed. It is of no value to say that a boat is fast merely because it can travel at a certain speed. Speed must be related to length in some way and it is a convenient fact that the length of the waves set up by the hull in motion, being determined by the particular combination of speed and length of that hull, can provide us with a basis for fair comparison. In about 1870 William Froude started a series of experiments with model hulls and was able to produce his laws of comparison. He established that when a ship and a model of it move through the water at such speeds that the speed of the model is to the speed of the ship as the square root of the length of the model is to the square root of the length of the ship then the waves set up by each are of identical pattern and the two can be compared on a fair basis. The velocity of a wave in water is proportional to the square root of the length of the wave, so that as the length of a ship’s wave when travelling near its maximum speed is roughly equal to the length of the waterline of the ship, we can compare the speeds of different vessels by looking at the factor _¥ VLWL where V is the speed in knots and L.W.L. the waterline length in feet. For example, a yacht with a waterline length of 36 ft. travelling at 6 knots has a speed/Iength ratio of a = 1-0 THE DANIELS DESIGNED “SERICA’? PROBABLY UNDER-CANVASSED FOR HER SIZE IN LIGHT CONDITIONS MODEL RACING YACHTS greater share that skin friction has on the overall considera tion. It is often the case that a heavy boat has less wette: SPEED RATIO I-3 SHALLOW HULL FORM SPEED RATIO 1-3 DEEP HULL FORM WAVE FORM OF YACHT FIGURE 6 Likewise an ocean liner 900 ft. on the waterline travelling at 30 knots also has a speed/length ratio of 1-0. Thus the express liner is just as slow as the sailing yacht when length only is taken in consideration. For a normal displacement type hull a speed length ratio of 1:3 is rarely exceeded and ratios of 1:0 to 1:1 are much more common. Above 1-3 the wave length set up by the hull begins to exceed the L.W.L. and special types of hull form have to be considered for these higher speeds. Not very much reliable data is available for the actual speeds of sailing yachts as there are so many variables in type and in condition of sailing. It is known that powerful sailing yachts do achieve a speed ratio of 1-5 but it is probable that the average speed of a racing yacht is less than 1-0. With models the picture is somewhat different due to the scale effects of wind, etc. and speed/length ratios of above 1-0 are much more readily reached. Therefore a racing model may be designed to suit a higher average speed than its equivalent full-size craft. This is one more reason why a good model does not necessarily produce a good large craft. It is all a matter of compromise as the racing boat has to be of lower resistance than its competitor over the complete speed range. From the argument emerges the basic of all truths in yacht design that in order to obtain speed the most important single factor is the length. For this reason most rules govern- ing racing yacht design control length by some means in the formula. Usually an increase in length has to be paid for by a reduction in sail area. It is the designer’s choice as to how far he can increase the length before the sail area becomes too small to drive the yacht reasonably well in light winds. It should not be forgotten that when we speak of the velocity of waves we are talking of the velocity of a motion. The water itself does not move forward but merely goes up and down in the same place. To be strictly accurate the particles of water described earlier orbit but there is no general progression in the direction of the wave. Whilst the length of the wave is related to its velocity so is the power needed to generate a wave related to its height. For a given waterline length a heavy displacement hull will produce a deeper wave formation than a light displacement hull and it will require considerably more power to drive it at a given speed. For this reason a long light hull will have a higher potential speed than a shorter heavier one. However, the resistance of the longer hull may be considerably greater than the shorter heavy boat at the lower speeds due to the 16 surface and it is one of the reasons for the apparent parado: that the heavier boats perform better in light airs. This ha been proved time and time again in racing results both full size and model; only the designer can decide just what ar the best proportions of length and displacement to suit hi particular needs. This is why it is so important for a designe to observe yachts performing under all conditions and t have a broad knowledge and understanding of othe designers’ work. Having selected a length and weight the designer will bi concerned with producing a hull of minimum midship cross section and with the displacement spread out towards thi ends of the hull as far as practicable. He will also endeavou to keep the hull shallow rather than deep as the shallow hul produces a flatter wave formation and is also more easil! persuaded into a planing action when driven very har« down wind. All these factors add up to a high maximun potential speed but also they cause the light weather ability to suffer. I _ There are sensible limits in hull form beyond which a de signer should not go, For example, a hull designed for th: higher speed ranges may have quite adequate performance in light airs but if the high speed characteristics are pushec even further the result may well be only an infinitesimal im provement in top speed and complete ruination of ligh weather ability. It is not possible to set a limit and a designe: should be allowed to make his own mistakes in this respect 1932 AND THE LATE BILL DANIELS WITH “ANGLIAN” emer: MODEL RACING YACHTS What would be true for one designer would not necessarily follow for another as it is the designer’s individual concep- tion of the vessel as a whole which is important, not the elaboration of any single feature on its own. Closely allied with the resistance of a hull due to simple wave making as a result of length and displacement, is the rather more complicated consideration of hull form. In other words, how should the displacement be distributed within the waterline length? We have already said that the higher speeds are achieved by spreading the volume of the hull towards the ends, but how much should be in front of the midship section and how much should be aft of this point? Here again the model yacht designer has an easier job than if he were designing a large vessel. There are three basic hull types: (a) Cod’s head type (b) Wedge type (c) Symmetrical type The cod’s head type of hull is that which has a larger proportion of its displacement situated before the midship section than aft. This gives very full waterlines forward and a beautifully buoyant bow. The after lines of the hull will be quite fine and smooth. The type has some attraction and for a time was popular with full-size designers. Tests have shown however that the resistance of this type is only lower than the other two at very low speeds when there is practically no wave-making resistance. This rules the type out as far as the model designer is concerned. At least it does so assuming that no radical development is about to occur in sail plans. Should it become possible to use large genoa jibs on a model then the fuller and more buoyant bow may well be superior. A genoa sail has considerable depressing action right where a yacht has least reserves and to be able fully to utilise this sail could well result in higher speeds despite the greater resistance of the hull. Consideration of resistance should never allow the designer to ignore the power available in the sails and a number of well known and very successful ocean racers are designed in this way. It may well be that due to the success of these boats it will become fashionable to have LW.L.PLANS OF SYMMETRICAL AND WEDGE FORM HULLS L.W.L. INTERNATIONAL “A” CLASS “SHALIMAR” IN 1953. BRITAIN’S CHOICE IN THAT PERIOD TO CHALLENGE FOR THE Y.M. CUP IN U.S.A. this hull form and we shall see the type wrongly used in classes where the genoa sail is not allowed! The wedge type of hull with fine waterlines forward and full lines aft is also a traditional type. The old waveform theory of displacement distribution inevitably had its effects in this direction butall things considered it is a good hull form for full-size yachts. Problems of seaworthiness and pitching action worry the full-size designer and the fine slicing bow is an attraction to many who have to sail in choppy water. The hull can have ends which are distinctly dissimilar and this damps out pitching motion to some extent. There is also the advantage that the type provides adequate support for a crew weight concentrated in a cockpit near the aft ending of the L.W.L. These three advantages are of no consequence to the model designer and can be thoroughly ignored. He is only concerned with sheer speed and at high speed/length A. WEDGE FORM ratios too. The wedge type has the highest value of resistance at very low speeds but the situation quickly changes as soon as wave making starts. From about 0-5 to 1-0 speed/length ratios the type has the lowest of all three. Above this speed the symmetrical hull form is slightly superior. However, as soon as the model is forced into semi-planing conditions the wedge form probably is again superior. B. SYMMETRICAL FORM FIGURE 7 M.R.Y.—2 The disadvantage from the model designer’s point of view is that the wedge type is not so readily ‘balanced’ as the 17 MODEL RACING YACHTS symmetrical. This feature will be discussed more fully in a later chapter. The symmetrical hull form is the best for the racing model as the resistance at low speed is less than the wedge type, is distinctly less than the cod’s head type, greater than the wedge type at medium speeds (only very slightly) and has slightly less resistance at the higher speeds in which models most frequently operate. As in all things a compromise usually works out best and the most successful model yachts are of symmetrical general form with their centres of buoyancy slightly aft of midships. Therefore the model designer’s job is relatively simple; he chooses length and displacement, decides whether he is designing for maximum speeds or medium speeds and spreads the displacement accordingly, arranging at the same time for the centre of buoyancy to be midships or slightly aft. It is as simple as that! There are other refinements which can be studied. For example, if the forward waterline endings are made somewhat more blunt than the actual L.W.L. a lowering of total resistance can result. This is a nicety of design but it is doubtful whether these tiny modifications to a basic hull shape can actually be detected in the performance of a racing model. They mean much more to potential America Cup challengers where every detail must be perfect. One of the sad things about model yachts is the need for high displacements in order to obtain power and stability. This makes the wave making resistance a most important issue, fortunately simply dealt with, but, nevertheless, inhibiting radical development in design as a whole. Uffa Fox has been quoted as saying ‘Weight is only useful in a steam roller’ and up to a point this has some truth in large yachts generally, is absolutely true when applied to planing boats and has no truth whatever when applied to models as we at present know them. Over the years the displacement of model yachts has grown and grown, the sail areas have become smaller but all the time the average speeds have gone up. In the International A class and 10 rater classes the design compromise has probably been reached during the last 5 years. The 6 Metre class is now virtually ignored but is very much undeveloped in model form, the International M class is such a poor rule that it is valueless from a design development point of view. We now await new advances in materials and sails. These things can themselves cause a change in hull style and choice of basic dimensions. Skin friction It is obvious that a hull with a rough surface will have a higher resistance than one that is smooth. What is not obvious is the degree of smoothness necessary to obtain worthwhile benefits. An examination of skin friction problems can be most interesting as we soon find that it is not just a simple matter of smoothness but the question of shape and form have to be brought back into the argument. To put the problem into perspective we know that at a speed/length ratio of 1-0 the total resistance of a hull is 50 per cent due to wavemaking and 50 per cent due to skin friction and eddy making. Below 1-0 and at about 0:5 the skin friction can account for as much as 80 per cent of the total. Above 1:0 the wave-making resistance begins to increase very rapidly in proportion but the skin friction does still increase with speed. Naturally a reduction in skin friction at higher speeds will contribute little in the matter of increased speed but at medium speeds it is very important indeed. For the full-size designer skin friction is one of his headaches; he can design the wetted surface to be as small and as long as practicable but otherwise he is helpless. He is dependent on the owner keeping the yacht clean and free from marine growth. The model yacht designer however can design into his boat flow characteristics which will assist in reducing skin friction and which can be maintained during the life of the model with reasonable care by the owner. There is great scope for development in the field and here is one place where the model designer may be of considerable help in full-size development. To appreciate the full implication of skin friction we must look more closely into the mechanics of the flow of water. If we consider the flow of water past a surface to be built of extremely thin layers we can imagine that the layers close to the surface will be travelling at a lower velocity, than the layer some distance from the surface. The change in velocity relative to the surface will be from zero immediately in contact with the surface to the speed of flow some distance away. The thickness of water in the state of changing velocity is known as the boundary layer. If the surface is perfectly smooth, in an academic sense, then the flow past the surface is said to be laminar and is of the minimum possible resistance. It is not easy to achieve this theoretical perfection HOWARD NASH 0O.B.E. AND “FANTASY” IN NOTE THE PRE-VANE ERA TYPE OF SKEG AND RUDDER 1935. MODEL RACING YACHTS but at low speeds with a very smooth surface and with a helpful shape of body much can be done. Very small imperfections of the surface will destroy the laminar flow and turbulence is set up, the degree of turbulence being approximately proportional to the magnitude of the roughness. The greater the turbulence the greater is the . frictional resistance. It is possible to have a condition where laminar flow exists in the boundary layer very close to the surface and turbulent flow in the remaining thickness, but as speed increases the laminar flow will break down and the flow will be entirely turbulent. It is easier to maintain a laminar or transitional flow condition when the water is tending to impinge on the surface rather than tending to diverge from it. A model yacht, although often travelling at a relative speed higher than its full-size counterpart, spends much of its time at quite low actual velocities. Thus it is more reasonable to expect laminar flow conditions to be main- tained on a model than on a larger vessel. In fact if models were only about 12 in. long when travelling at speed/length ratios of around 1-0 it could be expected that the flow be entirely laminar! Laminar flow causes difficulty in tank testing procedures at low speeds and test models have to be fitted with studs or WAVE MAKING RESISTANCE INTERNATIONAL “A” CLASS “YEOMAN” DEMONSTRATING THE USE OF A SMALL SEMI FLAT SPINNAKER FOR RUNNING IN A FRESH QUARTERING WIND RESISTANCE wires on the hull to try and destroy this condition which would never be achieved in full scale. Many bad mistakes SKIN FRICTION -~ FIGURE 8 were made over this phenomenon in early testing and this is one of the reasons why commercial tests are carried out with models as long as many full-size yachts. Laminar flow then is a function of smooth surfaces, low speeds and favourable shape. Skin friction is reduced in first consideration by reducing the total area, without destroying other desirable performance characteristics, making the surface as smooth as possible bearing in mind the possibilities of laminar flow with super smooth finishes, and area for area making the surface longrather than short. The model de- signer can then spare a thought to making the shape, particularly of the keel, more prone to laminar flow. He should. not forget though, that these shapes offer higher resistance under turbulent conditions and if the surface is not going to be super smooth then he had better not experiment. These remarks on laminar flow are something of an over simplification and if the designer is sufficiently interested he should study a good book on hydraulics. 19 CHAPTER IV The Keel as a Salient Feature DuRING the past fifty years the most noteworthy development in yacht design has been the progressive way that the keel has emerged as a salient feature. We have now reached the stage where the keel can be regarded as a separate functional unit and its reaction on the canoe body design is relatively unimportant. At any rate this is true as far as the model designer is concerned although it will be seen later that a heavy displacement canoe body should be associated with a different fin keel from that for a light displacement canoe body. Model yacht designers have been in the van of this development and we now see quite a number of full-size designs with the fin and skeg combination so long ago proved successful in model work. It is realised that the fin keel has the most important part to play in promoting efficient sailing on a windward course and that the hull proper has relatively little to contribute in this respect. The forces acting on a sailing boat when sailing to windward are shown in Fig. 9 and it will be seen that in order to prevent a wholesale movement sideways it is the lateral resistance of the keel that checks the movement and permits the yacht to travel forward. The resistance generated by the fin keel is not only due to the pressure on the leeward side of the keel but also due to a lowering of pressure on the windward side caused by the water flow around it. In this respect, and many others, the keel can be likened to an aeroplane wing in its action. In order to produce the ‘lift’ the keel will take up a certain angle relative to the direction of flow of water. The angle is called the leeway angle and is the reason why a yacht does not travel in the direction it is looking! The amount of the angle, which can also be called ‘angle of attack’, is dependent on a number of factors such as: WIND DIRECTION LEEWAY ANGLE FIGURE 9 DIRECTION OF WATER OVER KEEL ACTION OF KEEL WHEN SAILING TO WINDWARD 20 (a) (b) (c) (d) The The The The area of the keel aspect ratio, i.e. the depth/chord ratio cross-sectional shape of the keel speed The increased efficiency that development has produced in keel design has enabled the total area to be considerably reduced. This is very fortunate because the more salient keel inevitably increases the wetted surface of the yacht on a given displacement. Only by drastic modification of the profile shape has the total area been kept within reasonable limits. Nevertheless there is a tendency for modern yachts to have a poorer light weather performance than older vessels due to increased skin friction. This is taking due consideration that older boats usually carried more sail as well. The criterion of design for an efficient fin keel is that it shall have a high lift and a low drag. This is normally refer- red to as the lift/drag ratio and it is generally accepted that a narrow chord and a great depth will produce the best results. This is all very well up to a point and now we have to consider the practical difficulties and compromises necessary. As well as depth and chord the keel must have thickness. All other things being equal a thin keel has been proved to provide a good lift/drag ratio superior to that of a thick cross-section. On the other hand, when a very heavy displacement hull is under consideration it may be worth while permitting an increased thickness of keel to absorb some of the displacement. This will make it possible to have easier lines and perhaps less resistance in the canoe body. The thicker keel will also allow the lead ballast to have a lower centre of gravity. Obviously this will make the yacht more stable and she can be driven harder. This is particularly important in model designing. These advantages may in some instances outweigh the disadvantages of a lower lift/ drag ratio. In the author’s experience thick keels do not benefit the model designer and they are best avoided. However, this does not mean that useful experimental work cannot be carried out in this direction. From tests already made with several model racing yachts it would seem that the higher resistance of the thick keel is only apparent when going to windward and that there is little difference when the yacht is sailing before the wind with no angle of leeway. If we now swing to the other extreme and consider a really thin keel we come up against the difficulty of finding room for the lead ballast. Why use lead? Gold, platinum, uranium, and a few other precious metals are available if you have the money. Mercury is not so expensive but is rather difficult to handle but why not put it in a plastic bag heat sealed and inserted into a hollow fabricated fin keel? MODEL RACING YACHTS Even resort to these limits will not allow keel thickness to be ideally small, particularly if the designer wants to have a small chord. For model work it is advised that the thickness be somewhere in the range of 8 per cent to 12 per cent of the chord. This automatically sets a limit on the chord for all practical purposes and means that very high aspect ratios are not feasible. This is not so serious as may be thought at first, as area for area a high aspect ratio of keel gives a higher skin friction than does one of lower proportions and it is a noticeable trend that models with deep narrow keels aresomewhat sluggish despite perhaps a lower total wetted surface. The choice of cross-sectional shape for the keel is important but not much factual information is available to help the designer. It is usual to employ a symmetrical aerofoil as shown in Fig. 10(a). This indicates a maximum thickness some 30 per cent back from the leading edge and a fairly blunt form of entry. Fig. 10(b) shows something generally similar but with a sharp entry. This has found favour with a number of designers but the very sharpness of the leading edge is open to criticism. When in condition of flow with an angle of attack the sharp edge could set up eddies which may break down the steady flow over the windward surface and thus induce increased drag and loss of ‘lift’. Fig. 10(c) shows another section which has been used successfully and it will be seen that the maximum thickness has been moved back to some 45 per cent of the keel chord. This type of section probably has virtue in being more prone to laminar flow conditions. It would be very interesting to carry out a whole series of tests using different keel sections under a constant canoe body design’ The designer should make himself familiar with the range of modern aerofoils published in various journals, particularly those of the N.A.C.A. This is a field wide open to research and the model designer can make a worthwhile contribution, providing his experiments are well reasoned and well conducted. We are now naturally led into consideration of total fin keel area necessary for good performance. It has been suggested that the area of keel can be related to sail area but this leaves out the effect of speed on the lift/drag ratio. When moving slowly a yacht cannot generate proportionately as much lateral resistance for a given area as it can at higher speeds. If there is insufficient area the angle of attack increases and likewise does the drag so that we can now see the difficult state of affairs the designer is in. For light weather windward ability he requires a large keel area for low induced drag but he also requires a minimum total wetted surface for low skin friction. At higher speeds he can reduce the lateral area but as wave-making absorbs so much power from the sails he does not gain very much by doing so. The type of canoe body needs to be considered at this stage. If the yacht is of heavy displacement and deep cross-sectional form it should not be asked to sail at high angles of attack. The resistance of such a hull being driven obliquely through the water is bound to be excessive and it is better to suffer the penalty of too much keel area and the associated skin friction. The penalty will be paid when running and reaching in light airs. If the hull is of light displacement and flat cross-sectional form it may. well be that the induced drag due to the greater obliqueness of travel will not be greater than the reduction in ars due ‘to the small keel area and a benefit is possible. However, whilst we are designing canoe bodies of generally symmetrical shapes it is probable that the angle of attack TYPICAL CROSS SECTIONS OF KEELS — A. ROUND NOSE —- ra 30Z0F CHORD a B. SHARP NOSE C. SHARP NOSE MAX.WIDTH 457 OF CHORD ZMAX.WIDTH SO7 OF CHORD D. LAMINAR FLOW PRONE SECTION FIGURE 10 should be kept to a minimum. Should the design trend be towards extremely small keel areas then it may well be that the canoe body will need to be of different type. This presupposes a general reduction in displacement of models and leads one into the realm of catamarans and other types which do not achieve stability by weight alone. It is therefore preferable to have too much lateral area than too little for good all-round performance. On consideration of satisfactory ballast C.G. and the resultant effect on keel chord we have an immediate guide for the allowable depth of keel or total draught for the model. This seems to work out at between 11 in. and 13 in. for the three most popular racing classes, i.e. International A, 10 rater and International M. The fact that draught is limited by the Class rule in A class makes the job easier for the designer. The profile of the keel is discussed lastly as it probably is the least important although it will be the first thing the designer draws. Having decided what approximate area the keel shall have and accepting a greater chord than we would really like in order to accommodate the lead we see that there are only two sensible alternative profiles. There is the basic parallelogram or a smooth flowing shape of considerable artistic merit. From a sheer efficiency point of view the parallelogram should be superior and is the one usually adopted these days. The chord is greater where the lead is needed and the relatively constant cross-section should contribute to a good performance. On the other hand two of the finest designers in the world nearly always adopt the smooth flowing type, of profile without apparent loss in speed and ability. There is more in this question than meets the eye and keel design is by no means fully understood. The positioning of the fin keel under the canoe body is one of compromise but one in which the practical considerations outweigh theory. The leading edge of the keel will have a slope of usually 45° to 55° and this means that with a centre of buoyancy just aft of midships it is not practicable to put the lead right across the bottom of the keel without placing the whole appendage too far forwards. It will be too far forwards because it is necessary for the sail plan to be situated in a relative position to the keel. If the keel goes forward so must the sail plan and this cannot be carried to excess 21 MODEL RACING YACHTS aon WL Nccnone \) 45/55) oad USUAL LEAD BALLAST LINE A. RECOMMENDED TYPE OF PROFILE B. PROFILE OF FLOWING LINES C. FULL KEEL TYPC FULL KEEL TYPE OF REDUCED WETTED SURFACE achieved. In order to compensate for this some designer, like to thicken the cross-section of the keel and form a sor of bulb to take the lead. With a normal type of profile thi: should not be necessary and could easily reduce the overal keel efficiency. Some years ago there was violent argument whether o1 not the rudder should be placed on the aft edge of the kee or whether it should be hung on a separate skeg further aft Practical tests settled the issue, as far as models are concerned, in favour of the separate skeg arrangement. The advantages seem to be principally in the greater contro] and directional stability achieved and less tendency to wander off course when sailing to windward with variable angles of heel. It is also possible to design with less wetted surface area but one must not ignore the fact that a number BALLAST HIGHER mR CU D. MODIFIED These limitations on keel positioning force the lead t be concentrated towards the leading edge of the keel anc gives a somewhat higher C.G. than would be otherwis i FIGURE 11 KEEL PROFILES without performance limitation. It is also desirable that the thickest part of the keel be placed under or very near to the deepest part of the canoe body. This enables a much more satisfactory blending of the two shapes in the gar- boards. of very successful full keeled models have been produce d. Strangely, though, these have not been of British design. It is possible that, with the knowledge now availabl e, the full keel type may still have a future. The increased wetted surface may be offset by the production of laminar flow. The keel being of great chord can be relatively thin and still accommodate the lead very low down. The full keel will not need a high angle of attack and the induced drag of the hull will be low. Providing the rudder post is vertical and well aft there should not be undue difficulty in achieving adequate control. However, until a designer has some considerable experience he is advised to concentrate his efforts on the conventional fin and skeg types. The keel areas and proportions shown in the various designs in this book are the result of much thought, experi- ment and intense competition racing. It is signific ant that there is nothing radical about them. CHAPTER V Stability and Hull Balance Very fortunately for the model yacht designer he has no need to carry out the tedious calculations determin ing stability which are so often required with large vessels. We know that generally speakinga model yacht cannot be too stable and that this stability is derived from two sources. Firstly, the ballast in the keel should be as high a percentage of the total displacement as possible, and its centre of gravity should be as low as possible. The two factors are linked with the initial choice of dimensions and the design of the fin respectively. The second source of stability is derived from the shape of the hull in cross-section. We have already discussed the position of the Centre of Buoyancy in a fore and aft direction but it must be obvious that this position can also be located in a vertical plane. For most yacht designs it is not necessary to make this calculation but the shape of the 22 canoe body will determine the actual height. The C.B. must be positioned in exact line over the C.G. when the yacht is upright. However, when the yacht heels the C.B. will move outwards in the direction of keel. This produces a righting couple which resists the force causing the heeling action. A vertical line drawn through the C.B. will cross the centre line of the hull at a point known as the Metacen tre. The height of the Metacentre can be taken as a guide to the stability and this position is sometimes used to analyse the characteristics of a hull when trying to achieve ‘balance’. The amount by which the C.B. moves is determi ned by the shape of the hull and the greater the moveme nt for a given angle of heel the greater is the inherent stabilit y. Thus a deep narrow hull will have less stability than a wide flatter type. The fact that a flatter type of hull also has a higher potential speed sometimes leads the designer into the mistake of excessive beam and flatness. It must be remem- MODEL RACING YACHTS bered that the wide flat form, although possessing consider- able initial stability, may well have less stability at large angles of heel than a more moderate form. Similarly, the wide hull will usually have a higher resistance, when sailed at angles of heel, than a deeper type on the same displace- ment. If a model could be sailed in an upright attitude in the same way as are racing dinghies the whole aspect of model yacht design would be changed. A further advantage of the narrower hull is that it can usually have the least wetted surface area. All these points have led to the tendency in model yachts for them to be both narrow and of fairly flat form. In order to obtain the required displacement the turn of the bilge is somewhat low and is distinctly rounded and full. This type has proved to be very successful but it is not necessarily so good when applied to full-size design. Hull Balance A yacht is said to be ‘balanced’ when it shows no tendency to wander off course during varying angles of heel. There has been more controversy over this aspect of design than any other. There is no simple answer to the problem but it is absolutely necessary for a model to be directionally stable. Things are not so critical for the full-size yacht as there is nearly always a helmsman ready to provide the necessary rudder correction and it may well be that a well balanced yacht is not necessarily the fastest. This is a penalty that the model designer must be prepared to pay as there is no point in having a very fast yacht that often speeds in the wrong direction! It has been said that a few degrees of weather helm is a good way of improving windward ability and this is true. It is not, however, necessary to cater for this condition at the design stage as it can be achieved by proper trimming and tuning if so desired. There are many influences which will try to alter the course of a model yacht when sailing. It is easy to visualise the force of the wind on the sails causing the yacht to heel. The force acts at a point on the sail plan called the Centre of Effort. This centre is normally considered to be at the centre of gravity of the sail plan and is easily determined. Unfortunately the centre of effort moves forward or aft depending on the wind strength and the trim of the sails. However, it will be seen that when the yacht is heeled the transverse position of the centre of effort will not be in line with the water forces on the hull itself and a slewing or turning action is produced. This has to be resisted by the hull and fin. The fin when resisting the sideways force of the sails does so through a point called the Centre of Lateral Resistance. This point can also be calculated and is the centre of gravity of the under water profile of the yacht. In a similar manner the Centre of Effort of the sails, the C.L.R. moves from the calculated position as soon as the yacht moves through the water. The actual position varies according to the speed, angle of attack, cross-sectional shape and the profile up into irons, head to wind. Model yachts are fitted with means to alter the mast position over a range of about 3 in. and this makes it quite easy to arrive at the best position. It is probable that many full-size yachts could benefit from a mast movement but this is rarely done due to expense and trouble, furthermore the effects of a wrongly positioned sail plan are so often concealed by the helmsman. This position of the sail plan can be used to correct other forces acting on the hull which we have not yet discussed. These forces should be eliminated if possible by good design rather than having to be counterbalanced. However, the forces of the sails can only be dealt with by counterbalance methods. The designer can help himself to a limited extent by not designing keels of exotic shape so that the movements of the C.L.R. are reasonable. For example a very steep leading edge to the fin tends to cause luffing at high angles of heel and it is not recommended that an angle of 45° be exceeded until considerable experience is obtained. s 7 CO oS SL} Z/ NO Ce SS / A BALANCED HULL SHEWN IN SOLID LINE eee UNBALANCED « > eee « ” “ FIGURE 12 – y oN) shape. The turning forces produced by the sails through the centre of effort have to be counterbalanced by the hull forces acting through the centre of lateral resistance. Both these forces move in a way which cannot be usefully calculated, therefore the designer is left in a pretty pickle. He has only one course and that is to guess at the correct positioning of the sail plan over the hull. If the sail plan is too far forward the yacht will not point up into the wind, and if the plan is too far aft the yacht will be constantly going 23 SRR SSS SSS SSS SS SSS a ea error MODEL RACING YACHTS FIGURE 13 identical. If this type of hull is ever proved to be the fastest all-round performer then the design of model yachts will cease to have any interest! F ortunately this is most unlikely. ‘ LW.L. A. UPRIGHT The similarity of the ends of the hull really comes about from the need to avoid a change of fore and aft trim on heeling. If the Centre of Buoyancy moves aft the stern will rise and the yacht has a strong tendency to gripe or shoot up into the wind. Conversely if the C. of B. moves forward then the yacht will head off the wind. It*is better for the C. of B. not to move at all up to angles of heel of 25°. This of course presupposes that there will be no other forces on the hull which will cause an unbalanced effect and which therefore need to be counteracted. For example, in designs with a full or long keel it is possible for the flow of water to Cause a pressure on the keel surface well behind the C.L.R . and this pressure can cause the hull to turn. Usually this effect is for the garboard stream to be trapped on the lee- ward side of the keel and the yacht tends to turn away from the wind. This can be offset by allow ing the C. of B. to move aft on heeling by some prede termined amount. To judge the actual movement necessary is one of extreme nicety and the designer has no guidance in the matter. He can only make a guess. It is far better therefore to avoid such effects and this is one of the main reasons that the fin and skeg is so satisfactory in model form. CENTRE OF LATERAL RESISTANCE AND CENTRE OF EFFORT B.HEELED RIGHTING MOMENT TRANSVERSE MOVEMENT OF C.B.ON HEELI NG It is in the design of the hull that the designer can do most to avoid unbalance in the completed yacht. Certainly if the canoe body is of the wrong form then nothin g at all will make the yacht a good racing model. Many fine brains have been applied to this problem to try and devise a geometric way of drawing the lines so that balance is automatically achieved. None of the theories so far promulgated are completely satisfactory. The most famous one is Admiral Turner’s ‘Metacentric Analysis’ and althou gh yachts designed to this method are undoubtedly docile and easy to handle they are not necessarily fast. The great success of his racing model design does not lie in the compli ance with his theories but rather with his foresight in choice of initial dimensions. He was the first model design er to see the advantages of heavy displacement. Now that other designers have gone further than the Admiral dimensi onally, his _ yachts are being beaten by models not design ed by the use C.OF E.OF Jip LW.t> : e of his method. The common factor which emerges from all hull balance considerations is that the ends of the hull should be similar in character. They do not have to be identical as in the tyP€ known as the ‘Circular Arc’ form. With these hulls the profile and cross-sections are all based on the arcs of circles and it is inevitable that both ends of the canoe body are 24 CENTRE OF LATERAL RESISTANCE = THIS DISTANCE CAN ONLY BE DETERMINED BY EXPERIENCE AND EXPERIMENT FIGURE 14 ESSE MODEL RACING YACHTS HEELED LW.L. *IN’WEDGE ‘ouT’ WEDGE do nothing about but we do know that a hull which is unbalanced when checked statically will certainly be unsatisfactory in actual practice. There is no guarantee, though, that any yacht of fresh design will be docile or balanced despite all the designer can possibly do. More often than not a new design is developed from a previous one of known characteristics and the designer is able to judge with more certainty what effects his modifications will have. There are many unknowns about sailing yacht hulls and it is a pity that yachts are such useless things that no really big sums of money and brains will be devoted to adequate research. On second thoughts, is it a pity? When all is known and the understanding of that knowledge can only be accumulated by the very brainy, something will be lost to the ordinary mortals. Club conversation and argument about the merits of particular craft will not be possible and a new topic will need to be found. Perhaps one of the big attraction of yachts is their uncertainty and the mumbojumbo which surrounds their design. IN AND OUT WEDGES FIGURE [5 “MOONRAKER II”? SHOWS THE GREAT WINDWARD It will be seen from the diagram that when a hull heels a ‘wedge’ of the cross-section is immersed on the leeward side and another wedge on the windward side merges from the water. If the area of the ‘In’ wedges is added to the crosssectional areas and the area of the ‘Out’ wedges is subtracted we can recalculate the centre of buoyancy and observe the movement. It will also be apparent that if the upright C. of B. is approximately at 50 per cent of the L.W.L. then the ends of the hull need to be quite similar. If however the C. of B. is well aft in the upright attitude then the ends can be dissimilar and the hull can be generally of the wedge form. The big difficulty in balance comes when the designer tries to produce a wedge-type hull with the C. of B. midships or a symmetrical hull with the C. of B. aft. These shapes are possible but they will never produce a balanced design. Trying to design a very flat run aft also runs the designer into difficulty. It should be obvious that if the C. of B. moves aft the ‘In’ wedges in the after part of the hull need to be reduced in area and the ‘In’ wedges in the forward half need to be increased in area. Usually a compromise is necessary and the ‘out’? wedges have to be correspondingly modified. This also will alter the shape of the L.W.L. plane. It does not require much practice before a designer can sense whether his initial lines will produce a balanced hull and the experienced man hardly needs to check whether the C. of B. does in fact move. The amount of movement permissible has been quoted from time to time and varies from author to author. However, it is the opinion of this author that on an L.W.L. of 55 in. the C. of B. should not move more than 0-02 in. aft and it should never move forwards, on 25° angle of heel. These checks on the C. of B. only apply when the hull is in a static condition and when sailing at angles of 20° heel or more there is a considerable amount of wave-making. The hull is subject to dynamic forces which the designer can POWER OF THE TURNER DESIGNED MONSTERS IN A FRESH BREEZE CHAPTER VI Drawing the Lines BEFORE any work on design can be started, other than rough freehand sketches (and many ideas never get beyond tihs stage), it is necessary to have acertain amount of equipment. As with most things a job can be done so much more pleasurably and perhaps a little better if the facilities and equipment are adequate. Of course a lot of good work has been done under very difficult conditions and with very meagre instruments but if it is intended to produce more than an occasional design then the following list of articles should be purchased: (1) A drawing board 54 x 32 in. is about the most useful size and as they are expensive it is worth trying to buy a secondhand one. Alternatively a piece of blockboard can be used as it is not necessary to have the usual straight edge down one side. The board should be covered by one or two layers of best quality cartridge paper. Ideally this should be shrunk and glued on but Terry clips are reasonably satis- factory. (2) A really good ebony edged straight-edge at least 48 in. long is essential and only the best is good enough. The whole accuracy of the drawing depends on this as waterlines have to be quite straight and parallel. It is better to plot the spacing of these lines rather than try to use a large T-square. (3) One 10-in. celluloid 45° set-square. Here again make sure that the 90° angle is truly a right angle, as it is surprising how often these instruments are inaccurate if a cheap one is bought. (4) One set of Dixon Kemp pear-shaped curves. They are made specially for the Naval architect and with them the job of fairing up a set of cross-sections becomes quite easy. The ordinary types of French curve are quite useless for yacht designs. (5) A set of splines and spline weights are well worth their money. The splines are usually made of lancewood but celluloid ones are also available. Splines can be tapered in thickness in various ways so that they take up a characteristic curve, but the most useful are: + X 7 tapering to 7 x i x 60 in. leng is x $ is Xt g x $ SET_OF FIVE DIXON MAHOGANY SCREWED LEAD 7 KEMP CURVES’ BASE TO SPLINE WEIGHT 5 REQUIRED Sy Wa TERRY SPRING CLIP FIGURE 16 26 99 t x $ ” 48 in. » §X a», 48in. 29 $ x as 29 36 in. ” ,, 29 Spline weights are expensive but can be quite easily made as shown in Fig. 16. The lead should be covered with some soft material such as leatherette, as uncovered it is too dirty to handle. Five such weights are required, although more are sometimes useful. However, it has been said that a curve requiring more than five should not appear in a yacht design and this has some truth when a comprehensive set of splines of all shapes and thickness is available. It is possible to manage with 4-square balsa wood held down with pins but very great care is needed to obtain an even curve. The use of splines requires a deal of practice and patience. WEIGHT ”° 5 29 (6) A planimeter is invaluable and we have already mentioned this instrument in an earlier chapter. The only scale required is a direct reading in square inches. Some instruments are adjustable on the scale arm but even if the design is half full size it is easier to multiply the readings by 4 than to readjust the planimeter from the direct scale setting. (7) Paper, rather obvious but most important. There are a number of advantages in using a transparent detail paper for the design as prints can be taken off without having to do a tracing. One can also superimpose drawings one over the other and make direct comparisons of lines. This is a MODEL RACING YACHTS a i USE OF SPLINE WEIGHTS FIGURE 1|7 most valuable feature as so often one design is a development from another. Paper is bought in 25-yd. rolls and it is a good thing to have plenty in stock as there should be no excuse for not throwing anything away which is not completely pleasing to the designer. (8) Anaccurate scale rule and a good 12-in. steel engineer’s rule are required. (9) The last instrument needed is a good pair of 6 in.-long dividers for transferring measurements from one view of the plan to another view. Some people like to use ‘tick strips’. These are strips of paper which can be placed on the drawing and marked on the edge each time a dimension is to be transferred. There is some merit in this but dividers used with skill are much quicker in the long run. Other facilities enjoyed by the author and thoroughly recommended are: (a) Asecond small drawing board for sketches and body plans. (6) A permanent position for the large board so that one is not constantly getting up and putting away. (c) Plenty of reference books to hand. (d) Good lighting. (e) A tolerant wife who is able to give an opinion as to the fairness of lines. Before any work on the drawing board is started the designer will have made up his mind as to the general dimensions of the yacht. He must have settled on a L.W.L. for the particular class concerned and he will know whether the displacement is to be heavy or light. This means he will have to have a good idea of the figures for L.W.L. beam and the depth of the canoe body. Usually a design is developed from the experience gained in previous work but in the first instance the beginner is well advised to have a close look at other designers’ work and examine the general proportions of various yachts. There is no point in starting work on the drawing board until the design is almost completely formed in the mind of the designer and do not forget that the design includes the sail plan as well as just a hull. The first actual lines to put down on paper are the set out of the waterlines and sections in the profile view, the waterlines and buttock lines for the cross-sections, and the centre line, buttocks and sections in the plan view. All these lines are straight and should be drawn with great care. If the waterlines, for example, are not exactly parallel it will never be possible to obtain a truly fair set of hull lines. It is convenient to set the lines out at a scale of half full-size and this gives sufficient space on the size drawing board recommended. Although half size is adequate for the body plan of an A-class yacht it is better to draw the body plans of the other smaller classes to full-size. The profile should be sited exactly above the deck plan and the body plan can occupy spare space either to the right or left of the profile view. Remember to leave enough room for operation of the planimeter arm so that it will not run off the board during displacement calculations. The L.W.L. will be divided into 10 equal parts and this determines the spacing of the section lines. It is becoming common practice to divide the L.W.L. into 8 equal parts but if this is done intermediate sections should be drawn at the final stage of the design so that the builder will have sufficent information for his building shadows or templates. The spacing of the waterlines is not important but it is usual to use 1-0 in. for model work. In some instances g-in. spacing is adopted as this is often the thickness of timber used by builders who employ ‘bread and butter’ construction. A plank of wood 1-in. thick usually finishes down to 7 in. and using this spacing the builder can take off his plank widths directly from the drawing. The drawing should clearly state the section spacing and the waterline spacings. 1957 “HIGHLANDER’S” WINDWARD ACTION IN A 30 KNOT WIND MODEL RACING YACHTS WU 10 LW.L. Fig. 18 shows the layout for a typical design with a tentative midship section profile and deck plan already drawn. Sometimes a published drawing shows the body plan turned on its side the between profile and deck plans. This is done to save space and reduce cost of the reproductions and is arranged this way when the designer’s original paper is traced. When a designer has his work published he is rather dependent on the accuracy of the tracing made from his original by the publisher for it is not often that a designer has time to do all his own work in this respect. Having put the basic construction lines down on paper the next step is to consider the shape of the midship section. There are a few basic types and an infinite number of variations of them. Fig. 19 shows a variety of types and re zZ 5 0 Ee ws 2 low S 6eé a na . O . they all have their particular merits. Pp The flat floored rather beamy type of section as typified Bow by Glengarry in the ‘A’ class and the old 10 rater types ee Oes BO Gee ine produces a very fast hull when sailed at small angles of eye “a: . : heel. It has great initial stability due to a high metacentric WME Oa oFuS Ba 1 and a potentially high speed. Unfortunately the type has inevitably a high wetted surface and light weather performance suffers somewhat. Furthermore, when heeled the shape of the L.W.L. changes quite considerably and this can mean an increase in resistance. Due to the large ‘In’ wedge the hull tends to lift out of the water on heeling and this offers considerable windage which spoils the windward performance and also reduces the effective lateral area of the keel. Lastly, the stability decreases rapidly at large angles of heel. Thus it can be seen that the ‘scow’ type of section is only satisfactory when sailed in an upright attitude and in moderate to fresh winds. The section therefore is more =) Ba height. The shallow body gives a shallow wave formation y suitable for full-size craft of dinghy type than for models. The narrow, deep-bodied hull, as a contrast, exhibits to a large extent the opposite properties to the scow. The first y advantage of this type is the lower wetted surface for its displacement and a good light weather ability can result. The deepness of the hull however sets up a very deep wave formation when travelling at higher speeds. The resistance of such a hull will prevent it from having the potential high maximum speed of the scow type. The stability of the deep narrow hull is not great at small angles of heel but it increases progressively as the heel increases. The sail-carrying power in high winds is thus quite considerable. Mention has been made of the area of ‘In’ wedges and if a model can be shaped so that it does not lift out of the water on heeling a potentially higher speed to windward can be obtained. This is due of course to the maintenance of a long waterline length rather than a shortening of the L.W.L. – | This can be achieved by having a small ‘In’ wedge and a large ‘Out’ wedge. It is extremely fortunate that this idea LW.L , a TENTATIVE MID. SECTION |} ek yt 4 i; also fits in with the model designers’ wishes to have a narrow beam and flat floor combined with a heavy displacement for the L.W.L. in question. It is no coincidence that the authors’ most successful designs, Sirocco in the 10 rater class and Highlander in the ‘A’ class, employ this type of midship section and both of them have won their respective national championships twice. Fig. 20 shows the mid- ship section of these two yachts superimposed and it is interesting to note that the 10 rater is 1 in. longer on the L.W.L. than the A boat and its displacement is 18 1b. less! Tests in full-size craft have shown that this type of crosssection is not the fastest and this is probably due to the higher speed ratios and the need for greater stability in the model. MODEL RACING YACHTS |_\ ee e 13 ‘ 2 rH POS | | IN 2 Q) z 2 i at a Qq-| 2 I FIGURE 19 L Jaw W, NN SW 29 MODEL RACING YACHTS FIGURE 20 A CLASS HIGHLANDER a“ 10 RATER SIROCCO \ a MIDSHIP SECTIONS OF HIGHLANDER AND SIROCCO SUPERIMPOSED Having drawn a tentative midship section we can now consider the profile of the yacht. Three points are already established, i.e. the L.W.L. endings and the depth of the canoe body at the middle of the hull. Whether or not this is to be the greatest depth of the canoe body has yet to be decided. The points which need to be considered in this respect are whether the designer is going to try and achieve an extremely flat run aft to the hull by pushing the greatest body depth forward. If this is carried to excess it becomes difficult to achieve good hull balance and it may also be difficult to fair the keel into the hull smoothly. The curves towards the bow tend to become steep and it is not easy to obtain a respectable length of forward overhang. It is suggested that for a first design the maximum depth is positioned actually on the midship section. Using a spline which is gently tapered towards one end and with the thick end towards the stern an attractive sweep through the three known points can be drawn. The curvature aft will be less than forward and this gives the desirable flat run to the hull quite automatically. The curve between sections 4 and 6 should be virtually symmetrical and just about on section 1 the spline can be allowed to spring straight so that the bow overhang is not too short. It is almost certain that the beginner will have, quite with- out thinking, drawn the curve so that the yacht is pointing towards the left of the paper. This is not the usual practice of professional architects who almost without exception draw their lines pointing to the right. It is a peculiar fact that the natural thing to do when drawing almost anything is to face the object to the left and as this comes naturally it is suggested that the conventional practice is ignored. When the profile is drawn, however, just turn the paper the other way up and view the drawing from the back. You will be surprised as to how different the yacht looks and you may well be tempted to alter some of the curves! Having swept this first curve through the waterline endings it is necessary to decide on the length of overhang at each end. This will be influenced to some extent by the amount of freeboard and the boldness or otherwise of the sheer curve. The freeboard may be decided by the class rules, as in the International A class, or be without restriction as in 30 the 10 rater and M-class. A good look at other designs will give the beginner a guide as to how much is acceptable. There is no point in having too much freeboard, and remember that a narrow hull needs less freeboard to avoid immersing the deck edge at a given angle of heel compared with a beamy hull. The sheer curve itself is very important aesthetically. Except for the ‘A’ class which insists on a concave curve, a straight line is probably the most logical for a racing machine as it provides height midships where it is needed and limits the height at the ends where it is doing no useful job. The designer must decide how much he is going to let cold logic influence his works and whether he will accept a minute difference in performance for the sake of making his creation beautiful. When the hull is viewed in the solid a straight sheer looks as though the hull has droopy ends and as if the ship has a broken back. It requires quite a pronounced concave curve to avoid this effect and if the beginner wished to make his yacht good looking then he should give more curvature than he really thinks is correct! This applies particularly to the lift towards the bows. Examination of lots of drawings by famous yacht designers is probably the best way of judging the degree of curvature necessary. The other point to watch is that the minimum height of freeboard occurs just forward of the aft waterline ending and this is further aft than one would expect. Drawing a good sheer curve requires a great deal of practice and critical examination. It is best to use a heavy-sectioned spline for the job with the ends forced upwards slightly against the natural spring of the wood. With the sheer curve drawn we can now complete the overhangs at each end. At the bow a Dixon Kemp curve will produce a satisfactory shape but the curve should be in character with the rest of the yacht. It is not good to marry a long spikey overhang with a full sectioned hull and a selection of shapes is shown in Fig. 21. The stern of the yacht can be completed in a variety of ways, none of which has any great influence on performance. These are shown in Fig. 22. The most difficult type is the pointed or canoe stern and, if this is adopted, considerably more rise to the sheer should be given. The deck line is also more difficult to get attractive and once again a close MODEL RACING YACHTS examination of other designers’ work is the best way to learn. William Fife designed the most attractive pointed sterns of all. The other forms of counter profile are easy enough and the model designer does not even need to draw out the developed shape for the builder as does the full-size designer. The keel profile can now be established, bearing in mind what has been written in previous chapters. Make the keel too large in area rather than too small and choose a quadrilateral shape. You can’t go very far wrong if you copy the designs in this book to start with but after the first couple of boats have been built to your drawings and have been satisfactory, you then have the basis to start experimenting. One of the joys of designing your own yachts is the freedom to try out your own ideas. The deck plan will now receive attention and in the first attempt it may help the beginner to draw the complete plan rather than just the half plan usually shown on lines drawings. So far we have only two points to guide the curve, i.e. the bow ending and the width at the midship section, and although we know the length of the stern overhang we have still to decide the width of the counter to establish the ending of the deck plan. The counter width should be kept narrow unless some difficulty in hull balance is not to be avoided. It is fairly obvious that a broad stern will promote large ‘In’ wedges aft and cause a movement of C. of B. on heeling. The maximum width of the deck can either be actually on the midship section which is quite acceptable or somewhat further aft. The usual practice is for this width to be about half way between sections 5 and 6 but this decision is influenced by the designer’s wish either to tend towards the wedge form of hull or the symmetrical form. It is probably helpful in some ways to put the maximum deck beam just aft of the midship section as this will in its turn tend to bring the C. of B. a little aft also and make positioning the C.G. of the ballast less difficult. Using the same tapered spline that we used for the profile the deck curve is now drawn. The thick end of the spline should be towards the stern as before. The most common mistake made is to draw the line too narrow towards the bow and this should be guarded against. The curve should be an even sweep through the point of maximum beam and its width at the forward waterline ending should only be slightly less than at the aft waterline ending. If it has been decided to plan the maximum beam of the deck aft of the midship section it is necessary to indicate on W.L. A, SUITABLE FOR SCOW TYPE OF HULL B. SUITABLE FOR the plan where the maximum beam of intermediate waterlines shall be. This is simply a straight line joining the point of greatest body depth and the greatest beam on deck. The maximum breadth of the waterlines must lie on this line. Similarly the greatest depth of the buttock lines must also be indicated so that a truly fair set of lines is produced. In elevation the line of greatest depths is not straight but starting from the point of maximum body depth it sweeps through a curve whose shape is influenced by the flatness or otherwise of the midship section, the actual position in a fore and aft direction of a particular buttock being determined by the projection of the point where the buttock crosses the maximum beam line in plan. The actual depth of the buttock at that point is defined by the sweep of the buttock line itself. The load waterline is the next important line to be drawn and we only have three fixed points at this stage, i.e. the endings and the width at the midship section. The shapes which can be drawn are of course infinite and in this shape the performance characteristics of the yacht are established. In models we wish to make the hull fairly full in the ends and it has been found that the half angle of entry to the L.W.L. can be as high as 33°—beyond this it is not wise to go and this figure may be taken as somewhat extreme. The angle that the L.W.L. makes with the centre line at the after end can be anything between 45° and 90°. For a first design it is better to keep the angle nearer the small figure, otherwise excessive fullness of the stern will result. Once again a good look at many other designs will indicate the variations possible in waterline shape. At this stage the line should be considered somewhat tentative as it is quite likely that small alterations will be required during the general fairing up process. A complete set of tentative cross-sections are now required and providing that no unusual form of hull is being attempted it is surprising how accurate these can be with some practice. The point to remember is that the character of the midship section is maintained from end to end. The use of the Dixon Kemp curves helps greatly in this but one should guard against becoming a slave to a particular combination of curves. From these tentative sections it is possible to draw the quarter beam buttock and make alterations where necessary to ensure that where lines intersect in plan they do so in the appropriate position in elevation and cross-section. Particulary aft, the quarter beam buttock should be almost parallel to the profile line with only slightly more progressive rise towards the end of the L.W.L. It is now not a bad idea to run the planimeter round the sections and see if the displacement is near to the figure intended. A check can also be made on the ‘In’ and ‘Out’ wedge areas to see if the centre of buoyancy moves to any V SECTION HULL A. TRADITIONAL COUNTER PLWL. C. RATHER SHORT FOR DISPLACEMENT TYPE BOW OVERHANGS FIGURE 21 Cc. CANOE TYPE STERN OVERHANGS B. TRANSOM TYPE D. REVERSE TRANSOM FIGURE 22 31 MODEL RACING YACHTS extent. It will be remarkable if everything is alright but this check will show in which direction alterations need to be made and a lot of tedious re-drawing of lines can be avoided at a later stage. For all intents and purposes the designing stage is now complete. The rest is simply mechanical drawing and it is only necessary to put in sufficient diagonals to intersect the cross-sections not adequately dealt with by the waterlines and buttocks. After say four diagonals are drawn it will be found that the remaining lines fall almost automatically into place. Every designer develops his own preference as to the order in which he draws the various lines for fairing up, in fact some only use the diagonals, ignoring the waterlines and buttocks. Making sure that all is fair and true and at the same time producing the shape intended is a matter of careful patient work and lots of practice. The fin keel presents little difficulty once the shape of longitudinal cross-section is decided and provided a reasonable profile is chosen. It is also worthwhile drawing in some extra vertical cross-sections to help in fairing up and to make calculation of the lead ballast more accurate. The shape of the lead ballast can only be determined by trial and error and the two things which have to be fairly accurate are the total weight and the position of the centre of gravity in a fore and aft direction. The designer can only assume an approximate position for the C. of G. of the hull construction excluding ballast and therefore he is very dependent on the builder to ensure that the final trim of the yacht is correct. Generally speaking with a model carrying a vane steering gear the C.G. of the hull will be slightly aft of the C. of B.: it will therefore follow that the C.G. of the lead ballast must be correspondingly forward of the C. of B The extent to which this applies is of course dependent or the actual position of the C.G., but the point is that if the C.B. is approximately at midship it will be necessary to have the C.G. of the lead further ahead of the C.B. than if the C.B. was say 2 in. aft of midships. The actual weight of ballast is more easily determinec but here again although the designer can specify the con structional weight of the yacht all too often a builder doe: not adhere to them and blames the designer for inaccurat« calculation. It can be assumed that the all-up weights o various class models, excluding lead ballast, lie between thi following figures. M class 10 rater A class 6 to 7 lb. 9 to 10 lb. 13 to 15 lb. The weight and C.G. of the lead is calculated by usin; the trapezoidal rule in just the same way as described fo displacement and C.B. calculations. The density of the leac can be taken as 6:3 oz. per cu. in. and it is wise to cal culate the ballast to be about 2 lb. heavier than the fina assumed figure. This tolerance will then take care of thi following variables: (a) lead varies slightly in density (b) the workmanship of the foundry man (c) the accuracy of the pattern (d) it enables the C.G. to be adjusted to obtain the correc trim of the yacht. It is thoroughly recommended that a model yacht b checked on the measuring tank before the final coats o paint are applied. CHAPTER VII The Sail Plan THE model yacht designer has little difficulty in deciding the type of sail plan to use and the rating rules encourage him in the right direction. The choice is obviously the Bermudan Sloop. One should not, however, presume that this rig will remain the fastest possible in the light of research that is going on at the present time. It will be necessary, though, for the rating rules to be modified before any further worthwhile advance can be made by the model yachtsman and until then we must make the best use of things as they are. The first thing to be considered is the total area available and not a single square inch of sail area should be lost due to carelessness either in design or rigging. Each class rule has its own restriction on allowable sail area and the available total should have been considered at the same time as the decision on L.W.L. and displacement. In the case of the M class the area is fixed at 800 sq. in. measured in a certain way; in the 10 rater the area is reduced as the L.W.L. is increased with no limits set as maximum or minimum and in the A class the formula is somewhat more complicated but again the area is modified by L.W.L. and displacement. The A class also sets a maximum height to the rig which should change the viewpoint of the designer from the normal 32 consideration of ‘what is the maximum sail area I can pu over this type and size of hull’ to ‘what is the best hull I cai put under this sail plan ?’ This statement leads us directly int: the discussion of height of rig and what is commonly calle: aspect ratio. This is a widely misused term and we prefer t refer to luff/foot ratio which is the number of times th foot will divide into the luff. It is generally accepted that a tall narrow sail will hav greater driving force to windward than a low long foote: sail, area for area, and whereas some years ago a sail o luff/foot ratio of 2 was common, ratios of 3:5 to 4-0 ar now quite acceptable. One must not go wild on this heigh business, however, because for down-wind sailing a squar sail is probably the most satisfactory! Therefore one ca see that when the rating rule fixes the maximum height of rig the designer must decide on the optimum luff/foot rati and settle the area in that way. Of course, if he knows the his design will be used mainly in light air he will allow th area to be larger even though slightly less efficient than if h knows that the boat will be used where strong winds pre dominate. In this case he can cut the sail area by reducin the length of the foot without great loss of driving force an FIGURE 24 FIGURE 23 SAIL PLAN OF ‘A’CLASS \ AT 1475 SQ” \ , AND 1600 SQ. \ BASE OF FORE-SAIL _ \ \ . INCREASES FROM 21 TO 23” . AND MAIN-SAIL FROM 23:2’ TO 27-5” ti — / NORMAL AND ULTRA HIGH ASPECT RATIO MAIN SAILS. BOTH SAILS ARE EQUAL AREA AS MEASURED BY RULE AND HAVE SAME CURVATURE IN ROACH ULTRA HIGH SAIL GAINS AN EXTRA 38SQ° FREE M.R.Y.-—3 33 MODEL RACING YACHTS NOTE STRAIGHT LINES LEACH BETWEEN BAT TENS TO MUST NOT CURL AVOID CURLING a FIGURE 25 FIGURE 26 provide a long powerful hull to cope with the rougher condi- of the sail. One often sees the leach curling and thus disturbing the natural flow of the air as shown in Fig. 25. This is hopeless and a sail which does this should be thrown away. One of the reasons for this happening can be greed over the free area and it might be a good thing if sails were cut so that the back is a straight line between the battens as shown in Fig. 26. In these days of sailing with loose-footed sails and very tight kicking straps a heavy strain is put on the leach and the natural thing is for it to curl if the shape is exaggerated. The next question to vex the designer is to proportion the areas of jib and mainsail correctly. The use of the 85 per cent of the fore triangle measurement for the jib does tend to lead one into making the jib as big as possible so that the greatest advantage is got out of the rule. Furthermore, as the size of spinnaker is based on the fore triangle dimensions, a big jib also means a big spinnaker. Now whilst it is probable that, years ago, jibs were not big enough, the author is now satisfied that the proportions illustrated in various designs in this book give the optimum results. Experience has shown that very large jibs cannot be carried successfully by model yachts. The large spinnaker is also a snare and delusion and a properly cut small sail is better than a big bag hanging on the mast. It is also a mistake to try and fill too much of the fore triangle with sail, particularly at the head. It must be obvious that the jib has a considerable effect on the way that the air flows across the mainsail. It can either be helpful or harmful depending on the cut and setting of the jib. Ideally the air should flow off the jib, through the gap between the leach of the jib and luff of the mainsail and tions. In this way the sail area of successful A class yachts can vary from 1,475 sq. in. to 1,650 sq. in. To wander outside these limits makes the yacht too much of a single purpose vessel. In Fig. 23 can be seen the superimposed sail plan of two A class yachts. In the 10 rater and M class there is no limit to height except in the fore triangle. The law of increased efficiency with increase of height is one of diminishing returns and the designer must be careful if he wishes to exceed a luff/foot ratio of 4-0. As the height increases so does the length of the mast and therefore its weight increases and so does the height of its centre of gravity. This can have a serious effect on the sail carrying power of the hull and a increase in luff/foot ratio can result in a reduction of overall performance. On the other hand, assuming the amount of free un-measured sail area hidden in the leach of the sail is limited by a 3-5 in. roach, the increase in free area by having a very high rig can be considerable. Fig. 24 shows a normal 10 rater sail plan for a boat of 55-0 L.W.L. and superimposed is an extremely high sail plan of the same area as measured by the rule. The increase in free area amounts to 38 sq. in. As far as the author is aware such a high rig has never been used in the 10 rater class but in the U.S.A. some Marbleheads have been so fitted. The stability question is one which requires careful thought but developments in this direction may be worth pursuing with 10 rater of 60 in. L.W.L. and 35 Ib. displacement. Whilst discussing the ‘free’ area available in a sail we should remember that the battens are limited in length by the rule and this prevents too much curvature being put into the back 34 MODEL RACING YACHTS across the leeward surface of the main in a smooth uninterrupted manner. If the gap is too narrow or the angle between the jib and mainsail incorrect the air off the jib can flow into the luff of the main, causing backwinding and considerable loss of drive. Fig. 27 shows this situation. If things are arranged correctly the jib can exercise a very beneficial effect on the mainsail and in the past this effect has been likened to the slot on an aeroplane wing, which stabilises the airflow and delays stalling. This analogy should not be taken too literally, but it does help to illustrate the point. One should remember that, contrary to usual belief, it is difficult to have the gap or slot big enough and one of the reasons is that a normal racing hull does not have sufficient beam for proper sheeting of the jib. If the rules would allow such a thing it would be helpful to move the luff of the jib to windward! It will also be fairly obvious that if the actual sail area is taken close up into the top of the fore triangle it will not be possible, no matter how the jib is sheeted, to form an adequate gap to release the air. It is bound to be very turbulent and backwind the mainsail. Therefore this is another case where greed for sail area can in fact reduce the performance of the yacht. Unfortunately no one can yet be sure just how big the gap should be, but it is quite likely that existing rigs could be modified in this respect to some advantage. When the wind blows on to a sail it causes the material to bend and form an arched surface. This is in many ways similar to the curved surface of an aeroplane wing and we know that the greatest propulsive effort is derived from the leeward surface of the sail when the velocity of the air stream will be greatest. In order to obtain the highest efficiency the camber of the sail should be greatest when the wind is light and least when the wind velocity is high. The sail maker _—<> =< BACKWINDING OF MAINSAIL DUE TO JIB FIGURE 27 bered that different types of yacht can carry different amounts of flow in the same wind strength. For example a 14-ft. International dinghy can have proportionately much greater flow than say an International 12-metre, the big difference between the two yachts being their angle of leeway. A very close winded 12-metre must have sails which are comparatively flat. This same distinction may be made between model A class yachts and 10 rater models. The 10 rater can have greater flow in this case, but the difference exists also within a particular class. For example, Highlander and Vital Spark, illustrated in this book, can have fuller sails than any other A class shown. WALTER JONES’ FAMOUS ‘A’ CLASS ‘‘SHALIMAR’’ AT FLEETWOOD therefore cuts the sails accordingly and to a very large extent indeed the yacht designer is dependent on the sailmaker’s skill and the owner’s willingness or otherwise to spend money on a number of different sails of the same size. It is perhaps no longer good enough for the designer to decide sail dimensions and then leave the rest to the sailmaker. The yacht designer should not only show the outline shape of the sail on his plans but should design the sail to produce what he thinks is the right camber under various wind strengths. The principle way of obtaining camber or ‘flow’ in a sail is to put a certain amount of correct curvature in the luff and foot. In the ease of loose-footed sails it is only necessary to consider the luff. It is deciding this curve wherein lies the sail-maker’s ‘art’. When considering sails for racing models, we without doubt will be using proofed Terylene which virtually has no stretch and there seems to be no reason why the sail should not be cut out over a solid pattern made exactly to the shape desired by the designer. This pattern or mould could be built up from thick cardboard templates with the spaces filled with plaster of paris. The whole design responsibility would then be on the designer, which is just as it should be. One can visualise all the best A’ boats being equipped with at least 3 full top suits with different flow characteristics, 2 second suits and one each no. 3 and no. 4 suits. The spinnakers would be designed in the same way and a set would comprise 2 full-size balloons, 1 small balloon, 1 large flat and 1 small flat for heavy quartering winds. To go with all these sails would be an accurate wind velocity meter so that the skipper can know for sure just when to change from one sail to another. Before leaving this question of flow it should be remem- 35 PART TWO CHAPTER VIII The 10 Rater Class Yacht THROUGHOUT the history of organised model yacht racing the 10-rater has enjoyed a steady popularity. This is probably due to the simple rules which govern the class, avoiding complication of design and measurement for rating purposes. The rule produces a model of convenient size although the modern boats have become rather heavy for easy transportation. The smaller M class may have prevented the 10rater from growing as large as it might have done and this is a great pity because the 10-rater is quite superior as a racing yacht in its sailing and handling characteristics. The only JOHN LEWIS WITH ‘‘HERALD’’, A TWIN KEEL EXPERIMENT WITH A 60 IN. L.W.L. TO HIS DESIGN BUILT BY K. JONES OF BIRKENHEAD disadvantage is that it will not go inside the average family motor car; on the other hand a roof rack is cheap enough. The 10-rater rule was devised in the later part of the nineteenth century by the famous naval architect Dixon Kemp. He saw the significance of the ratio of sail area to waterline length and expressed this in the form L.W.L. x S.A. _ 49 6,000. Thus if the L.W.L. is increased the S.A. must be reduced in order to balance the equation. Naturally Dixon Kemp had full-size yachts in mind rather than models and a large number of ‘Raters’, as they were called, were produced over the years. As usual yacht designers tried, and succeeded, in cheating the rule by making the measured L.W.L. bear little relationship to the actual L.W.L. when the yacht was heeled a few degrees. This was achieved by giving the yacht very long overhangs and furthermore their profile was often concave. Fig. 2 shows a typical rater type of about 1910. Some very extreme types were built and before long too much seaworthiness was sacrificed together with other desirable qualities and the yachts also became very expensive. Lightness of construction and annual obsolescence sounded the death knell of the type. Fortunately the model yachtsman’s adaptation of the rule prevented undesirable developments and the very fact that model yachts have to cope with more severe conditions than their larger counterparts has kept the class healthy. Today the model 10-rater is an extremely sound and seamanlike craft. The years of development that have gone into the class show that eccentricity of design and extremeness in any direction just do not pay in competition work. What is required is a good sensible hull shape of maximum displacement and until startling development takes place in sail plans the L.W.L. is likely to remain in the 55 in. region. Unfortunately the 10-rater class has not received the attention of the naval architect in the same way as has the International A class and it is not possible to trace a steady line of progress similar to that class. This is not to say that the 10-rater has not progressed for it most certainly has. There has been an increase in displacement, L.W.L. and speed over the years but considering how free the rule is this progress has been remarkably slow. There have been isolated designs of revolutionary aspect from time to time, but none of them have proved as satisfactory as the conventional 30/35 1b. displacement type with good balance. There comes to mind the copies of the Uffa Fox Flying Fifteen boats and one of these has won the championship under favourable conditions. There have 36 7 \ = Ore SH = H f LIE Yi; Ee |e s (B1OTRA2FEYI9LPGUCW0) 12:0” DRAUGHT ” “ “ , e ermIiesiYe=0ALBS.3ao-75sDIPSACoEMeNTe t i e T c a l o a u SeSae e heS teabsc a y MODEL RACING YACHTS (‘A“DLER1BTOP|FSIVJGHNC0U”), 1CNHA&T9MIPO586L 37 MODEL RACING YACHTS MODEL RACING YACHTS PHOTOGRAPHS ON OPPOSITE PAGE, TOP LEFT, ‘‘BLUE NYMPH’’, AN ULSTER BOAT TO THE PRIEST ‘‘BLUE HAZE’”’ 10 R. DESIGN y WHICH ENJOYED MODERATE SUCCESS IN COMPETITION. TOP RIGHT IS AN EARLY LEWIS 10 DESIGN AT A 55 IN. L.W.L. BOTTOM, NO. 1438 IS THE IMMENSELY SUCCESSFUL “SIROCCO”’ DESIGN BY LEWIS WHICH WON THE CHAMPIONSHIP IN 1956 AND 1958. 1506 IS ‘‘BINTANG”’ BY PRIEST, ANOTHER SUCCESSFUL COMPETITION MODEL. been others throughout the years and the author must admit to some unusual and unsuccessful designs. The 10rater has an appeal to the designer with wild ideas but it is rarely that such a designer can settle down seriously to developing a trend and draw reasonable conclusions. There have been many flashes in the pan and no doubt some good ideas have fallen by the wayside due to lack of development or misapplication. The author has probably designed and built as many 10raters as anyone and has concentrated on their development for some 15 years. There is still a lot of work to be done but I will try to set down my findings during that period. Before the 1939 war I sailed quite a lot but was only in my teens and did not get down to serious design work although ideas were beginning to form. During my service in the Fleet Air Arm I was able to study theoretical naval architecture and it became obvious to me that the 10-rater would be the ideal craft to prove statements made by the people and also try out ideas of my own. ABOVE, DICK PRIEST WITH ‘‘TORNADO”’, 60 IN. L.W.L., 27 LBS DISPLACEMENT, 103 IN. BEAM AND 1,000 SQ. INS. OF SAIL. THIS BOAT WAS RUNNER-UP IN THE 1953 CHAMPIONSHIP AND THE WINNER IN 1955. LEFT IS ‘‘MOONSTONE’”’, THE FIRST TWIN KEEL EXPERIMENT FROM THE LEWIS BOARD. BELOW, ‘‘TRIPLANE’’, BUILT TO THE LINES OF A FLYING FIFTEEN, WHICH WON THE CHAMPIONSHIP UNDER ITS OWN CONDITIONS BUT WHICH WAS NOT SUCCESSFUL IN ALL WEIGHTS OF WIND. As soon as possible after my release I designed and built a series of 10-raters, each of which had some particular design feature I wished to observe. None of these designs however was very experimental except that I was pushing the L.W.L. up from the conventional 48 in. towards my goal of 60 in.; 54 in. L.W.L. was reached without much happening except that the yachts were faster and I had to stand a certain amount of derision from the experts who declared that 55-in. L.W.L. was much too long. They had not noticed Terylene coming over the horizon and as soon as sails were made in this new material a 55-in. L.W.L. was quite the thing. Having reached the 55 L.W.L. mark I started to be rather more radical in hull form and in some designs deliberately exaggerated a feature so that its faults would show up more clearly. Thus we discovered just how full the bow sections can be and how important the bow overhang is whereas the stern overhang can be cut off without loss of performance. The need for plenty of displacement to give power to windward became obvious. Hull form became a matter of producing this heavy displacement with 39 MODEL RACING YACHTS iw | Zz fe) ri | Zz fe) od wn fe) [4 = an fe) | | | a f] uu 1 if | +Z | y | s a ee sa |) 22 FIGURE 5 BODY PLANS OF “MOONSTONE” (TOP) AND “HERALD” a \ WL3 L.W.L WL5 , TM ee 700-91 WL6 0:9 Ist 48 1 ,0-61 ‘pag — “pu 2 ,0S-81 .0O'Bl Ue 3rd FIGURE 3 40) 71-75" 5750" 2nd. 64-50" 4th 50-50" al ~~ too IN Lo wo oo